All right, I'll be quite honest I was getting really suspicious of swirler since it all seemed to make so much sense. He seemed to be playing a very calculated way, and now that I look back at my post other than some of it which was solid a lot of it was just clutching at straws really as I don't like being the sort of position where I am now where I think most people are sort of leaning town.
However he has cleared it up for me, unless he is still playing a real blinder for the Mafia, the very calm way he has approached my lynch on him makes me think he is actually just town trying to get to the Mafia, his defence has been solid and instead of putting out a typically poor Mafia defence he has reasoned well.
He remains on my suspect list but for now I feel like I can lay off him.
Unlynch: swirler
Yes WC, please tell us more about your role? Please paraphrase to an extent what was in your role PM.
Also interesting to remember that Manly believed Bowie was likely to be Godfather, what do people think about Manly's suspicion? He did seem to have an agenda against WC throughout the game, but maybe he knew something which he was hiding?
The suspicion of Abhas makes sense to me. RPHKR never ceased to be suspicious to me up until the time he was replaced. Abhas then comes in, and being the immensely experienced player he is, he comes in and to extent removes all the suspicion everyone had of him. People also began to rule him out as a suspect as he had just joined and people wanted to figure it out.
However, you look at his play and there are still inconsistencies and he has had trouble explaining himself.
He first said both RPHKR and himself would have interpreted the game very differently and used that to justify RPHKR's scummy play. He claimed miller as well so I think the scope for difference in interpretation is much lower.
He also said he thinks he is bulletproof and miller... I would think he got a straight name for his role and a combination between two roles is something that I'd assume is strange and very uncommon. That was an odd thing to say and this was his exact reasoning which is quite poor IMO:
Even I was a bit surprised, but the reason kind of made sense.. Being one of the best in the world, yet, having lost the ashes thrice, a miller (villain) combined with a bulletproof ability (hero) would probably be the perfect balance to the character.
Abhas, can you please paraphrase exactly what is in your role PM?
Miller again is a very scummy claim to make, it makes him immune to the cop and deems him basically a vanilla townie so that he doesn't have to explain for what he did each night for example, like WC and Simon are having to do.
This was one of his first posts where he mentions WC. He has been suspicious of Varun throughout the game but back then wasn't sure about WC at all, he was even getting suspicious of Varun because of this.
I disagree that WC could be a sacrificial lamb for the mafia because unless Colin has misbalanced this, there surely cannot be enough mafia to lose 1.
That leaves me a tad suspicious of Varun for wanting Wc 's head, unless he's got something, of course, which I may have missed.
He is now very keen on lynching WC purely on Manly's word. Also based on WC's suspicions when he himself earlier agreed that WC wasn't contributing enough.
lynch: WC
And with that, I'm 100% certain, we've found our mafia.. He was against Manly and Ste. First having helped lynch Manly, he decided to take out Ste, because these two, and Varun were consistently gunning for his head.
Manly suggested that Bowie could be the godfather, and I did not agree with him then because I felt he was mafia, but now, I feel he might have had a point.
Lynch: Abhas
.
