World's most Over-rated and Under-rated player!

[gold639]

Langer scored 215 against New Zealand last week,and was that luck?

 

[hbkjai]

Yeah.. lol.. no seriously that dude's definitely the luckiest batsman ever.. n I've watched enough innings to confidently say that.. bad decisions.. dropped catches.. more edges than normal for any batsman.. He certainly does NOT deserve 20 centuries!! Unfortunately that can never be changed so.. Still as I said good on him for making it count.. And sure.. the NZ attack was threatening right?

 

[MWaugh]

Warne over-rated.......

hmmmmm, he's just the world record holder with a record of 539 wickets @ 25.58, Strike Rate of 59.8, 28 five fors (innings), Eight 10 fors (matches). All of his wickets have come against top quality sides, none of that Zimbabwe and Bangladesh rubbish. He doesn't bowl 40-50% of the sides overs, but has to share his wickets with other world class bowlers (Gillespie and McGrath). Come back from a shoulder injury, and a 12 month ban, plus several other injuries, lots of off-field dramas, and still takes a bag.

[sarcasm] Very overated Nik [/sarcasm]

plus the aussie ground staff dont go out of their way to make pitches to serve him best "murali" *cough*

 

[ZoraxDoom]

Overated: Akhtar, Laxman.....
Underrated: Agarkar, Rafique.....

 

[greencarrot2]

Overated: Harmison
Underated: Hoggard

Simple as that

 

[nik]

i think caddick was underrated! ps. what has happened to caddick?!

 

[angryangy]

Yeah.. lol.. no seriously that dude's definitely the luckiest batsman ever.. n I've watched enough innings to confidently say that.. bad decisions.. dropped catches.. more edges than normal for any batsman.. He certainly does NOT deserve 20 centuries!! Unfortunately that can never be changed so.. Still as I said good on him for making it count.. And sure.. the NZ attack was threatening right?

Sure and he followed it up with 191 and 97 against Pakistan at the WACA, outscoring Pakistan by 37 runs. He finished 2004 with 1481 runs for the calendar year. If that's just capitalising on good fortune then he must be luck incarnate.

 

[ZoraxDoom]

Overated: Harmison
Underated: Hoggard

Simple as that

I'll agree with this.....

 

[nik]

now, i don't think hoggard is underrated after he took that 7 wicket haul vs RSA!

 

[sahil]

i think caddick was underrated! ps. what has happened to caddick?!

Got thrown out after tendulkar smashed him for a six in a world cup match in durban in 2003.

 

[squiz]

I don't think people can say Brett Lee is over-rated now, receiving the Player of the Series in the VB Series. Although he does need to bowl a bit better in tests

 

[nik]

brett lee has been a bit scratchy recently, and i think kaspro deserves his place in the test side!

 

[andrew_nixon]

brett lee has been a bit scratchy recently, and i think kaspro deserves his place in the test side!

An average of 21 in the VB Series is scratchy?

 

[Sureshot]

Got thrown out after tendulkar smashed him for a six in a world cup match in durban in 2003.

bot just that but he is 36 now and has a bad injury

 

[Gibbsrules]

Most overated: Steve Harmison
Underated: Jacques Rudolf