Well, I dont know what was in Freddie's mind when he made this decision. One thing is for sure, England would be weak without him. I don't think they have an allrounder of similar quality with them right now. Flintoff is the only cricketer in world cricket that I have not seen struggling with line or length or being hammered by oppositions in recent times, he has been the most dominent figure in England's bowling dept and no one really goes after him.
I have seen bowlers like McGrath and Lee being hammered, treated like sh*t and shown no respect, but it was different with Fred. A man who can bowl yorkers at will, has a great heavy ball and is a real storehouse of energy. No matter, how badly injured or tired he is during a game, he would give more than 100% everytime he bowls. England team would never be the same again. Check out their current oneday performance, without Freddie and KP, they are really struggling.
Broad does show some good potential for an all rounder however not in the same league as Freddie at least in terms of bowling
Please put some paragraphs into your post's, otherwise it's just a bulk or writing and it's horrible to read.
You've basically conceeded that Flintoff no longer wants to play for England, which clearly isn't case. Just cos he doesn't have a contract doesn't mean he can't play for them.