Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[Bevab]

I never said that I was too helpful, I'm trying to help the town best, I told you earlier that I don't know much about Harry Potter.

Still you don't believe me after my character claim..

And who on earth silenced Matt121?

 

[ARay]

Limiting, and silencing could be both the same person of mafia.
And your FOS'ing of me is rather suspicious.

I doubt, the same person will have two power roles. Once again the balance is totally weird if something like this happens.
Its interesting how bevab is still under suspicion even after his role claim. While I do support that an eye should be kept on each and every member. Bevab can certainly still be mafia. But we also need to turn to other suspicious members and also pressure them.

It will help attain more information which will be more useful down the road, especially when we have some more townies to help out to give multiple views.
Lynch: Varun
He is way too quiet for my liking. Maybe this will be an incentive for him to post.

 

[Chewie]

Varun has actually posted more than Matt, BKB, Aditya and Bevab

 

[CG123]

Bevab has looked a bit dodgy, but in saying that he did last game as well, and turned out to be town. Chewie does have a perfectly valid point, and Bevab has straight away come out and gone FOS on Chewie.

Following on from that this could be a noob question/point, but how could Bevab have a post restriction on the first day when that's when the game started? And then he later came out and said that it was just for that day, it does seem a bit weird to me as there was no time before then for someone to PM in to Chez who they want to silence.

 

[ARay]

Following on from that this could be a noob question/point, but how could Bevab have a post restriction on the first day when that's when the game started? And then he later came out and said that it was just for that day, it does seem a bit weird to me as there was no time before then for someone to PM in to Chez who they want to silence.

That is actually an interesting point. I know I have not considered this point.
Bevab how did get a post restriction before any night role could be done?

 

[hedger_14]

What a waste. Back to my ████ way of playing the game and I might live longer...

Funny how the 2 mods of the previous game were killed first.

 

[ARay]

What a waste. Back to my ████ way of playing the game and I might live longer...

Funny how the 2 mods of the previous game were killed first.

I really would not suggest you to do that. Like I said, its better for the town people to be vocal than quiet. Of course we have new players, so new townies keep quiet in order to survive. But what they don't understand is the best defense against mafia is to speak up and discuss. If every townie looks like an equal threat, life for mafia becomes more difficult.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Damn it, 'Evil looking potions teacher' was someone with a role of a cop maybe. Big big loss. Also, anybody noticed this?

Also a bit weird they went for hedger and not some of the more intense discussion makers.

If I was a mafia, I would have tried to kill off Aray, simply because he is very active in the discussions and good at analyzing the situation. Eventually he would figure out who the mafia are and thus he would be one of the first I would kill at night. Weird that they did not go for him, suspicious even

This could be either way. Mark indirectly wanting us to believe he is clearly not a mafia or maybe this can be a valid reason. I mean Ray can also be a part of the evil team.

 

[Bevab]

That is actually an interesting point. I know I have not considered this point.
Bevab how did get a post restriction before any night role could be done?

Please ask Mr.Spin for that, he was the one who sent me a PM on day 1 stating that I can't post much. Spin randomly generates the no. of posts I can make in each phase. If I'm close to my post restriction, Spin will send me a PM stating I'm close.

And Mark's post is very funny, considering he is trying to help the mafia. He could be an individual.

FOS:Mark, Varun

 

[Aditya]

We lost Snape. I'm suspicious of Bevab, at first place his role claim didn't really impress me. I agree, it's only his 2nd mafia game but doing a quick search on google
can let him know about mafia roles. So, it's not a big deal that maybe he is mafia and false role claimed to not get lynched.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Look, I don't think Bevab can come up with such a role claim if it was false. Either he is helped by his mafia members if he is a mafia that is. If not, then I believe him.

 

[Varun]

Ughh, Snape's dead. "Evil looking man", he might be the miller.

Regarding me, I don't have that much posts because of time of coming online. The time I'm online, most of the members are mostly offline and lot of discussion has already taken place.

Harry Potter Mafia - Day 3! - Page 13 - PlanetCricket Forums

Here another instance when I commented on my agony, I was the only active guy there at that time.

Plus the lynches, Paki was already lynched till I came unless I would have changed my lynch (or no lynch whatever). I was not that sure about Matt, and then CG had again already hammered voted him when I came on.

I hope that clears me, I'll post my opinions on the writeup and the following sequences in a little while. If needed, I can role claim - but that's too dangerous for me.

----------

Again, only few people are active when I am.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm there, chill.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Regarding me, I don't have that much posts because of time of coming online. The time I'm online, most of the members are mostly offline and lot of discussion has already taken place.

Harry Potter Mafia - Day 3! - Page 13 - PlanetCricket Forums

Here another instance when I commented on my agony, I was the only active guy there at that time.

Plus the lynches, Paki was already lynched till I came unless I would have changed my lynch (or no lynch whatever). I was not that sure about Matt, and then CG had again already hammered voted him when I came on.

I hope that clears me, I'll post my opinions on the writeup and the following sequences in a little while. If needed, I can role claim - but that's too dangerous for me.

----------

Again, only few people are active when I am.

That's a very weak excuse. Me, User, Callum, ARay, Chewie are all online atm. And that link you posted about your post, both BKB and User were online (atleast) since they both posted at a a similar time to yours.

And you could lynch anyone who you thought were suspicious - no idea why you thought you had to jump on the paki and matt bandwagon. Like I said, I didn't suspect you until I tried to find all of Hedger's posts. I'm not convinced you're a townie.

I trust Bevab's role-claim. For now, I believe he's a townie.

----------

Also, FOS: Chewie
Reason: Trying to defend Varun while at the same time trying to bring the suspcion back on to Bevab

 

[CG123]

BTW I hammered Matt, not Paki.

The Matt hammer was after a lot of waiting, so I'm sure you would have come on some time around when the lynching of him was happening.

----------

That was in response to:

and then CG had again already hammered voted him when I came on.