End Game Mafia returns

[Yash.]

The I don't have a clue, but have a look at those two doesn't sit well with me ATM.

Care to mention why so?

 

[asprin]

Without a night kill action, the only hope is that the town had a PR role too. It certainly ought to as it's hard to fathom a setup without one.

Going by the number of players in the game, I'm leaning 1 mafia, 1 sk and 4 townies. My feeling is that in such a small setup, the mafia would be too strong if there's two of them.

 

[RUDI]

Care to mention why so?

With no information about how many townies have night roles... I don’t think we have much to work with, considering there hasn’t been much discussion or a kill.

However, @RUDI and @asprin need to talk more.

I'm leaning 1 mafia, 1 sk and 4 townies

Two night killing roles and four townies seem a bit unfair. TV would have had to include an investigating role also.

 

[CerealKiller]

Without a night kill action, the only hope is that the town had a PR role too. It certainly ought to as it's hard to fathom a setup without one.

Going by the number of players in the game, I'm leaning 1 mafia, 1 sk and 4 townies. My feeling is that in such a small setup, the mafia would be too strong if there's two of them.

Where do you deduce that from? There was extensive analysis of the writeup, largely to the conclusion that there are two Mafias

 

[zwarrior]

With no information about how many townies have night roles... I don’t think we have much to work with, considering there hasn’t been much discussion or a kill.

However, @RUDI and @asprin need to talk more.

Since it's a closed setup, we will not know how many townies will have night roles.

I am the most inexperienced among us. I have no idea how to proceed this game. Please you guys start discussion. I will join.

Just see how others post and if you get a suspicion on the way they post or if you have different opinions, then you can reply to it. Basically, to get more details, we need to post more. Otherwise we won't get clues.[DOUBLEPOST=1605271478][/DOUBLEPOST]

Where do you deduce that from? There was extensive analysis of the writeup, largely to the conclusion that there are two Mafias

Even I believe there is 1 mafia and 1 serial killer/hitman. I had posted my analysis 2 pages back. But Jack said the writeup is mix of flavour and interpretation. So, we can't really analyze and tell there are 2 mafias or 1 mafia and 1 sk and so on... right.

 

[zwarrior]

Two night killing roles and four townies seem a bit unfair. TV would have had to include an investigating role also.

I am leaning to this now. Great point. I missed to read this post while replying above.

 

[asprin]

Where do you deduce that from?

A combination of guess work and intuition. Doesn't have to be set in stone, so take it with a pinch of salt.

Two night killing roles and four townies seem a bit unfair

By townies I meant including PRs. Total 4 towns + 2 bad guys. Number of PR roles at play is anybody's guess.

 

[CerealKiller]

Trying to get the ball rolling, so we don’t waste another day.
Lynch : asprin

Seems like he is trying to walk on eggshells. Asked one question of Yash at the beginning, the rest is responding to others, or posts about the setup. No investigation.

 

[asprin]

Trying to get the ball rolling, so we don’t waste another day.
Lynch : asprin

Seems like he is trying to walk on eggshells. Asked one question of Yash at the beginning, the rest is responding to others, or posts about the setup. No investigation.

To be fair, there hasn't been much to dig into. I'm also not sure what purpose does a pressure lynch serve as I (as the one who has the lynch on) very well know that you put it there for "x" reason but not because I'm confirmed scum.

 

[CerealKiller]

To be fair, there hasn't been much to dig into. I'm also not sure what purpose does a pressure lynch serve as I (as the one who has the lynch on) very well know that you put it there for "x" reason but not because I'm confirmed scum.

You could’ve still tried to question people?

 

[RUDI]

Going on @Ashutosh. theory IRL @asprin must be one of the two that fatally wounded or killed Till Valhalla I mean, Till Valhalla always want to lynch asprin [DOUBLEPOST=1605282660,1605282275][/DOUBLEPOST]

two Mafias

Highly doubt this Talha, in just about any setup you never get a mafia team both with killing abilities.

Honestly think this:

1 x Mafia - night kill ability
1 x Assassin - night kill ability
1 x Town Cop - Investigate one player at night
3 x Vanilla townies

 

[Yash.]

I am the most inexperienced among us. I have no idea how to proceed this game. Please you guys start discussion. I will join.

This could be a genuine reason, but I’m leaning it towards being an anti-town role. It would a good move for the Mafia as he can easily wait and minimise chances of any slip ups.

 

[CerealKiller]

Highly doubt this Talha, in just about any setup you never get a mafia team both with killing abilities.

Honestly think this:

1 x Mafia - night kill ability
1 x Assassin - night kill ability
1 x Town Cop - Investigate one player at night
3 x Vanilla townies

Could be. We'll see, i guess.
@Ashutosh. waiting and seeing what others say is going to make you look suspicious, in the absence of any other leads. What you need to do is ask questions, even if they don’t make sense. At least they would lead to people talking. Try to pick up things in what others are saying.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Going on @Ashutosh. theory IRL @asprin must be one of the two that fatally wounded or killed Till Valhalla I mean, Till Valhalla always want to lynch asprin [DOUBLEPOST=1605282660,1605282275][/DOUBLEPOST]
Highly doubt this Talha, in just about any setup you never get a mafia team both with killing abilities.

Honestly think this:

1 x Mafia - night kill ability
1 x Assassin - night kill ability
1 x Town Cop - Investigate one player at night
3 x Vanilla townies

I agree with this. Town must have a PR. Without a PR, there is no use of night 1.

This could be a genuine reason, but I’m leaning it towards being an anti-town role. It would a good move for the Mafia as he can easily wait and minimise chances of any slip ups.

Could be. We'll see, i guess.
@Ashutosh. waiting and seeing what others say is going to make you look suspicious, in the absence of any other leads. What you need to do is ask questions, even if they don’t make sense. At least they would lead to people talking. Try to pick up things in what others are saying.

I was watching the thread and was thinking what to post. I didn't want to post anything which will create problem for me in future.

 

[CerealKiller]

I was watching the thread and was thinking what to post. I didn't want to post anything which will create problem for me in future.

I was giving you a tip about how to participate more
If you had to give me a list of people, from the most suspicious to the least, what would it be?