Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[ARay]

Hey guys,
A lot of discussions while I was sleeping.Is there any character who can benefit from getting lynched?I mean Matt posted 'Lynch me,Lynch me,please'.Is it that he is stupid?or is it that he might get something from it?

I think that is what the discussion has been about. That he might have a role which might be harmful to town.
Tell me what do you think of hedger and CG?
Go back and read their posts and describe how you feel about them?

Questions for our active hedger,
What do you make out of CG and papa smurf so far? . Does any attribute stand out?

BKB, once again has been super quiet. I get nervous whenever a good player is silent over long periods of time.
I agree he might not have the time, but I expect atleast one good substantial post from him whenever he is online.

 

[Gaurav_7]

We're running low on time, isn't it? When does the day end?

 

[ARay]

I presume we have another 24 hour or so.
Obviously we still have 3 more mafia members (it is a 16 person game right?)
I really am not sure whether to push pressure chewie to role claim yet or not.
I know I definitely want Matt out of the game though. Reading through his mindless posts can be annoying.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Yes, Matt should go really. I don't think game will be over if he is a jester though. That is highly unlikely in such a game. We need to take him out as he's not posting anything of substance and is acting foolish. I also have suspicions on Chewie but, feel Matt should go.

Unlynch - Chewie
Lynch - Matt

 

[ARay]

Yes, Matt should go really. I don't think game will be over if he is a jester though. That is highly unlikely in such a game. We need to take him out as he's not posting anything of substance and is acting foolish. I also have suspicions on Chewie but, feel Matt should go.

Unlynch - Chewie
Lynch - Matt

Even if he is a jester, and he wins the game, the game will not end. It would really be a sad ending to an interesting mafia game if it did happen
But I think the game will continue and it will be one less anti-town member to deal with.
I want Matt to role claim now.
He is at L-2 (two votes from hammer) I think.
I want to know which crazy character he has.

----------

And don't hammer till he role claims or alteast refuses to role claim.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I don't think he's going to post any good. Forget the role claim. If he's town aligned, he will actually try to help than add to our trouble.

----------

That post was edited by mistake as the net went down for a minute or two.

 

[ARay]

Yeaaaah, I guess. But I still want to be sure, because it might be a character which might be important

 

[Gaurav_7]

But, will he do that? That's the biggest question. Maybe he will come up with another horrible post?

 

[pcfan123]

unlynch : BEvab

lynch : matt

I still think most of our discussion is overly speculative.

I do find Abhas post about Pakis lynch being a waste interesting.

 

[Near]

Hmmm....Chewie is looking suspicious to me.Another questiono you guys count this to be a small game?If not,then I take Chewie knew this and still brought up the Jester thing.That obviously makes him a very possible mafia candidate.And in first Chewie tried to pin the suspicion on the no lynchers saying that the people no lynching must contain the mafia(And made Matt go with no lynch so it would sound like that they are not in cahoots),But what if he was just pointing us to the direction so we would make a random lynch and lose a townie and in the end saw that paki is being inactive and turned towards paki?Either way:

FOS:Chewie

EDIT:The grin is a d.

------------
edit:About hedger,he and papa smurf might be connected or might be in cahoots.I mean agreeing on a lot of things and having a good friendly chat does show a connection.About CG I am still thinking what his role might be

 

[Chewie]

So you expect me to just sit here watching while everyone goes and lynches someone without a proper investigation into what his role could be? Don't you think it is worth exploring all possible alternatives before lynching someone who wants to be lynched? He is obviously being annoying for a reason, and you guys are just gonna vote him off because he is annoying and not contributing, while his role may have something happen when he is lynched.

One other alternative to a jester is that he is a suicide bomber sort of role who takes the hammer voter with him.

Also, it is good to see that p23456789 is contributing, but all he is posting is what other people have posted, in a confusing way.

----------

Matt121: 7 (p23456789, Aditya, Bevab, ARay, Papa Smurf, User2010, Mark)
Chewie: 1 (Abhas)
8 votes for a lynch

 

[pcfan123]

why dont you lynch Matt with us Chewie, just need the hammer vote.

 

[hedger_14]

What do you make out of CG and papa smurf so far? . Does any attribute stand out?

Ok, I really haven't taken much out of Callum's game so far. Looking back at his posts, he's been trying to get Matt out of the game and decided to change to Paki late in the first day. He might be mafia but I'm not too sure. He was also the first one to try and find out what Hagrid's role might have been and I can't remember who said it (I think it was Abhas) but they said it would be a good tactic for the mafia to know what roles have been dismissed. So he may well be mafia.

Papa Smurf, it's his first game so I can't tell whether he is just an active player trying to get involved in his first game or if he is mafia, then his mafia partners are telling him to be active. He's been the most active first time player and so far, he seems to be helping with the discussion. At the moment, I'm inclined to believe he is townie but he could well be mafia and playing a good game.

I won't lynch Matt until he posts next if he does otherwise I might have to lynch him so we don't waste a day.

----------

Should I lynch Matt? ARay has said not to hammer until he roleclaims but there's a good chance he doesn't post.

 

[Chewie]

why dont you lynch Matt with us Chewie, just need the hammer vote.

Because I want him to roleclaim. I also don't want to die in case he is a suicide bomber sort of role.

 

[Near]

Ok.So Chewie you keep insisting that Matt might be a suicide bomber type character but this is Harry Potter mafia so can you think of any character who is a suicide bomber in Harry Potter?I don't think Peeves is a suicide bomber nor are the Weasley twins.I am just saying this cause Matt has been given a chance to defend himself and the thing he posted was "Lynch me Lynch me,please"And he might not even post.