War
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Feb 10, 2010
- Online Cricket Games Owned
So not only are you agreeing that they for financial reasons preferred to play in the IPL, you are also telling me why and totally backing what I have been saying all along - That WIans take the IPL seriously and in the past have opted to play in the IPL over playing for the WI. And yet you are pretending as if we are both saying two different things !! We are both saying the same thing, Bravo and Pollard have in the past ditched WI for whatever reasons, (more money, or to fight of aliens or whatever) and instead opted to turn out for the IPL teams.
I dont know WI are trying now, but GL to them in that, but what they are doing now has nothing to do with the statement that in the past Bravo and Pollard have preferred to turn out for the IPL sides instead of WI. You can argue till the cows come home, and keep trying to deflect it on a missing quote, but the facts are still the same. Bravo and Pollard refused to play for WI and instead chose to play for their IPL sides.
I am expecting another long post from you in reply, but save yourself the trouble and instead just save the time you would spend in the typing that long post and just take 5 minutes to look at facts. Real simple I will break it down for you.
Did Bravo and Pollard or did they not during 2008-2010 refuse to play for the WI and instead chose to turn out for their IPL sides - THEY DID.
Did they or did they not refuse to sign central contract with the WI board to play in the IPL hasslefree - THEY DID
Good now let is sink in and stop typing !!
Ha well firstly i notice in a few threads I've interacted with you some real aggression in your posts with me. I like it it!
http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/2718736-post778.html
Let me show you back your post, since you said two things:
Pocker said:Well it would not surprise me. WIans take the IPL very seriously. I think Dwayne Bravo said he enjoys playing for his country T&T the most, then playing in the IPL and only third for the WI.
I'm not questioning the facts of when the players did not play, when they did not sign contracts etc. Its the part in bold I want proof I want, since I know Dwayne Bravo has never stated that those are his priorities.
Based on your comments overall, I'm further convinced you don't understand the WICB vs WIPA vs Windies players problems of the past. You say you are not accusing them of being mercenaries - but the tone of your post, you sound like the many people over the years who have painted them as that & I take issue with that.
If as i mentioned before, if the windies did not have years of players vs board issues with regards to finances which dates back to when Lara was playing - when the IPL came out they would not have chosen to play IPL over windies easily - because them and the board were at logger heads.
You compare to how WICB handled its star players with regards to IPL contracts during those days compared to other weak financial nations such as NZ, SRI, PAK & BANG (although PAK players don't play in the IPL due to politics) none of these country had the name massive issues with its players like the WICB.
The WICB board acted ridiculously, so the players were in their rights to not sign contracts in the past. That was reaction to board after years of payment issues - it was not plain case of them simply wanting to play where they could earn more money.
And the WICB have essentially conceded they are wrong in the past, by now trying not to have the WI home season clash with IPL.
You read this Pollard interviews which he speaks on wanting to play test cricket & speaking of the peculiarities windies players face when trying to balance the financial reward of T20 & playing other formats, their intentions are good:
-Kieron Pollard: 'My only way of playing Tests is by performing in ODIs' | Cricinfo Magazine | ESPN Cricinfo
- Kieron Pollard Exclusive Interview | All Out Cricket | West Indies
----------
In all honesty the 2004 advantage was lost in 2008 when Australia lost the test series to India 2 - 0, and then doubly lost when Australia were whitewashed 4 - 0 in the tests on their next tour to India. Sure they could take it further in the ODI series, but they even lost that in 2013 when they lost the ODI series to India and the T20. I think Australia should have seen this coming.
More so the 2014 series vs IND was were the alarm bells about their ability versus spin. 2008 AUS batting vs spin although was not that bad, the drew 2 tests after all. Bowling selections was the problem, i.e choosing Cameron White as a main spinner.
1st test of that 2012 series AUS barely lost by 1 wicket in a classic. They won preceding series of test/ODI in SRI 2012 & won their last two ODI series vs PAK in UAE 09 & 2012.
Based on how they had recovered in the last few months, I did expect these issues versus spin to be so bad again. Simply despicable.