Strauss is an opener, nothing else. Denly is too. By definition Ravi drops down to 3, possibly 4 with Shah going up to 3?
Strauss averages 35 in ODIs opening, I find it amazing he gets stick. Sure he had a spell where he was looking too suspect outside off stump, but he's got over that with aplomb
STRAUSS ODIs - BY BATTING POSITION
Opener : 44 inns, 1469 runs @ 35.83
No 3 : 13 inns, 395 runs @ 30.38
No 4 : 28 inns, 731 runs @ 30.46
No 5 : 1 inns, 26 runs @ 26.00
Not bad in all positions, but most productive opening. The only criticism I would have is 17 fifties and only three hundreds, two opening and one at no 4.
STRAUSS ODIs - HUNDREDS
06/07/04 (Lords) 100 vs West Indies batting at no 4 in his 11th ODI. Strauss and Flintoff shared a 4th wicket partnership of 226 having been 54/3. England lost by seven wickets as Anderson went for 69 runs off 9.1 overs (two wickets) and Collingwood was hit for 58 off 9.0 overs.
21/06/05 (Trent Bridge) 152 vs Bangladesh opening, putting on 141 for the opening stand as England amassed 391/4 and won by 168 runs. This was Strauss' 32nd ODI. Tremlett took 4/32, Collingwood 6/31
22/03/09 (Providence Stadium) 105 vs West Indies opening, next highest scorer for England was Mascarenhas with 29 as England lost by 21 runs. Strauss was the 9th wicket to fall, only faced 129 balls and hit only seven fours. Some bright spark included Gareth Batty, 0/38 off six overs