India in England Jun-Sept 2014

@SaiSrini
Reason for picking Ashwin over Jadeja/Binny ?

I picked two spinners because I believe the pitch could be flat and to the batsmen's liking.

----------

Binny shouldn't have even been picked for this tour... :facepalm

My goodness, Dhoni is not good enough to bat at #5 lol.

Two things - Dhoni at 5 might keep him away from the new ball. #2 - to me, Rahane seems the Laxman mould where he can play with and around the tail.
 
I've been away for a while but wow, what a series this is going to be. Don't let the Indian impotency from 3 years ago fool anyone or England's success in India...these are terribly different circumstances.

No longer is India carrying the carcasses of Tendulkar, Dravid and co. This is a new generation of batsmen willing to take bowlers on, young, fit and with sharp reflexes.

England too are affected...but in a bad way, Pietersen is no longer around and neither is that number 3 batting rock of Trott. Cook is out of form and under severe pressure, not to mention a tradition of dying, slow pitches which will hamper England's swing and benefit India's spin and batting.

My starting XI for England would have to be:

1. Cook (C)
2. Robson
3. Ballance
4. Bell
5. Root
6. Ali
7. Prior WK
8. Stokes
9. Broad
10. Jordan
11. Anderson

12th man and very unlucky to miss out Plunkett. Stokes is a great choice I think, he can bat well and take wickets when it counts. He's a cricketer on the rise and adds balance to a team that so needs it.

I had to make do with the England squad but if I had my way, I would have picked a specialist spinner, ALi is new to int. cricket and already has so much pressure on his slender shoulders, he doesn't need the added headache of an Indian batting line up that can slaughter him. He needs to fully focus on his batting, wherein lies his strength.

With India, I think the batting line up pretty much picks itself and there's no doubt a lot will rest on how good Kohli is and their openers.

The bowling is, as usual, a real weak point, there was a time when India could pick from at the very least, 2 or 3 truly world class spinners but in my personally opinion, outside of Ashwin, who himself is average, there isn't much for India to pick from.
 
Last edited:
He hit three centuries. Pretty good. Even for a carcass.

without a doubt he was very good in that series but maybe I didn't explain myself that well. Dravid was still far from his consistent self in the series' against SA and WI leading up to England and didn't have a hell of a lot of success against the Australians in the series that followed.

So that's what I meant by carcass...India had to carry a lot of players in that time period, now they have a refreshed and young look about them. Cricketers who aren't trying to find form or some sort of last shot at glory but are looking to play hard, tough and play to win.
 
I would post my views after the first test because they are playing test after some period of time.
 
So, it looks like Indian final 11 will look like this based on all the build up.

Vijay
Dhawan
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Dhoni
Binny
Jadeja
Kumar
Ishant
Shami
 
So, it looks like Indian final 11 will look like this based on all the build up.

Vijay
Dhawan
Pujara
Kohli
Rahane
Dhoni
Binny
Jadeja
Kumar
Ishant
Shami

solid battling line up, really hope Dhawan and Kohli can bring fireworks to proceedings.

On the england front, glad to hear Buttler is getting a call up, even if it is as a back up to Prior. I've been calling for this guy to be our Test keeper for a while now
 
George Dobell: ECB profit could be England's loss | Cricket News | England v India ? Investec Test Series | ESPN Cricinfo

Yes been saying this for years, ECBs strange system of awarding test venues via the counties bidding may have certainly helped them greatly financially - but its knock on effects for the players are finally becoming obvious.

How can we really be acceptable that ENG groundsmen can't prefer wickets to give them prime home advantage, because something as frivolous as new drainage system across venues around the country?

----------

England better hope its rainy and overcast for 90% for every test, because you add the KP factor that continues to haunt the psyche of the team currently - this is turning out to be a ridiculous little issue.
 
Last edited:
KP echoes the same thing about pitches
Kevin Pietersen: England must beware India's new stars ? they are hugely talented and very hungry - Telegraph

these coloumns written by him show how sound his cricketing logic is not to mention how observant he is of not just the skills of other players but their mindset too, he should be captaining the side......on second thoughts may be after a month:D

The way he is hyping up Murali Vijay (his Delhi Daredevils teammate) makes me question how truthful he is trying to be.:rolleyes Its so stupid how he tries to put down the newly installed drainage system just because it negates the 'so-called home advantage' for England that was driven by moisture on the pitch/ground. For him, it seems like all he is concerned about in the advantage for England players. What about people who pay the ticket and come to watch a game? Just because the water/moisture is all absorbed, Trent Bridge/Lords, etc. is not going to become Wankhede/Eden Gardens.

I am not giving this article undue attention. Still very weary of this series because of our bowlers and Dhoni's captaincy. I think our batting will be fine. Its our bowling and captaincy.
 
Last edited:
The way he is hyping up Murali Vijay (his Delhi Daredevils teammate) makes me question how truthful he is trying to be
ya felt that a bit, its become customary for Overseas IPL performers to praise their teamates like Steyn on ishant etc, but still vijay is not totally bad in tests he does have the ability to face and grind attacks, not many may commend him but he is definitely blocking out he new ball and setting the platform for no3 and 4
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top