Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[RPHKR]

Umm. BKB, who did you target? Was he protected? or you're killed before it?

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Interesting.

BKB, are you allowed to give information out as KP? Cos if PD isn't revealing roles, then technically we're not supposed to know. Not that I'm complaining, but you could be mis-leading us if your new roles is also not pro-town.

If BKB is telling the truth, then the 1st line in the write-up refers to either a cult, or a recruitable mafia being recruited. If it's the latter, the 3rd line could refer to the mafia team being not fully assembled yet as they're still looking for a member. OR, it could refer to Matt P saving KP, and that's why BKB's kill didnt go through. Or the doc just made a good save.

Back to the game, this is going to sound hypocritical considering my own activity, but treva has posted almost next to nothing.

Lynch: treva

 

[BKB1991]

Well all I know is that I was unsuccessful in killing my target. I dont know the reason why. The PM basically said I was unsuccessful and that I am now dead.

Lol, I dont see the reason why I should reveal my target? I had to choose someone or PD would choose it randomly.

 

[Abhas]

From the writeup we can conclude one thing, KP was killed by the mafia, and not by the person he targeted (something like a role being night unkillable, and the person trying to kill him, gets killed instead).

Maybe the death of the SK put the cult into action.. That would explain the reintegration thing.

I didn't realize there was a 48 hour deadline to the day!! We arent going anywhere so far.
Lynch: user

Although the 1st day vote was random, I wasn't too convinced with his reply, besides, since we don't have much to go from, a little bit of pressure would be helpful.

 

[Gaurav_7]

BKB, are you allowed to give information out as KP? Cos if PD isn't revealing roles, then technically we're not supposed to know. Not that I'm complaining, but you could be mis-leading us if your new roles is also not pro-town.

This. I don't think we are allowed to reveal the previous role info.

I didn't realize there was a 48 hour deadline to the day!! We arent going anywhere so far.
Lynch: user

Although the 1st day vote was random, I wasn't too convinced with his reply, besides, since we don't have much to go from, a little bit of pressure would be helpful.

Interesting hearing that you weren't convinced with my reply. I don't actually remember defending myself or replying anything to those 'not really called for' votes. They were random. So, my posts were random as well.

Coming back to BKB, I think he is experienced enough to know that we shouldn't reveal the previous role info. He is the suspect for me now. Or, I'd want PD to confirm whether he could reveal it. Till then,

FOS: BKB1991

 

[Sedition]

Still nothing from Aditya? Strange. Treva's post was a whole lot of nothing. And Manly also said he'd get back to us. Probably no chance of getting anyone lynched until people actually start paying attention.

The only possibility I see for BKB being cult would be if he conveniently targeted Varun and converted him. I guess coming back as mafia would be okay, but that's one less person they'd know to target.
Have a feeling he's misleading us with his vague responses and being defensive about who he targeted. I also don't remember PD ever sending a PM to tell me that I was unsuccessful and dead.

 

[thedon5]

Perhaps he targeted someone who was protected by the doc? That's the best I can gather from "unsuccessful".

When I died last game PD sent me a message to say I died after using my role that night, so I do believe BKB when he says. His general vagueness, not sure I am convinced by his current role or his previous role. We'll see how things pan out though, it's just a bit suspicious atm, nothing fully concrete.

We'll see, I have read very little from most of the guys in the game so far. Honestly even if we found someone we were certain was mafia, we'd have trouble lynching him with the general lack of activity from absolutely everyone.

Anyway, let's get moving. 24 hours left max, so we really need to come to a decision now.

 

[Manly]

I said treva plays a quiet game when he's mafia and there's still been nothing from him. Time to apply some pressure.

Lynch: treva

 

[Sedition]

I think RPHKR was likely correct about the doc protection scenario not being possible. As far as night actions go, the kill priority is fairly low overall, however when mafia target SK, their kill often overrides the SK's. It can depend on the mod though, sometimes if the SK submits their kill before the mafia kill him, it may be successful.

Pretty much the only way we're gonna lynch someone today is if all the active people are town. I'm gonna lay one down on Aditya and see if we can get a response today..

Lynch: Aditya

 

[barmyarmy]

From the writeup we can conclude one thing, KP was killed by the mafia, and not by the person he targeted (something like a role being night unkillable, and the person trying to kill him, gets killed instead).

Maybe the death of the SK put the cult into action.. That would explain the reintegration thing.

I didn't realize there was a 48 hour deadline to the day!! We arent going anywhere so far.
Lynch: user

Although the 1st day vote was random, I wasn't too convinced with his reply, besides, since we don't have much to go from, a little bit of pressure would be helpful.

As you say, he didn't bother with a defence. Therefore good a place to start as any.

FOS: User2010

 

[Aditya]

Sedition, you sure are aware about the time difference between India and Australia. Been a busy weekend though, apologizes for my inactivity.

Someone raised a point about me jumping on bandwagon on day 1 and going for a no lynch. So what? Did we really had any discussion at all? What option I had apart from going for a no lynch?

@RPHKR - You really expect BKB to reveal who he targeted?

The PM basically said I was unsuccessful and that I am now dead.

PD actually replied back saying you are now dead? That's weird. Mods don't usually reply back saying that you are now dead.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Yeah, didn't bother. And, won't now as well tbh as these votes don't really make sense. If it is that I didn't defend myself earlier then, it is more senseless for someone like you to say tbf. Unless ofcourse you are mafia and wanting a RC from me.

----------

My post was for Colin.

 

[Aditya]

Not that I want to defend User, I've got no read on any player at all but I have to agree with him here. He has nothing to defend himself for, regardless of the pressure being put on him, I still don't really get what he has to defend himself for..

 

[Manly]

Sedition, you sure are aware about the time difference between India and Australia. Been a busy weekend though, apologizes for my inactivity.

Someone raised a point about me jumping on bandwagon on day 1 and going for a no lynch. So what? Did we really had any discussion at all? What option I had apart from going for a no lynch?

@RPHKR - You really expect BKB to reveal who he targeted?



PD actually replied back saying you are now dead? That's weird. Mods don't usually reply back saying that you are now dead.

That may be because PD cocked up and sent an initial PM saying you're successful... Actually wait no you're dead.

 

[Sedition]

Sedition, you sure are aware about the time difference between India and Australia. Been a busy weekend though, apologizes for my inactivity.

Someone raised a point about me jumping on bandwagon on day 1 and going for a no lynch. So what? Did we really had any discussion at all? What option I had apart from going for a no lynch?

@RPHKR - You really expect BKB to reveal who he targeted?



PD actually replied back saying you are now dead? That's weird. Mods don't usually reply back saying that you are now dead.

The timezone excuse doesn't fly with me when a game day covers multiple days. We're not that far apart in reality I think you were planning to mod a game since you had more free time, so just found it suspicious that it took 75% of the day to pass before checking in.

The alternative to voting no lynch in a 48 hour day is to vote nothing and let the time expire if things are going nowhere, rather than attempting to shorten it.

Within that period there was thedon, User, you and BKB that voted to no lynch. BKB we know was scum and acting alone, so that doesn't paint a pretty for the rest of you.