Australia tour of West Indies

[lancashire666]

its also not the first time symonds has been not out to a terrible decision by Benson.

not all aussies would stay there, Adam Gilchrist was well know for walking if he felt he was out, unfortunatly there isnt that many people like that in the game anymore, but then again sometimes you can be given out when your not so it evens itself out somewhat

 

[shravi]

its also not the first time symonds has been not out to a terrible decision by Benson.

not all aussies would stay there, Adam Gilchrist was well know for walking if he felt he was out, unfortunatly there isnt that many people like that in the game anymore, but then again sometimes you can be given out when your not so it evens itself out somewhat

I don't blame Symonds. If I was Symonds and my team would be in a situation Australia would have been in if Symonds had walked, I wouldn't walk. It's the umpire's job to give the batsman out and if he cannot make a simple decision like that, I personally, would deem him incompetent or past his prime.

 

[Gilly Fan]

How'd they miss that run out!?!

Lee would've been so far out.

 

[WestIndian]

Lol, Lee, properly softened up by Edwards, man it seems to continue from the 2nd test nice to watch.

 

[sammy]

LOL@Australia .... hanging on for life, playing without any class, just looking desperate

 

[Gilly Fan]

Wow, great battle! Binga fighting for his life at the moment. So close to being hit in the head.

Would be great if he just lunched into a pull shot out of the ground.

Edit: Instead, he blasts a cut through backward point for 4.

 

[aussie1st]

That batting of ours sure doesn't look stable these days. Both Ponting and Hussey bearly making contributions of late and Haddin has been a let down so far, hasn't produced that winning knock that he usually does for NSW.

 

[Dare]

well a good 1st day for the West Indies but this rain is really ruining their chances, they had Australia all but wrapped up.
And again this Symonds guy is pissing me off.

 

[Gilly Fan]

well a good 1st day for the West Indies but this rain is really ruining their chances, they had Australia all but wrapped up.
And again this Symonds guy is pissing me off.

Don't blame Symonds. He's done nothing wrong. Blame Benson who has given him not out 3 times this year.

Gilly Fan added 0 Minutes and 51 Seconds later...

That batting of ours sure doesn't look stable these days. Both Ponting and Hussey bearly making contributions of late and Haddin has been a let down so far, hasn't produced that winning knock that he usually does for NSW.

Ponting made 150 in the first test and about 65 last test. So I don't know what you're basing your argument on :

 

[Jit]

i hate that benson umpire he is an idiot he gave symo not out in ind vs aus where the match all changed

 

[0601731]

benson has made far too many mistakes this year,i hope the icc introduces more technology soon.

 

[Will_NA]

This Lee/Edwards contest is hardly fair! Lee is almost guranteed to last at least 6 overs, giving Edwards 18 deliveries at him whereas Edwards will probably be out before Lee gets a chance at him.

 

[formula1man]

Ricky Ponting has an average of 40 this year in tests so hes doing fine its his ODI average of 19 thats a worry.
Im Australian nd secretly i hope this year Australia get absolutely hammered, i want to be not so good and underdogs. or i could just barrack for England lol.
seriously i want us to win but being underdogs again would be better, be normal. i still believe Lee and tail will pull us through to 300 than we'll blast through WIndies for 190 than wipe the floor. same old thing, if we dont do that than we deffinantly have come back to the pack

with walking, i wouldn't walk, the amount of times you didn't edge it & were out or lbws that weren't out but u were is wat you remember wen ur notout. i mean Sangakkara walked in the IPL semi, wat an idiot

 

[Ponting_14]

Australians cheat way toomcuh, but they dont care as long as they keep winning without getting any real respect. I dont think people will look back and praise australia the way they praise windies because of the cheating.

LOL@Australia .... hanging on for life, playing without any class, just looking desperate

My god you are rubbish. You make me look good when it comes to posting. The mods should do something right for once and ban you.

 

[Dare]

Ricky Ponting has an average of 40 this year in tests so hes doing fine its his ODI average of 19 thats a worry.
Im Australian nd secretly i hope this year Australia get absolutely hammered, i want to be not so good and underdogs. or i could just barrack for England lol.
seriously i want us to win but being underdogs again would be better, be normal. i still believe Lee and tail will pull us through to 300 than we'll blast through WIndies for 190 than wipe the floor. same old thing, if we dont do that than we deffinantly have come back to the pack

with walking, i wouldn't walk, the amount of times you didn't edge it & were out or lbws that weren't out but u were is wat you remember wen ur notout. i mean Sangakkara walked in the IPL semi, wat an idiot

lol your calling a guy and idiot for being honest, unlike that thing on your team that you call a cricket player he is a class act and a way better batsman.
I can only imagine what the Aussies and Symonds would have said if the decision that Rudi made against Sangakkara in the 2nd test in Australia was made against Symonds. how long would it have taken Symonds to walk of.