Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[Chewie]

I'm posting things for people to consider. Personally I find it intriguing that Matt wants to be lynched, and am trying to find reasons for why he wants this.

As to characters from Harry Potter who could be a bomb, I can't think of any.

 

[CG123]

Ok, I really haven't taken much out of Callum's game so far. Looking back at his posts, he's been trying to get Matt out of the game and decided to change to Paki late in the first day. He might be mafia but I'm not too sure. He was also the first one to try and find out what Hagrid's role might have been and I can't remember who said it (I think it was Abhas) but they said it would be a good tactic for the mafia to know what roles have been dismissed. So he may well be mafia.

Fair enough, at least you gave me a reason to reply to unlike the other four people who posted they were suspicious of me without any reason what so ever.

I wouldn't say I've been trying to get Matt out of the game, it's just that he's really been pissing me off, as he's been no help whatsoever. ATM eight people have lynches on him and I don't, so that's a pretty stupid thing to say. If anything I've been trying to keep him in, as I don't think he's mafia, and he might have a role that backfires on us when he's lynched off.

My Paki lynch was made when I got up, most people started changing their votes to him overnight my time, but if you look at the timing I wasn't just waiting to late before voting for him, I did it as soon as I got up. It probably does seem like I was following the crowd a bit, but like I said it was either that or I just didn't lynch at all, and it made sense to lynch him which in the end turned out to be the right decision.

In terms of the Hagrid's role, IIRC a few people were trying to find out what his role was, including yourself, if you knew it was a good tactic for the mafia which I'm not, why would you try to help me if you think I'm mafia.

I hope that clears a few things up, if it doesn't feel free to ask a few more questions, unlike the others who just said they were suspicious of me without giving a reason. It's all good if a couple of people say that, but I can't really defend myself/reply if that happens with a lot of people.

If need be I'll put the hammer vote on Matt, but I'll wait until later today and give him some time to roleclaim. (I assume there's still enough time in the day to wait)

 

[Chewie]

There's about 30 hours left.

 

[hedger_14]

In terms of the Hagrid's role, IIRC a few people were trying to find out what his role was, including yourself, if you knew it was a good tactic for the mafia which I'm not, why would you try to help me if you think I'm mafia.

Yeah, you were the first one to ask and tbh, I wasn't thinking of that tactic at that time and only when Abhas said it, I thought that it would be a good tactic for the mafia. (I did say that in my previous post).

Ok, I see where you're getting at with Matt, looking at your previous posts, I think you were pretty much entirely annoyed at what he was doing.

And like I said, I'm willing to hammer Matt but I want to give him some time to roleclaim.

 

[hedger_14]

Well he's online now so hopefully he comes and posts.

 

[The Spin]

The deadline will be extended because debate is very good. Ignore it for now.

 

[CG123]

Like Brendon said he came online, but has since gone back offline.

I'll give him another couple of hours before lynching him.

 

[Bevab]

Maybe Matt has the role which blake had in Wrestling mafia, where Mattfb had to sacrifice yet Blake could not be killed.

Still don't hammer him, let him explain himself.

 

[ARay]

Matt, is clearly being worthless. However, I dont want people getting impatient and hammering him before he speaks.

While I am severely tempted to ask you guys to lynch him off, I have to keep in mind that he might have a role which might harm townies.
I want hear his role claim before it.
I honestly wish I did not have to lynch him and use voting pressure to focus on other people, but he is quite irritating and disturbing.

As far as I am concerned, some of CG's votes has been quite conveniently placed. While it does not prove anything, its still a point that has to be noted.

 

[hedger_14]

Matt has the role which blake had in Wrestling mafia, where Mattfb had to sacrifice yet Blake could not be killed

What are you on about? Shan had a role that revealed one of his mafia members, which was Blake and then they lynched off Blake but his role didn't allow him to be lynched once. Where did Matt come into this? He was exposed by the cop and killed.

 

[CG123]

The thing is he's been online, but has now gone back offline, so I don't think he's going to say anything properly, like roleclaiming or anything.

----------

As far as I am concerned, some of CG's votes has been quite conveniently placed. While it does not prove anything, its still a point that has to be noted.

Can you please expand on this, I don't really get what you mean by conveniently placed?

 

[hedger_14]

Matt, is clearly being worthless. However, I dont want people getting impatient and hammering him before he speaks.

That's why I haven't hammered yet but I bloody wish he would hurry up and post something.

 

[CG123]

Can you please expand on this, I don't really get what you mean by conveniently placed?

Following on from this, as I have no idea what you're talking about Aray.

My first lynch was on Matt, because he made two stupid posts, I said after the first one I was temped to lynch him, then he made another one so I did.

Then once we got later into the day, Paki still hadn't posted anything, so I decided to change my vote to him. I also see you voted for Paki after I did, so if my vote was conveniently placed, yours was even more conveniently placed.

Today I first lynched Bevab, of which I gave three ligament reasons in my post to do so(You can look back if you want). He then cleared that up, so I unlynched him, and here we are now without me placing another lynch.

I'd really like to know what you're talking about by conveniently placed, as I've only made three lynches, all with good reasons.

 

[ARay]

Hmmm, Matt or Paki?

Matt's actually posted, but his posts have been idiotic, while Paki hasn't posted at all. Matt's role could possibly have something to do with it (which could backfire on us), so I'll change my lynch to Paki.

Unlynch: Matt121

FOS: Paki007

In terms of the extra vote on Paki, I assume someone's a double voter.

Lynch: Paki007
No point in keeping townies who are just dead weight.
Its interesting about the way matt is behaving. Obviously, he does not seem afraid of a lynch. There is a possibility of him being mafia, but one cannot be sure.
I believe he might be more individual aligned.

I'd really like to know what you're talking about by conveniently placed, as I've only made three lynches, all with good reasons.

Well, I was basing the fact I felt that you were just using frustration as an excuse to hop into the Matt bandwagon in your very first lynch. While something like this is hard to be said to be as solid evidence as it is based on my intuition.

However the second reason, I am basing it on the fact that you did not lynch him before me. You FOS-ed him.
I had lynched Paki because I knew a matt lynch is less viable than a lynch on an inactive member.
The main reason why I felt your vote on paki was conveniently placed is because of your follow up post in which you stated

Woops, I meant to say:

Unlynch: Matt121

Lynch: Paki007

Can I ask how can you confuse FOS and Lynch so easily when they don't even have the same letters? I mean I don't know about you but I think confusing an FOS and and lynch is extremely hard to make.

It seems rather like you originally hadn't planned to lynch him, but after seeing votes grow against him (and also seeing my post voting him), you decided that you wanted to bandwagon into Paki as well.

 

[Gaurav_7]

So, what have we got so far? Matt still not posting anything? Well, he's pissing me off now. Why would he be so much a trouble for us?