Mini Mafia 2 - End Game. Mafia (Barmyarmy) wins

[barmyarmy]

I get the whole miller = cop thing but I really doubt there would effectively be two cops in a game this small. BKB and Hedger.
Ultimately I can see that it comes down to whether you believe hedger/Zhuorb or me/Varun are the mafia team.
It's on you and PD to work that out between you.

 

[ved_]

Oh fearsome tweak. I'll be modkilled? Maaaaan, I never thought it was against the rules. -_-

----------

Also, if I am killed, I think this will actually benefit the town. Just because it is easier to find the mafia out of 3 people rather than 4.

 

[Aditya]

Not taking Zhourb's case into consideration, just saying generally, I thought it would be obvious that quoting your role pm is against the rules of mafia games. However, I will not mod kill him as it wasn't mentioned in the first post.

Vote Count
Varun (1) - Hedger_14
Hedger_14 (1) - Barmyarmy
Zhourb (1) - Varun

It takes 4 votes to lynch someone

 

[Gaurav_7]

It did say the basic rules apply, isn't it?

 

[ved_]

User, why are you sooo eager to get me modkilled? Sorry Aditya, didn't know it was not against the rules. However, for future issues, I'd make this a personal rule for all games that I play.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Just the rules plus it makes it a hell lot easier for the town. Beloved princess, if the role is there in the game, shouldn't have been there at all at first place. One wrong step and you're gone.

 

[Aditya]

It is against the rules.

User, I personally feel that as I didn't mention this rule separately I can make this a exception and as none of you know whether Zhourb is telling the truth or not, me commenting too much on this wouldn't be a good idea. I should say this generally though, that quoting your role pm doesn't has a big impact on the game but still it is a rule that must be followed but it isn't like it's something for which someone must be modkilled. It's not like he has taken a pic of his role pm or something because that's something for which one must be mod killed and as someone mentioned earlier, the players playing don't know whether he is telling the truth or lying so it's better that we go along with the game as it doesn't have big/any impact on the game and discuss this after the game finishes.

 

[barmyarmy]

It could just be a very clever ploy to throw us off scent

 

[Gaurav_7]

Alright. I feel I need Hedger and PD to post as well. Mafia could be either of the pair. I just hate it when I've to go with my instincts!

 

[Varun]

Isn't it that you need to quote your PM under the

quote box

to get modkilled?

I am still pretty sure that Zhuorb is mafia, but now feel that lynching Hedger is a better idea. Still, we'd have to wait for him to post first, which is going to take some more time.

 

[puddleduck]

Ok, I'm convinced Zhuorb is mafia. I just can't buy into the whole Princess claim. I think his writing it down is potentially a subtle ploy. As you say, he could be mod killed, but then, he may well not have actually written down his Pm so he can't be modkilled for it...

I want to hear from Hedger again before I proceed, but I am leaning towards lynching Zhuorb and Varun roleblocking Hedger.

The issue I am having, is that Varun's claim is also slightly suspect to me.

As I've said User, I am thinking that BKB was for all intents and purposes the cop, and Barmy is essentially a town cop because I think mafia have to actively visit their kill and he can spot that. I think princess/cop claims from Hedger and Zhuorb are nonsense, and don't exist within the game.

To me, we have:

2 mafia - Hedger and Zhuorb?
1 watcher - Barmy
1 roleblocker - Varun.
1 Miller - PD
1 Vanilla - User
1 Cop/Doc limited use role - BKB.

To me that seems a reasonably balanced setup I think. The tracker would essentially have unearthed any initial dodgy behaviour allowing BKB to use a one time investigative option to confirm one mafia. Adi makes it seem his death is a massive loss, which to me implies he was the only Cop/Doc role in the game.

 

[barmyarmy]

Once again tracker and watcher are different. I also would like to hear more from Hedger but, if people are accepting my claim, I don't know why we're not lynching him. If we lynch Zhuorb and he is telling the truth it's game over. The only evidence against him is his posts rather than power role info.

 

[puddleduck]

You know what I mean. Tracker then

I still might lynch Hedger, I just want to hear what Hedger has to say since he claimed cop.

 

[Sedition]

I'm a bit nervous about PD's game with all these jailbreakers, jailkeepers, watchers, trackers, dogcatchers getting around

 

[hedger_14]

Well considering from my point of view, barmy and Varun are mafia, that mean's there would be a Beloved Princess, Cop, 1 vanilla, 1 miller, and a one time investigate and protective role, which seems to be balanced a bit, especially with day start. Really though, since you are saying it's me/zhuorb or colin/varun, and doesn't having a tracker/roleblocker/JOAT seem a bit overpowered.

And sorry, it's been a lot to read so I'm not sure. Although as much as I don't want to, I think Zhuorb should be modkilled for quoting his role pm :/