Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[Aditya]

I was planning to run a game. Diwali break got over on friday and hence I'm no more as free as I was the previous week.

----------

Sedition, I don't see the point of you questioning my stance or anyone else' on a no lynch. You placed your lynch here. You neither supported a no lynch or went after any other member. To sum up, I don't understand what your tactics were on day 1.

 

[thedon5]

PD actually replied back saying you are now dead? That's weird. Mods don't usually reply back saying that you are now dead.

He did for me last game. It was part of his reply to reveal the result of my night action though.

----------

The whole no lynch fiasco seems ridiculous to me.

I thought that was generally what everyone did... If they can't come to a conclusion, no lynch. That was PD's advice to me in the first game so that's why I did it here too.

 

[Sedition]

As opposed to doing nothing right? Sitting on your hands and saying no one seems suspicious is only going to get you so far.

I'm certain that at least one of the first 3 initial no-lynchers are mafia. Maybe it's User and he's copping heat from other directions, so I don't see the need to focus on him yet.

 

[thedon5]

Obviously no-one has posted anything overly suspicious yet, though the lack of activity certainly is. Fact is a lot of guys have been barely active so it's hard to pinpoint one or two.

 

[Sedition]

Which is why narrowing it down to say, 3 or 4 and going through them one by one helps. You can try to discredit my tactics all you want, but it has worked well for me in the past.

If the first 3 people to jump in and vote no lynch on an already short day are all town, then god help us. Last game Days 1 and 2 lasted about 5 days each and the town won with mislynches to spare, kinda shows how beneficial dragging a day out as long as possible is.

 

[RPHKR]

The no-lynch theory doesn't satisfy me enough to enforce lynch. I think it was a usual vote to end the boring day. It might be in both ways though.

Sedition, I agree with you here:

If the first 3 people to jump in and vote no lynch on an already short day are all town, then god help us. Last game Days 1 and 2 lasted about 5 days each and the town won with mislynches to spare, kinda shows how beneficial dragging a day out as long as possible is.

BKB said "he was killed before he attempted to kill". So if it's true, then the 'doctor' theory put forth by Sedition isn't possible.

 

[Manly]

I was planning to run a game. Diwali break got over on friday and hence I'm no more as free as I was the previous week.

----------

Sedition, I don't see the point of you questioning my stance or anyone else' on a no lynch. You placed your lynch here. You neither supported a no lynch or went after any other member. To sum up, I don't understand what your tactics were on day 1.

I'm inclined to agree with Sedition, I'm on my phone so won't be able to quote further posts, but as I recall yourself User and Don are now high on my list for 2 mafia of the three of you.

Unlynch

Fos: those three, especially Adi because from experience, Mafia try and bury themselves in majorities.

I'll be returning to treva however.

 

[treva]

All those saying I'm quiet and that I'm mafia (Ben - becoming to predictable fella), it's merely the fact I've not actually been on the forum. If I was constantly viewing the thread and not posting then that's a different matter. Again, I'm currently in a uni seminar on my iPod, so can't post much more than a brief defence, considering I'm apparently being put under 'pressure'.

 

[Manly]

*too

 

[treva]

Bastard.

 

[thedon5]

Honestly, I'm wondering whether this whole no lynch thing is just a way of making sure you lynch someone today, or actual suspicion.

Anyway, I feel I've defended myself well enough regarding this 'suspicion'. Bear in mind that was my first day 1, I have no idea what usually happens on the first day and I certainly didn't know that putting in a no lynch is considered so 'suspicious'...

 

[Sedition]

I thought I moved on from you, so not sure why you felt the need to continue defending yourself, or the others involved when 1 has already been confirmed scum.

So you think both User and Aditya are clean then because they also no lynched? I mean, you think me going after you guys is ridiculous, so you must. Seems like a good start for you to narrow down who you think the actual mafia are then.

 

[thedon5]

You and Manly haven't moved on from me and the other no lynchers, look back a few posts to the one above treva's.

No, I'm not saying User and Aditya are most likely clean. I'm saying purely using the fact that they put in a no lynch isn't a good enough reason to get overly suspicious of them.

I'm more suspicious of the guys who aren't posting. Abhas was Godfather last time and posted about as much up to this point in that game as he has here. We haven't heard from Zhuorb for a while. Papa smurf has done little other than putting in the lynch on treva. So we'll have to wait and see.

 

[treva]

On this no lynch situation, as far as I see when there is nothing to talk about on the second day people always target those who 'no lynch'. Would it not then be a stupid decision as a mafia to all jump on the bandwagon of a 'no lynch'?

 

[Manly]

You and Manly haven't moved on from me and the other no lynchers, look back a few posts to the one above treva's.

No, I'm not saying User and Aditya are most likely clean. I'm saying purely using the fact that they put in a no lynch isn't a good enough reason to get overly suspicious of them.

I'm more suspicious of the guys who aren't posting. Abhas was Godfather last time and posted about as much up to this point in that game as he has here. We haven't heard from Zhuorb for a while. Papa smurf has done little other than putting in the lynch on treva. So we'll have to wait and see.

I've not singled you out and put pressure on you have I? I merely cast you in the same net as two others. So for you to now come out and say I've not moved on from you is very suspicious in my book.