thedon5
Panel of Selectors
I'm game. It'll be good for the other townies as they'll be safe tonight as I will be the one killed
.
.
Mafia - Janitorial 2.0 - Game Abandoned
- Thread starter hedger_14
- Start date
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Okay, thedon can replace Abhas.
----------
And read the setup details. There is a full description of all the roles there in the first post.
----------
And read the setup details. There is a full description of all the roles there in the first post.
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
Oh yes, got it. TheDon was an Oracle and he selected Psq who is now revealed. That clears him for the game which is a very good thing for us after a poor start. Plus we also know that the doc isn't dead. So, I hope he knows whom to protect in the coming nights. It's also nice that the doc can protect the same person consecutively. Whoever is the doc, please do not out at all! Unless there is an absolute need to do so.
TheDon was janned too it means. But, him being an Oracle helped as we now know who he was!
TheDon was janned too it means. But, him being an Oracle helped as we now know who he was!
Villain
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2011
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - PS4
A real bad start for us, Oracle is killed and the Cop is revealed. We can still go on as the only hope now would be the Doc.
Right now the only good thing is that we found out one of the mafia(s), Don(Abhas).
Lynch: thedon5
You won't be as the Doc is still there and as you're a confirmed cop he'll anyway save you in the following night.
Right now the only good thing is that we found out one of the mafia(s), Don(Abhas).
Lynch: thedon5
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
OK so yes I was the oracle and went for P_Squared as I have never played a Mafia game with him before. Bad choice though, unveils the cop to the Mafia straight away! Makes him an easy night kill!
I have read enough Mafia QTs to know exactly who would target me on the first night. That very same person just explained that having the cop outed is a good thing. I'm not sure in what world that is a good thing for the town. Also, the filler about the doctor not . My spidey senses are tingling as the man I replaced so accurately said a couple of games ago.
FOS: User_2010
You investigated Abhas? Can't really argue with that, can I, I will probably be lynched. I am just a villager. Seeing as it says a miller appears as a villager to themself, I would think either I am the miller or P_Squared is paranoid/insane, but I think I am more likely the miller as I doubt this setup would work if the cop is paranoid/insane. I do understand that you guys will probably not believe me, but at least I will try and make my opinions known before I die. Right now User is the obvious one that looks suspicious to me, yash could be Mafia trying to go in for a quick lynch, but I think he is more likely just town following the cop. Bit of a poor decision to go straight in with a lynch in a game with a miller, but not much I can do about it.
It takes five to hammer, so of the four including yash that will lynch me other than P_Squared, expect 2-3 to be Mafia members. The people who actually consider whether or not I am miller are more likely to be town. Anyway, I think at least let the day run before lynching me. Right now the town has learnt nothing about the rest of the players, most haven't even posted. So I advise you to unlynch me yash, for now at least, as you have set up a quick fire Mafia lynch if you are town. Work up suspicions before blindly going into a vital next day, as then you'll be able to make a better decision as to who is Mafia on a LyLo day.
Btw, it says if the miller is lynched they will come up as Mafia. Just keep that in mind. Assuming someone dies tonight, that is 4 vs 3, LyLo and an almost impossible position to win from. Knowing this the Mafia will probably kill someone other than P_Squared, especially after he gets one of the townies lynched as killing the cop isn't vital to them, killing anyone at all is. Don't be fooled into thinking it's 5 vs 2 with a very good chance to win, make no mistake, it will be LyLo.
----------
You'll be safe, but that's not what's important. The Mafia just need to make a kill, be it you or anyone else. They'd be much better off randomly going for someone the doctor wouldn't protect, as it takes them incredibly close to a win, a position it'd be almost impossible to lose from (LyLo three days in a row...).
I have read enough Mafia QTs to know exactly who would target me on the first night. That very same person just explained that having the cop outed is a good thing. I'm not sure in what world that is a good thing for the town. Also, the filler about the doctor not . My spidey senses are tingling as the man I replaced so accurately said a couple of games ago.
FOS: User_2010
You investigated Abhas? Can't really argue with that, can I, I will probably be lynched. I am just a villager. Seeing as it says a miller appears as a villager to themself, I would think either I am the miller or P_Squared is paranoid/insane, but I think I am more likely the miller as I doubt this setup would work if the cop is paranoid/insane. I do understand that you guys will probably not believe me, but at least I will try and make my opinions known before I die. Right now User is the obvious one that looks suspicious to me, yash could be Mafia trying to go in for a quick lynch, but I think he is more likely just town following the cop. Bit of a poor decision to go straight in with a lynch in a game with a miller, but not much I can do about it.
It takes five to hammer, so of the four including yash that will lynch me other than P_Squared, expect 2-3 to be Mafia members. The people who actually consider whether or not I am miller are more likely to be town. Anyway, I think at least let the day run before lynching me. Right now the town has learnt nothing about the rest of the players, most haven't even posted. So I advise you to unlynch me yash, for now at least, as you have set up a quick fire Mafia lynch if you are town. Work up suspicions before blindly going into a vital next day, as then you'll be able to make a better decision as to who is Mafia on a LyLo day.
