Newbie Ocean's Mafia - Endgame (Town Win)

[Haarithan]

AP, in case of a typo, just re-post saying for example:

In case you spelled swacker as swocker, then just re-post:

*swocker -> swacker

 

[swacker]

I'd like to believe that I would offer the same help no matter what side I'm on. Mafia is a lot like Magic in that you need to encourage the community. Letting you play blind, no matter what side you're on or what side I'm on, doesn't necessarily help either of us.

The point of the game isn't actually to survive.

 

[RPHKR]

I guess you chose to ignore that just to make a comment for the sake of commenting or hopelessly trying to divert the attention away from you

Away from me? Good. I've role-claimed. It's your wish to believe me or not. I can't defend me anymore.

 

[RPHKR]

@AP - What is the thing you don't believe in my role-claim and description? or What makes you suspicious of me?

 

[barmyarmy]

@Haari - yes please on the extension

----------

Just to justify that we obviously are going to lynch one of the three mentioned; I just want to know why Themer favours swacker.
Can we have 2 or 3 more hours? The point of the game isn't to close a day when there is activity.

 

[Haarithan]

Just to justify that we obviously are going to lynch one of the three mentioned; I just want to know why Themer favours swacker.
Can we have 2 or 3 more hours? The point of the game isn't to close a day when there is activity.

Yeah don't worry. You all have until Hedger comes online the following day to make a decision, given he's in a different time zone. Also given that Themer comes here from work past deadline, I thought it'd be fair if the time was extended by atleast 6 more hours. Will see when Hedger turns up and yeah you all are guaranteed atleast 6 more hours from this post.

 

[Bevab]

Hmmm............

My exams are nearing up. I'll let you know if I want a replacement, as I can't be sure of that once they arrive. BTW, no problems with my activity, right?

 

[barmyarmy]

How soon are they?

 

[AngryPixel]

Hmmm............

My exams are nearing up. I'll let you know if I want a replacement, as I can't be sure of that once they arrive. BTW, no problems with my activity, right?

Come on Bevab. Man up. Who has ever cared about exams at PC anyway.

 

[BKB1991]

So whats the consensus? Both claims could equally be right or wrong imo

 

[AngryPixel]

*shudders. Thor in the house.... Hide everyone. He's watching

----------

lol. Just realized he's not in the game

 

[Themer]

@Themer - reasons?

Now why did Themer lynch Swacker?

We have to lynch someone as we're mostly agreed after biding our time first day. The reason I've gone for Swacker is that I just can't see a Beloved Princess being in a game this size. One of the big 20 odd player game its a good role to have in the mix but when we've only got a few people playing I fail to see how it wouldn't make the game unbalanced slightly what with us losing a whole day.

It's highly possible that RPHKR is lying about his role as well but realistically how likely is it for their to be a miller in a game this size? Quite likely. Yet no one has counter claimed. Comparing that to the likelihood of a Beloved Princess?

Obviously we should be a lot more cautious about lynching him due to the claim but I still think its probably worth the risk. I just can't see a Beloved Princess in the match I'm afraid.

Despite all this it is worth mentioning that Aditya has still contributed very little to the game whilst pushing RPKHR to the brink of being hammered without really giving an in depth reason as to why.

 

[AngryPixel]

I think we have more to lose if we lynch Swacker and he turns out to be a townie. Coz it would skip a day. Thus we would lose 3 townies at max. If RPHKR gets lynched and turns out to be a townie then we would just lose 2 townies at max. So...
Lynch: RPHKR

 

[Themer]

Scratch that last bit. Aditya's claimed DV hasn't he? Forgot about that.

 

[AngryPixel]

Unlynch: RPHKR
Reason: Themer posted something noteworthy. Gotta go through the thread once again

----------

Scratch that last bit. Aditya's claimed DV hasn't he? Forgot about that.

Yeah but Swacker is new in the game thus i doubt he knows about the Beloved Prince role but then again as Barmy said, one of his mafia buddies might have suggested him that.