Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[Sedition]

Because he was acting as though he had a result on me. I can already rule out numerous other roles that would give incriminating evidence on me, because no such evidence exists.

 

[Abhas]

His recent elevation had given him twice the pulling power.

I'm not too sure if there would be recruit able mafia, cult, SK, masons in a 14 player game. Something just doesn't seem too right about this.

No matter what, he knew he would carry on. He was in charge of it all. Nothing could take him down.

Sounds like a night-immune role. Could be GF, maybe there is a horcrux or something like we had in the Harry potter game which would make him invincible. Could also be a commuter. They would be immune to night actions, however, they won't have a role of their own either.

He knew where he worked was a joke, but it was his chance. He only hoped he could find the truth. He just had to find some promising leads.

Lie-detector maybe? "Find the truth" and "promising leads" imply the existence of one.

The last para looks like a mason, or could be a cult, considering they were "looking for their future". Cult would explain why his other partner hasn't showed up with the 'dossier'.

----------

Because he was acting as though he had a result on me. I can already rule out numerous other roles that would give incriminating evidence on me, because no such evidence exists.

You've covered your tracks well enough?

Why only insane, Why couldn't he be a paranoid cop? because that would still leave a chance for you to be mafia?

Also, what got you worried he has a result? Your guilt?

 

[Sedition]

Paranoid, insane, doesn't make a difference. I know he's not a cop or he wouldn't have given up on me.

I remember last game when we were mafia and you said you'd come to my defence if things were looking bad. Makes me wonder if you're doing the same here since you didn't mention Aditya even being remotely suspicious.

 

[treva]

The reason the role block on me didn't work was because I have no night role. Smurf targeted me because of his attempt to lynch me.

 

[Abhas]

The reason the role block on me didn't work was because I have no night role. Smurf targeted me because of his attempt to lynch me.

A roleblock on a person without a role is not unsuccessful, it is simply wasteful.
I never asked why Smurf targeted you.. It's not rocket science to judge why he would claim to target you. I put forward the fact that a doc would probably not protect you.

@sedition, no I'm not defending anybody here. I'm just putting forward my observations and opinions. From what I see, there is a brigade of people wanting to go after Aditya, and so far none have convinced me why. Yes, I'm suspicious of him, but the same way I'm suspicious of 10 others.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I dont know why I was unsuccessful Abhas. My initial thought was that treva didnt have a night role. Someone mentioned that there could be no doc, but a jailkeeper instead, and they targeted me last night. That to me would sound the most logical.

And I dont understand this whole priority thing over who's kill goes 1st. I thought they would both happen, and if the SK and GF target each other, they both die in the cross-fire. That's certainly been the case for all the games I've played in.

----------

Massive FOS at Zhuorb and thedon.

All game, both have you bandwagoned on to lynches straight away. The no lynch, the Smurf lynch, and now the Aditya lynch.

Highly suspicous of User2010 as well. He said his phone isnt working, but clearly it works enough for him to post. Nice little excuse to stay in the shadows.

----------

I dont know what to make of Aditya. I would have lynched him straight away if this wasnt his usual way of playing. Makes an easy target for the town to waste a day on if you're mafia.

 

[Sedition]

@sedition, no I'm not defending anybody here. I'm just putting forward my observations and opinions. From what I see, there is a brigade of people wanting to go after Aditya, and so far none have convinced me why. Yes, I'm suspicious of him, but the same way I'm suspicious of 10 others.

So 10 others + Aditya + yourself + the 4 people you just FOS. I don't think there are that many players still alive. Unless you mean you're no more suspicious of Aditya than you are everyone else still in the game?

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I'm not too sure about Smurf's claim of roleblocker now. If he's the roleblocker, and there's another one in the game, he would have definitely been counter claimed. Even if I consider him to be the town blocker, the mafia blocker would have counter claimed easily, knowing that PD's not revealing roles, so there would be no way to verify the claim.

True, but they would've put themselves under suspicion when it would've revealed that I am Jonathan Trott.

 

[Abhas]

So 10 others + Aditya + yourself + the 4 people you just FOS. I don't think there are that many players still alive. Unless you mean you're no more suspicious of Aditya than you are everyone else still in the game?

That's exactly what I mean.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

Paranoid, insane, doesn't make a difference. I know he's not a cop or he wouldn't have given up on me.

I remember last game when we were mafia and you said you'd come to my defence if things were looking bad. Makes me wonder if you're doing the same here since you didn't mention Aditya even being remotely suspicious.

wait, what? if he was a cop he would still be going after you then?

 

[Sedition]

I dont know why I was unsuccessful Abhas. My initial thought was that treva didnt have a night role. Someone mentioned that there could be no doc, but a jailkeeper instead, and they targeted me last night. That to me would sound the most logical.

And I dont understand this whole priority thing over who's kill goes 1st. I thought they would both happen, and if the SK and GF target each other, they both die in the cross-fire. That's certainly been the case for all the games I've played in.

----------

Massive FOS at Zhuorb and thedon.

All game, both have you bandwagoned on to lynches straight away. The no lynch, the Smurf lynch, and now the Aditya lynch.

Highly suspicous of User2010 as well. He said his phone isnt working, but clearly it works enough for him to post. Nice little excuse to stay in the shadows.

----------

I dont know what to make of Aditya. I would have lynched him straight away if this wasnt his usual way of playing. Makes an easy target for the town to waste a day on if you're mafia.

If there's no doc and instead a jailkeeper on the town side, then I don't know why we'd also have a roleblocker. I agree that a jailkeeper is possible, but if you're a town roleblocker, it would be the mafia's equivalent of one and the protection side could be used to protect against the SK.

From PD's SK/GF games, mafia's kill takes preference as far as I'm aware, but has varied whether they have a vest or not.

----------

wait, what? if he was a cop he would still be going after you then?

If he was cop with a guilty like he came into today suggesting, then yes he would still be going after me. He would only have guilty if he was a cop variant, but I know he has none of these possible roles.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I'm just highlighting a possibility.

The mafia RB could have roleblocked me as well.

----------

Alright, I'm not going to be online for a while.

Treva's yet to post anything of note, despite being online, and has himself admitted that he's got no role.

Worth the gamble.

Lynch: Treva

 

[barmyarmy]

Just checking in to say I'm now away til Sunday. Will check in on my phone when I can but don't expect anything substantive.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

If he was cop with a guilty like he came into today suggesting, then yes he would still be going after me. He would only have guilty if he was a cop variant, but I know he has none of these possible roles.

just read back and can't find anyway from today where he has suggested he was a cop with a guilty.

maybe i missed it but all i saw was you saying the only role you could give him credit for was insane cop.

again maybe i have just missed it, but it seems like you have made it up.

 

[Sedition]

It's pretty easy for me to narrow down what roles he could possibly have when his first act is to start the day like that and I know I'm town. I made my points clear enough when I lynched him and Aditya's done fearsome tweak all for the entire game, I'm pretty confident with my reasoning.

Something seems weird about you, Colin and Abhas, but unless someone posts something concrete or Aditya comes back and actually does something to convince people that he's town, I'm not going in circles with you guys.