Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[thedon5]

I don't think anyone else so far has wanted either of us dead...

 

[treva]

Colin, you were blocked on night 1 and hence didn't get any result on Sedition. Now, why did you want to investigate Abhas on the next night phase and not Sedition again? If you say, you wanted to know the alignment of a important player like Abhas, that makes sense but then why didn't you investigate him on night 1? Now, on night 3, you again investigated Sediton, so if I may say "back to circle one".

As much as I would like to believe Colin, I can't help and say, if he and Sedition are indeed working together, his claim is terrific and most safe. Abhas is dead and hence a cleared townie. Sedition is his mafia partner and claiming cop, helps his own team mate. I'm just pointing out the possibility, I might well be wrong here.

I'm pretty sure Smurf is done and it's between Colin and thedon from my perspective..

Aditya clearly thinks Colin is mafia whilst Sedition thinks one of you two should now be targets.

 

[thedon5]

Aditya seems hell bent on getting Sedition, more so than Colin.

 

[Aditya]

If you read through my posts, I'm suspicious of both. I've just targeted Sedition, rest haven't. Now, I'm shifting to Colin. I mentioned earlier, if there are two members on whom Manly and I had the same views, they are Sedition and Colin. I'm going after the latter now but that doesn't mean, Sedition is confirmed townie for me.

 

[thedon5]

Aditya clearly thinks Colin is mafia whilst Sedition thinks one of you two should now be targets.

Well let me get it out of the way now then. I have contributed all the information I can really, I've given a solid claim and have been contributing a lot. Go after me if you want, but the fact remains that we still have a list of guys who still could be Mafia who are either not posting or refusing to claim. We can go after one of the cops based solely on the theory that it doesn't make sense to have two cops, or we can actually move on and try and get claims out of the remaining guys so that we can work on lynching Mafia members and not townies.

 

[Aditya]

Basically what you're saying is, we should lynch Colin if not you, right?

 

[thedon5]

Nope, I'm saying instead of going on this theory that there can't be two cops, I want us to go for the guys who haven't claimed yet. Ste, RPHKR and BKB. Possibly Sedition too, though both me and Colin have town results on him. His play has also been leaning town.

 

[Aditya]

Even if they claim it wont prove anything. How do we know, the ones who have claimed are telling the truth! Among those who haven't claimed, Ste is the one who has been "under the radar, so to say. RPHKR has contributed, so has BKB.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

Nope, I'm saying instead of going on this theory that there can't be two cops, I want us to go for the guys who haven't claimed yet. Ste, RPHKR and BKB. Possibly Sedition too, though both me and Colin have town results on him. His play has also been leaning town.

i don't think it's just simply not believing there are two cops, more that there are two cops and a tracker, it seems like a lot of investigation roles.

 

[treva]

I honestly wouldn't be surprised if both of you who are claiming cop are mafia and playing this off each other to keep both of you alive long enough to get into a position where you can't lose. Even if one of you are voted off then the other is effectively cleared and can continue right to the very end.

 

[puddleduck]

When I'm working like now can ssomeone post a vote count if we go through a few pages please? Means i can still stop things if a lynch occurs, thanks

 

[Aditya]

Yes, Ste's point does make sense. 4 mafia's, 3 investigative roles on the town side just cannot be true. I believe User, a tracker can be in this game. 2 cops is a big question mark. Trev too makes a valid point. For now, I'd stick with my lynch on Colin. We've got some time till the day ends, right?

 

[Papa_Smurf]

When I'm working like now can ssomeone post a vote count if we go through a few pages please? Means i can still stop things if a lynch occurs, thanks

Vote Count

Papa Smurf (5) - Barmyarmy, RPHKR, BKB, thedon, Treva
Barmyarmy (1) - Aditya
User (3) - Papa Smurf, Ste
thedon (1) - User2010

If Treva's telling the truth, I should be hammered, right?

----------

My comments will be somewhat valuable in a few minutes when PD reveals I was telling the truth.

I'm still 100% certain thedon is mafia. Especially after his claim.
Not sure what to make of User's claim, but from the looks of it sounds solid. Poor gameplay from him then cos the way he went after me and the way he initially claimed had scum written all over it.

 

[barmyarmy]

whilst Colin is a 'former captain'. This links back to the night write-up where a former captain killed Abhas.

Just to point out that User has me visiting Abhas the night before he was killed so I don't see how I can be the former captain.

----------

Yes, Ste's point does make sense. 4 mafia's, 3 investigative roles on the town side just cannot be true. I believe User, a tracker can be in this game. 2 cops is a big question mark. Trev too makes a valid point. For now, I'd stick with my lynch on Colin. We've got some time till the day ends, right?

Clearly there aren't going to be 3 investigate roles. One of the cops is either naive (and effectively vanilla) or someone is lying.
We did have a game recently with 2 cops plus this is the biggest game we've ha in a while. I'm not convinced that thedon is mafia at the moment.

 

[treva]

And I think User is mafia, so I am not intitled to believe what he says.