Btw, it says if the miller is lynched they will come up as Mafia. Just keep that in mind. Assuming someone dies tonight, that is 4 vs 3, LyLo and an almost impossible position to win from. Knowing this the Mafia will probably kill someone other than P_Squared, especially after he gets one of the townies lynched as killing the cop isn't vital to them, killing anyone at all is. Don't be fooled into thinking it's 5 vs 2 with a very good chance to win, make no mistake, it will be LyLo.
----------
Oh didnt realise there was a doc in this game. I should survive then.
You'll be safe, but that's not what's important. The Mafia just need to make a kill, be it you or anyone else. They'd be much better off randomly going for someone the doctor wouldn't protect, as it takes them incredibly close to a win, a position it'd be almost impossible to lose from (LyLo three days in a row...).
SiriusBlack
ICC Chairman
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2011
edited
Villain
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2011
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - PS4
I forgot the fact that there's a possibility that Don could be a miller as well. Henceforth,
Unlynch: thedon5
----------
A mislynch at this stage could cost us especially losing a strong player like Don who could be town.
Unlynch: thedon5
----------
A mislynch at this stage could cost us especially losing a strong player like Don who could be town.
P Squared
International Coach
- Joined
- Jun 13, 2010
- Online Cricket Games Owned
Now that was predictable.(miller claim)
However, I dont think anyone else should lynch atm, only after everyone has posted.
In all honesty though, I think (barring a massive brain fart by a mafia) that thedon will be lynched today.
However, I dont think anyone else should lynch atm, only after everyone has posted.
In all honesty though, I think (barring a massive brain fart by a mafia) that thedon will be lynched today.
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
So, theDon you are suspicious of me because of the last few games? That's nice. I did not mean to say that the cop out was a good thing. But, after that sort of a start it was a good thing because in such a setup the counter claims are very easy and it was good we knew the actual cop. Plus the doc having the ability to save same person is an advantage.
We should be careful whom we lynch today. Let us wait for everyone's input. As theDon has said, there is a miller in the game who appears as a villager to himself so we must not vote straightaway. One failed lynch and we are out of it!
First post says that miller will be revealed as mafia if lynched! Now that is even more confusing for us. TheDon could very well be lying too. Not sure what to do. But I won't lynch.
I am suspicious of Yash as well the way he was so quick to lynch theDon and then unlynching him straightaway again very quickly!
We should be careful whom we lynch today. Let us wait for everyone's input. As theDon has said, there is a miller in the game who appears as a villager to himself so we must not vote straightaway. One failed lynch and we are out of it!
First post says that miller will be revealed as mafia if lynched! Now that is even more confusing for us. TheDon could very well be lying too. Not sure what to do. But I won't lynch.
I am suspicious of Yash as well the way he was so quick to lynch theDon and then unlynching him straightaway again very quickly!
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
I just want to say that everyone should read a detailed description of the roles. I have not left any description out. There is nothing hidden in those roles. What you see is exactly what you get.
Lynch Count:
thedon5 (1) - P Squared
Also, I will allow 12 hours from the point of majority (unless everyone has lynched) before declaring a player killed, which gives you enough time to unlynch if absolutely necessary.
Lynch Count:
thedon5 (1) - P Squared
Also, I will allow 12 hours from the point of majority (unless everyone has lynched) before declaring a player killed, which gives you enough time to unlynch if absolutely necessary.
Umair7
El Presidente
....
Last edited:
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
It's nothing to do with the last few games. All I remember is in 2-3 games where you have been Mafia, you always bring me up as a target to kill, I see no reason why it would be any different now. Your first post was dodgy IMO which is why I went a step further and put a FOS on you, I probably wouldn't have looked too far into it had it not been for your first post.
I guess you are right about how it is an advantage that a cop CC is not possible now, but still the negatives outweigh the positives for me.
I would be suspicious of yash, but in all honesty I would've done the same had I not properly read the OP, I don't really think anyone had straight away. It could be dodgy Mafia play, but it could just as easily be a townie just warming up.
Honestly though, other than lynching myself I see very little opportunity for us to lynch anyone else unless there is some disastrous Mafia play which allows that. From the perspective of a neutral townie (i.e. someone who doesn't know that I am town), it would be difficult to lynch anyone else other than me. Tbh even a no lynch isn't a possibility as it's not going to help us too much for the next day as we'll be back at MyLo by tomorrow in a difficult position to find two more Mafia over the next two days.
Not blaming anyone here, but due to P_Squared's result, I see no easy way that we can win
.----------
On the bright side, at least the Mafia have already used their Janitor ability for the game.
Also, due to the presence of the lawyer, unless it has been used already which I doubt, I would be very weary of your result tonight P_Squared. IMO you will be the most likely kill target on night 2 and you'll have one more day and one more result. So keep that in mind if you get an innocent result, any more guiltys and you've picked out a Mafia member.
Similar threads
