End Game Dethwing Classic - Mafia (Rebel2k17) wins!

[Gaurav_7]

Sane Cop - aka normal cop. Will return a correct result.
Insane Cop - Will return the opposite result.
Paranoid Cop - Will return a mafia result.
Naive Cop - Will return a town result

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

Assuming the following:
Rebel - paranoid
Rudi - insane

-----------------------------------
Rebel (Paranoid) - Rudi - Mafia Rudi Town
PS - Villain - Town
Villain (Naive ?) - Rebel - Town Rebel Town
Rudi (insane) - Ali - Town Ali Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

------------------------------------
I'd like to hear @AliB analysis please?

I seriously do not get how you can trust anyone apart from yourself in this game given the setup. Villain has constantly hinted himself to be town aligned in 2-3 posts which I find scummy.

 

[RUDI]

No Lynch for now .

 

[Gaurav_7]

I appreciate the work PS and Rudi has put in, solid town vibes from both of them. But, also gotta agree with the fact that it's very hard to crack on the the basis of Night 0 investigations. We should be able to make a lot more sense the next Day, right now not only difficult but there's a lot of confusion since we're all on different tracks. Let's stick to the plan but that shouldn't mean we should not be trying something else.

I don't mean we should not try anything. What I posted was only because we will get more confused as I seriously was after PS analysis. What I also mean is, if we assume everyone to be town then actual mafia can get away easily. We got to suspect each and everyone in this setup. One wrong analysis and we are all gone. As I said earlier, I being a mafia was cleared as town in one such games which was hillarious.

 

[AliB]

People doubting me is fair as of late I've been busy with other stuff.

--

My analysis:
Rebel - Rudi - Mafia(Sane/Insane/Paranoid)
PS - Villain - Town(Sane/Insane/Naive)
Villain - Rebel - Town(Sane/Insane/Naive)
Rudi - Ali - Town(Sane/Insane/Naive)
Ali - Villain - Mafia (Sane/Insane/Paranoid)

 

[Villain]

I don't mean we should not try anything. What I posted was only because we will get more confused as I seriously was after PS analysis. What I also mean is, if we assume everyone to be town then actual mafia can get away easily. We got to suspect each and everyone in this setup. One wrong analysis and we are all gone. As I said earlier, I being a mafia was cleared as town in one such games which was hillarious.

I agree with what you said as well, and yes it got confusing. Gotta keep it simple and yeah kinda shocked nobody has been cleared by now, maybe someone messed up meaning got a different result and posted something else unintentionally.

And yeah,
No Lynch for now.

 

[AliB]

No Lynch for now.

 

[CerealKiller]

Day 1 has ended without a lynch. Night 1 begins.
No more posts in the thread.
​

@Rebel2k17 @RUDI @AliB @Perfect Square @Villain

 

[Perfect Square]

No wait!!!!

 

[Gaurav_7]

Yeah we were still discussing and everyone just said no lynch for now. CK got a bit carried away there.

 

[CerealKiller]

No wait!!!!

Yeah we were still discussing and everyone just said no lynch for now. CK got a bit carried away there.

The vote that creates a majority is a hammer, and cannot be reversed.

 

[Villain]

To be fair 3/5 said No Lynch, that's the majority. Let's wait now.

 

[Perfect Square]

I know who the Mafia, I can explain. But CK ended the day. Sorry for posting.

 

[CerealKiller]

As the Townies woke up the next morning, they found one of their neighbours murdered in cold blood.
Rudi is dead. He was a Town Cop.

Day 2 begins now.
With 4 alive, it takes 3 for hammer.
​

@Rebel2k17 @RUDI @Perfect Square @Villain @AliB

 

[Perfect Square]

My Day 1 Analysis:

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 1: Assume Rebel is Mafia.

PS - Sane/Naive
Villain - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid

Case 2: Assume PS is Mafia.

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
Villain - Sane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid

Case 3: Assume Villain is Mafia.

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Paranoid

Case 4: Assume Rudi is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid

Case 5: Assume Ali is Mafia.

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Naive
Rudi - Insane/Naive

Conclusion:

We get two pairs of roles in Case 2 and 3. Means Me as a Mafia or Villain. Since I was the only one who wasn't investigated. That means it is obvious you'll see 2 pairs of roles in Case 2 also.

Hence, Villain is Mafia![DOUBLEPOST=1521549326][/DOUBLEPOST]Lynch: Villain

 

[Villain]

Investigated @AliB, mafia.