Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[ste_mc_efc]

Because you had to kill a confirmed townie and he was the one who was guaranteed not to be protected.

but it'd make it more difficult to avoid being lynched and to get a mis-lynch through today.

 

[thedon5]

Because you had to kill a confirmed townie and he was the one who was guaranteed not to be protected.

Aditya, Zhuorb???

----------

Well I'm glad you solved the difficulty of who my mafia partner is cos you were struggling before when only you and ste were the viable candidates.

What have I "made up" about your posts?

Keep on straw clutching, you are going to lynch off Aditya next as Mafia masion.

Suggests to others I am making stuff up. When I'm not at all in any posts.

 

[barmyarmy]

That's not making something up about your post. That's just pointing out how illogical you're being.

----------

Aditya, Zhuorb???

You can ask RPHKR when he comes online but the chances are one of those two was protected. Try to kill them and it's a 50% success rate.
Killing Treva was the obvious move for the mafia no matter how much you try to pretend otherwise.

 

[thedon5]

I'm not being illogical at all, you are, you are trying to make things up about everything. You are seemingly certain about things we don't know, e.g. why treva was killled, the Mafia's exact thoughts, the roles previously in the game.

----------

That's not making something up about your post. That's just pointing out how illogical you're being.

----------



You can ask RPHKR when he comes online but the chances are one of those two was protected. Try to kill them and it's a 50% success rate.
Killing Treva was the obvious move for the mafia no matter how much you try to pretend otherwise.

No, killing you was.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm not being illogical at all, you are, you are trying to make things up about everything. You are seemingly certain about things we don't know, e.g. why treva was killled, the Mafia's exact thoughts, the roles previously in the game.

I'm explaining the mafia's thinking. How are you going to catch mafia if you can't understand their play?
As for the "mafia's exact thoughts" it's clearly facetious and doesn't merit a response. "Roles previously in the game" all I've said is that Smurf was the RB which he claimed himself...

 

[ste_mc_efc]

No, killing you was.

not really. if we were mafia night-killing colin makes it obvious that at least you were mafia. but then not killing him would give him another night to use his role... and there would be a case for it being so obvious that we couldn't have been stupid enough to do it...

but then that happens in future nights too. It'd have been worth taking the 50/50 chance. even though with RHPKR in the game it's not simply a 50/50 choice and chance between those two.

If i was mafia i definitely wouldn't have killed treva. Probably wouldn't have killed colin either and would have took the chance on one of the others and used treva to lynch off colin today.

 

[thedon5]

I'm explaining the mafia's thinking. How are you going to catch mafia if you can't understand their play?
As for the "mafia's exact thoughts" it's clearly facetious and doesn't merit a response. "Roles previously in the game" all I've said is that Smurf was the RB which he claimed himself...

Erm, you don't have to believe someone's claim, you can't as a matter of fact, just like you aren't believing mine. Especially when they are dead.

You are stating the Mafia's moves as facts. As this is clearly what reveals you as Mafia, you are using this in attempt to oust me as Mafia.

 

[ved_]

It's either ste mc efc & thedon5 or barmyarmy and RPHKR for the mafia team right now.

 

[thedon5]

not really. if we were mafia night-killing colin makes it obvious that at least you were mafia. but then not killing him would give him another night to use his role... and there would be a case for it being so obvious that we couldn't have been stupid enough to do it...

but then that happens in future nights too. It'd have been worth taking the 50/50 chance. even though with RHPKR in the game it's not simply a 50/50 choice and chance between those two.

If i was mafia i definitely wouldn't have killed treva. Probably wouldn't have killed colin either and would have took the chance on one of the others and used treva to lynch off colin today.

If I were Mafia we wouldn't be discussing Colin, he would've died on night 1. Especially since he was more active than BKB too on day 1, and it appeared as if he'd be leading discussions again.

 

[barmyarmy]

Erm, you don't have to believe someone's claim, you can't as a matter of fact, just like you aren't believing mine. Especially when they are dead.

You are stating the Mafia's moves as facts. As this is clearly what reveals you as Mafia, you are using this in attempt to oust me as Mafia.

Well it's pretty clearly a fact that they killed Treva last night. It's the obvious play and I've said why. As soon as the doctor reveals his target for the previous day that person it always in danger at night. The fact he is DV is irrelevant.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

The fact he is DV is irrelevant.

no it isn't. not with so few votes needed now.

 

[barmyarmy]

If I were Mafia we wouldn't be discussing Colin, he would've died on night 1. Especially since he was more active than BKB too on day 1, and it appeared as if he'd be leading discussions again.

I see we're back to the "if you were town you'd be dead" argument. I've won games as town in the past (by surviving to the end and finding the mafia) so clearly that's not true. I intend on doing the same here too.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

If I were Mafia we wouldn't be discussing Colin, he would've died on night 1. Especially since he was more active than BKB too on day 1, and it appeared as if he'd be leading discussions again.

i wouldn't have lynched him on day 1. I wasn't away he was perceived as being that important then, and if i was then there was a good chance that there was a doc who would randomly protect him on night one for the same reason.

 

[thedon5]

Well it's pretty clearly a fact that they killed Treva last night. It's the obvious play and I've said why. As soon as the doctor reveals his target for the previous day that person it always in danger at night. The fact he is DV is irrelevant.

It's not obvious, there are many angles to take. You are taking one angle and stating it as fact. You have to examine all angles.

It's not at all irrelevant in my eyes, you just saying this for your convenience.

Treva was on to something, that is a fact, so you lynched him off.

 

[barmyarmy]

no it isn't. not with so few votes needed now.

It's irrelevant to him being killed. He was killed because he couldn't be protected. This is very basic stuff and I wonder if you're pretending not to see that to clear yourself.