End Game Dethwing Classic - Mafia (Rebel2k17) wins!

[RUDI]

No way. Who posted that?

Ali - paranoid/insane/naive/sane cop

Just check if my analysis is correct.

 

[Villain]

Just check if my analysis is correct.

He can't be Naive since his investigation has me as a mafia.

 

[Villain]

Let's say Ali was lying about Villain being Mafia:

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Town

Rebel - Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Naive
Rudi - insane/Paranoid
Villain - sane/Naive

FOS: AliB

That analysis is correct, moreover it ticks Rebel not being a Sane Cop.

 

[RUDI]

He can't be Naive since his investigation has me as a mafia.

Thanks, noticed now that I at least have him as naive in the actual analysis lower down the post.

 

[Villain]

Any reasons for suspecting me @Rebel2k17?[DOUBLEPOST=1521538391][/DOUBLEPOST]
I wasn't active, thus was the last to post.

I may well believe it since that could be genuine but again sadly that's the tactic people use these days which isn't nice. We've nothing strong against you at the moment anyway.

 

[Perfect Square]

My Analysis:

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

Case 1: Assume Rebel is Mafia.

PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 2: Assume PS is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 3: Assume Villain is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Ali - Sane/Paranoid

Case 4: Assume Rudi is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 5: Assume Ali is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Insane/Naive

By counting the majority of possible cop role of a person this can be a Possibly:

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid (4 times both)
PS - Insane/Naive (4 times both)
Villain - Insane/Naive (4 times both)
Rudi - Insane (4 times)
Ali - Sane/Paranoid (4 times both)

I know this may be stupid thing. But by seeing how math works (That if one number or equation is wrong whole answer gets wrong).
So Only Rudi got 100% cleared. This his role is Insane. Which makes me wonder how?

Since,
Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
Ali - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Villain - Isane/Naive

How can Rudi get just Insane in the calculations? Hmmm.. Mafia?

 

[Perfect Square]

Okay. Now I'm a bit confused. Have I messed up?

 

[RUDI]

Okay. Now I'm a bit confused. Have I messed up?

Must be ... otherwise the mod messed up by not informing me that I am scum [DOUBLEPOST=1521542322][/DOUBLEPOST]

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid

Rebel is insane or paranoid

 

[Perfect Square]

UPDATED!
My bad I messed up Rudi's analysis.

My Analysis:

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 1: Assume Rebel is Mafia.

PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 2: Assume PS is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 3: Assume Villain is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Paranoid

Case 4: Assume Rudi is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Insane/Paranoid

Case 5: Assume Ali is Mafia.

Rebel - Sane/Insane/Paranoid
PS - Sane/Insane/Naive
Villain - Sane/Insane/Naive
Rudi - Insane/Naive

Posibilites:

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid (4 times)
PS - Insane/Naive (4 times)
Villain - Insane/Naive (4 times)
Rudi - Insane/Naive (4 times)
Ali - Sane/Paranoid (4 times)

So if we go by my analysis. Either Me, Villain or Rudi is Mafia.

 

[RUDI]

From what I can see is
Rebel - paranoid
Rudi - insane

So if we go by my analysis. Either Me, Villain or Rudi is Mafia.

Assuming everyone told the truth about their findings ...

 

[Perfect Square]

From what I can see is
Rebel - paranoid
Rudi - insane

If we go by yours then:

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Villain - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Paranoid

This cuts of Ali as well. So either me or Villain.

 

[Perfect Square]

Going off for few hours now. I'll re-check my analysis if I get much time.

 

[RUDI]

Sane Cop - aka normal cop. Will return a correct result.
Insane Cop - Will return the opposite result.
Paranoid Cop - Will return a mafia result.
Naive Cop - Will return a town result

Rebel - Rudi - Mafia
PS - Villain - Town
Villain - Rebel - Town
Rudi - Ali - Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

Assuming the following:
Rebel - paranoid
Rudi - insane

-----------------------------------
Rebel (Paranoid) - Rudi - Mafia Rudi Town
PS - Villain - Town
Villain (Naive ?) - Rebel - Town Rebel Town
Rudi (insane) - Ali - Town Ali Town
Ali - Villain - Mafia

------------------------------------
I'd like to hear @AliB analysis please?

 

[Gaurav_7]

If we go by yours then:

Rebel - Sane/Paranoid
PS - Insane/Naive
Villain - Insane/Naive
Rudi - Insane/Naive
Ali - Sane/Paranoid

This cuts of Ali as well. So either me or Villain.

Is Ali is Sane then Villain must be mafia?

Guys I don't think these individual analyses are going to work. Please let us stick to one logical one according to dethy mafiawiki page and keep to it. By that no one is clear. And if we say lynch someone and get it wrong, then we give the mafia a very clear headstart which is dangerous in such a small game. PS analysis hurt my head tbh! I have my doubts on Ali but not not enough to lynch him. So atm No Lynch.

 

[Villain]

I appreciate the work PS and Rudi has put in, solid town vibes from both of them. But, also gotta agree with the fact that it's very hard to crack on the the basis of Night 0 investigations. We should be able to make a lot more sense the next Day, right now not only difficult but there's a lot of confusion since we're all on different tracks. Let's stick to the plan but that shouldn't mean we should not be trying something else.