Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)
- Thread starter puddleduck
- Start date
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
i doubt it, the way it has played out if any of them got lynched and were mafia it'd go a long way to clearing the other two, but i think that they would have sacrificed a mafia to clear the other two at this stage when there was a strong chance we wouldn't have lynched a mafia member today anyway.
treva
ICC Chairman
I think at least two of you are, and I am still toying with the possibility of it being all three. The others who have not claimed yet may all, or mainly, be town that haven't wanted to reveal their roles as of yet. There could also be people who have claimed that do have power roles but didn't want to throw them out there.
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Dunno if the lynch is hammered yet, but as far as I'm concerned regarding Smurf's claim that he'd caught User and Thedon out by lying about his action, all he really did as far as I can tell is have two PRs out themselves.
If Thedon is mafia, then I think Smurf is anyway and they couldn't get their story straight about the block. More likely though, I think, thedon was reading through what he'd missed, saw the initial claims and got a bit excited when he thought User was lying about Smurf blocking no one. He did say that he was going back to read what he missed, so to me that looks more like excited town than mafia not taking in all the information.
Also I asked for his claim when he confirmed that he'd been blocked, and it came in full and looked spontaneous and honest. If he was mafia I'd expect him to try to buy a bit of time, or not contain as many details when claiming right away.
Anyway I'm certain Smurf is mafia and when lynched he might come up Jonathan Trott and no role/alignment will be revealed just like every other death, but that doesn't confirm he was town since some of the mafia could be England players. If he comes up anything else, IPL, DLF Maximum, Lalit Modi, then we can confirm we got a scum though.
If Thedon is mafia, then I think Smurf is anyway and they couldn't get their story straight about the block. More likely though, I think, thedon was reading through what he'd missed, saw the initial claims and got a bit excited when he thought User was lying about Smurf blocking no one. He did say that he was going back to read what he missed, so to me that looks more like excited town than mafia not taking in all the information.
Also I asked for his claim when he confirmed that he'd been blocked, and it came in full and looked spontaneous and honest. If he was mafia I'd expect him to try to buy a bit of time, or not contain as many details when claiming right away.
Anyway I'm certain Smurf is mafia and when lynched he might come up Jonathan Trott and no role/alignment will be revealed just like every other death, but that doesn't confirm he was town since some of the mafia could be England players. If he comes up anything else, IPL, DLF Maximum, Lalit Modi, then we can confirm we got a scum though.
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
DLF Maximum
.You must understand, I had to be quick. It was roughly two hours after treva had said he was going to hammer Smurf in one hour, and when I was roleblocked, I obviously thought it was Smurf who blocked me as he was suspicious of me the day before. So his claim seemed somewhat genuine to me at the time while in a rush to make a reply and call out User's apparent lie about Smurf visiting no-one.
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Yeah that was another point too. My post yesterday saying I wasn't sure about the Smurf lynch was a rushed one too, as the suspicion had turned from Zhuorb to Smurf while I as away, so by putting myself in your shoes, I can see it as an honest mistake.
Also I'm kinda wondering why Colin even claimed at all. He hasn't come across as CC'ing, more suggesting that there's 2 cops, so why out yourself? Just trying to create confusion or something? The results were the same anyway. I don't believe there's 2 cops, so I feel the first two mafia are Smurf and Colin.
If this lynch hasn't been hammered, and now Trev is hinting at people fake claiming when PRs, then Trev is probably the third. If PD's just taking his time updating it then Trev is cleared and considering we've had next to nothing from RPHKR and Zhuorb today, they're not doing a good job as town if Ste or someone else hiding away is the third.
Also I'm kinda wondering why Colin even claimed at all. He hasn't come across as CC'ing, more suggesting that there's 2 cops, so why out yourself? Just trying to create confusion or something? The results were the same anyway. I don't believe there's 2 cops, so I feel the first two mafia are Smurf and Colin.
If this lynch hasn't been hammered, and now Trev is hinting at people fake claiming when PRs, then Trev is probably the third. If PD's just taking his time updating it then Trev is cleared and considering we've had next to nothing from RPHKR and Zhuorb today, they're not doing a good job as town if Ste or someone else hiding away is the third.
RPHKR
National Board President
- Joined
- Oct 9, 2008
Spare me some time to read the pages guys. I wasn't online yesterday. I came on yesternight but just had time to make a quick surf.
----------
A roleblocker, 2 cops, a tracker? That's really confusing.
Let me analyse the claims and night actions.
First mentioned that he blocked thedon, then quickly changed it and said that he didn't block anyone! With the mentioning of 2 hits at one stone and claiming that he blocked noone. That's really made up. Papa has been leaning town at the start but after his claim, his actions didn't suit the play.
User posted his lynch immediately after Smurf's action posted. After mentioning that Smurf lied, he claimed tracker. Yeah it seems valid time to claim. Why would Smurf lie and say he blocked noone?
thedon came quick to lynch User saying he was blocked. His character looks funny but valid though after its linkage to the write-up. Colin comes in and claims another cop. Really confusing. 2 cops and a tracker doesn't make sense.
Though User confirmed Colin's action, there's a chance that they're mafia buddies or thedon's lying. It goes round. Tonight's action can figure out who's lying and who's not.
----------
A roleblocker, 2 cops, a tracker? That's really confusing.
Let me analyse the claims and night actions.
First mentioned that he blocked thedon, then quickly changed it and said that he didn't block anyone! With the mentioning of 2 hits at one stone and claiming that he blocked noone. That's really made up. Papa has been leaning town at the start but after his claim, his actions didn't suit the play.
User posted his lynch immediately after Smurf's action posted. After mentioning that Smurf lied, he claimed tracker. Yeah it seems valid time to claim. Why would Smurf lie and say he blocked noone?
thedon came quick to lynch User saying he was blocked. His character looks funny but valid though after its linkage to the write-up. Colin comes in and claims another cop. Really confusing. 2 cops and a tracker doesn't make sense.
Though User confirmed Colin's action, there's a chance that they're mafia buddies or thedon's lying. It goes round. Tonight's action can figure out who's lying and who's not.
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
And why is that? I can't believe you and Ste tbh. Just ignoring anything and everything I post and it's like you have made up your mind about me. What makes you believe I am mafia? All this only if you are towm which we should know now that you have voted Smurf.
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
Yeah Ste has looked scummy for me in the past two days.
treva
ICC Chairman
I assume PD hasn't had time for the write up yet. In either case he'd just posts vote count to let you know.
User, I'm ignoring your posts because I believe you are lying. I don't have to listen to anything anyone says, so not gonna change because you 'can't believe' what I'm doing.
User, I'm ignoring your posts because I believe you are lying. I don't have to listen to anything anyone says, so not gonna change because you 'can't believe' what I'm doing.
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
as i said i'm not going to claim now as it'd be stupid of me to do so until the next day. i can't really explain what i've been doing and why without giving my claim away either.
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
I haven't just decided you are mafia and then ignored the whole thread. that isn't what happened. even if you say the exact same thing about six times it still isn't what has happened.
----------
But as it stands not sure if smurf has been hammered by treva or not, if i vote now he definitely has enough, but will that stop us from founding out if the double vote is genuine or not?
Similar threads
