End Game Dethwing Classic - Mafia (Rebel2k17) wins!

[Perfect Square]

Investigated Ali. : Town

Lynch: Villain

 

[Gaurav_7]

I investigated Ali, he came up as mafia. I haven't read PS' analysis as I am out for work so just posting this quickly. I will advice people not to jump on conclusions without analysing this thoroughly. We have already lost Rudi which is a setback and one more wrong lynch and we are doomed.

 

[Villain]

My Day 1 Analysis:

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 1: Assume Rebel is Mafia.

PS - Sane/Naive
Villain - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid

Case 2: Assume PS is Mafia.

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
Villain - Sane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid

Case 3: Assume Villain is Mafia.

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Paranoid

Case 4: Assume Rudi is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid

Case 5: Assume Ali is Mafia.

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Naive
Rudi - Insane/Naive

Conclusion:

We get two pairs of roles in Case 2 and 3. Means Me as a Mafia or Villain. Since I was the only one who wasn't investigated. That means it is obvious you'll see 2 pairs of roles in Case 2 also.

Hence, Villain is Mafia![DOUBLEPOST=1521549326][/DOUBLEPOST]Lynch: Villain

I'm yet to go through that but I suggest you to not jump to conclusions this early, we may lose it if you're town.

I've investigated Ali and the result was Mafia pretty much leaning towards me being Sane. Only he's left to post the result.

 

[Perfect Square]

Unlynch ; Villain

 

[Villain]

Night 0:
Rebel - Rudi - Mafia (Sane, Insane, Paranoid)
PS - Villain - Town (Sane, Insane, Naive)
Villain - Rebel - Town (Sane, Insane, Naive)
Rudi - Ali - Town (Sane, Insane, Naive)
Ali - Villain - Mafia (Sane, Insane, Paranoid)


Night 1:
Rebel - Ali - Mafia
PS - Ali - Town
Villain - Ali - Mafia

Rebel is either Insane/Paranoid.
PS - Naive/Sane (Can't be Insane then that'd be two mafias me and Ali).
Villain - Sane/Insane (If I'm sane=Ali mafia).

 

[Villain]

To my understanding;
Rebel - Paranoid
PS - Naive
Rudi - Insane
Villain - Sane

Ali is mafia.

 

[Perfect Square]

My understanding:

Rebel: Insane
PS: Naive
Rudi: Sane
Ali: Paranoid

Villain: Mafia

Ali. Needs to post his investigation ASAP!

 

[Gaurav_7]

I don't think we can analyse without Ali's result. Also, I am on mobile and out for the night so will have to analyse whatever it is on the mobile itself which is difficult. So please bear with me.

 

[AliB]

I got Rebel as mafia, its clear that I'm Paranoid cop.

 

[Perfect Square]

My understanding:

Rebel: Insane
PS: Naive
Rudi: Sane
Ali: Paranoid

Villain: Mafia

Ali. Needs to post his investigation ASAP!

F.O.S: Villain

 

[AliB]

Rebel - Ali - Mafia(Insane)
PS - Ali - Town(Sane/Naive)
Ali - Rebel - Mafia(Paranoid)
Rudi - Dead - (Sane/Naive)

Lynch: Villain

 

[Perfect Square]

Lynch: Villain

 

[Villain]

Night 0:
Rebel - Rudi - Mafia (Sane, Insane, Paranoid)
PS - Villain - Town (Sane, Insane, Naive)
Villain - Rebel - Town (Sane, Insane, Naive)
Rudi - Ali - Town (Sane, Insane, Naive)
Ali - Villain - Mafia (Sane, Insane, Paranoid)

Night 1:
Rebel - Ali - Mafia Insane/Paranoid
PS - Ali - Town
Villain - Ali - Mafia
Ali - Rebel - Mafia

If Rebel is mafia;
Villain - Insane
PS - Sane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Paranoid
Can still be a mafia.

If Villain is mafia;
Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
PS - Naive
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Paranoid
Can still be a mafia.

If PS is mafia;
Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
Villain - ??? If I'm sane = Ali is mafia, if Insane= Rebel is a mafia
Rudi - Sane/Naive
Ali - Insane/Paranoid
This means PS is town.

If Ali is mafia;
Rebel - Paranoid
Villain - Sane
Rudi - Insane/Naive
PS - Naive
Again not clear but so many less options to choose from.

 

[Villain]

My understanding:

Rebel: Insane
PS: Naive
Rudi: Sane
Ali: Paranoid

Villain: Mafia

Ali. Needs to post his investigation ASAP!

Thanks for distracting the town on basis of nothing and attracting unnecessary attention towards me based on nothing. You gave him the spot "Paranoid Cop", he used it.

No Lynch for now.

All of a sudden from nowhere.

I got Rebel as mafia, its clear that I'm Paranoid cop.

Using the plot @Perfect Square gave him, posting after everyone posted their results, spoke the least. You be the judge @Rebel2k17, you've the game in hand.

Lynch: AliB[DOUBLEPOST=1521556982][/DOUBLEPOST]

To my understanding;
Rebel - Paranoid
PS - Naive
Rudi - Insane
Villain - Sane

Ali is mafia.

This is it.

 

[AliB]

Rebel has the hammer on Villain, he set the the plot perfectly but sorry Yash your game is over.