Newbie Ocean's Mafia - Endgame (Town Win)

[AngryPixel]

I strongly think bevab is mafia thats why i'm lynching him. But you never know, Bevab sometimes plays as poorly as i've in last few mafia games . So he could either be stupid townie or brilliant mafia .
I would push your lynch on swacker but it takes 5 votes to hammer and if none of you or BKB are mafia and Swacker happens to be a townie then it leaves him open to quick hammer if i lynch him too before he can put up a defense. Thus i'm avoiding lynching him for now.

 

[RPHKR]

@AP - No lynch? You think that the day phase should be skipped?

----------

On the other hand you have been busy targeting people at random. Now you see an opportunity to push on a bandwagon on Swacker and me defending another townie. So you thought why not divide townies and made them accuse each other. That smells like mafia from a mile away.

You may be right, but we need the solid reason behind your vote to "No lynch".

----------

Swacker is the most suspicious guy now, he would have played poor as this is his first game.

 

[AngryPixel]

Did you skipped the last page or what?
I have a lynch on Bevab. And gave my explanation for not lynching Swacker even though he's played poorly.

 

[Themer]

Quick note on who feels town and who I'm unsure of:
Barmy - town
BKB1991 - ??
RPHKR - ??
Bevab - Town
swacker - ??
AngryPixel - town
Aditya - ??
hedger_14 - town

Shamelessly copied off barmy. What I think I know so far.

----------

Oh and Lynch : Swacker

 

[RPHKR]

Votes so far,

Day 1

Me - Aditya, No lynch
User2010 - Bevab
Themer - RPHKR, No lynch
swacker - User2010
barmyarmy - TheRock
TheRock - swacker
BKB1991 - No lynch
Bevab - No lynch

Day 2

Me - AngryPixel, Aditya
BKB1991 - TheRock, RPHKR, swacker
Themer - Aditya
Bevab - TheRock
AngryPixel - TheRock, Bevab
hedger_14 - RPHKR
barmyarmy - swacker

The only guy yet to FOS or lynch someone is Aditya.
Lynch: Aditya

 

[Haarithan]

Vote count

swacker (3) - barmyarmy, BKB1991, Themer
RPHKR (1) - hedger_14
Bevab (1) - AngryPixel
Aditya (1) - RPHKR

With 9 alive, it requires 5 votes for a hammer.

 

[barmyarmy]

Think Swacker needs to offer a defence or even a claim at this point.

 

[hedger_14]

Not going to bother putting any more votes on Swacker but his posts have been very suspicious and especially calling my first post a stalling tactic, I have no idea why that would be thought as a stalling tactic.

And sorry but has AngryPixel claimed? Cause it's not often people say he's a townie

Anyway, my lynch on RPHKR stays as I don't feel like he has convinced me enough that he's not mafia.

 

[Bevab]

I strongly think bevab is mafia thats why i'm lynching him. But you never know, Bevab sometimes plays as poorly as i've in last few mafia games . So he could either be stupid townie or brilliant mafia .
I would push your lynch on swacker but it takes 5 votes to hammer and if none of you or BKB are mafia and Swacker happens to be a townie then it leaves him open to quick hammer if i lynch him too before he can put up a defense. Thus i'm avoiding lynching him for now.

And you're reasons? You've got to have a valid point.

You seem to be desperate to lynch me.

 

[BKB1991]

I am not a fan of your reasons AP, you tend to thing anyone who has fosed or lynched you is mafia.

Though after going through your posts, you havent really pointed strong fingers at anyone, and seem to being playing too cautiously. Way I see it, you could possibly be a clueless townie or a cautious mafia.

 

[RPHKR]

I don't feel like he has convinced me enough that he's not mafia.

I'm asking for a good reason to lynch me. Yeah, In the mafia game, we must not be naive. I'm too not convinced of those who have not role claimed yet.

----------

My lynch on Aditya as he is the only person who have not lynched or FOSed someone.
Take a look at this post.

 

[Aditya]

Alright, I read through the discussion, finally. The member who looks most suspicious to me is, RPHKR. As Hedger pointed out, he has been just going after inactive members and even though he has been pretty active in the thread he hasn't really helped the town in a great way rather than just going after inactive members. He hasn't really analyzed the game whatsoever and until (Themer?) pointed out about my inactivity he didn't post anything about my inactivity. It's time that he posts something more useful in the town's favor just going after inactive members isn't really gonna help.

I see that there isn't much discussion going on and as my role can easily be recognized while I lynch someone I'd just post about it now, I'm the double voter.

 

[barmyarmy]

Assuming Aditya is DV I reckon two of Swacker, RPHKR and BKB1991 are mafia. There's one post in particular from AP that convinces me that he's town.

----------

Just to add that I was using Themer's list and I'm not convinced Bevab is town yet.

 

[Bevab]

Has Themer character claimed yet?

 

[barmyarmy]

I don't think anyone has character claimed yet...