Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
Thedon, do you have any suspicion on who might be scum? You keep saying who should we go after next, but have yet to suggest any names.
Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)
- Thread starter puddleduck
- Start date
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
It's night time guys 
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
Sorry guys I slept all day and went to City - Madrid. Dont think we can discuss now so I will refrain from speaking my mind.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Day 3
It is now Day 3. With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch. There are an initial 72 hours left in the day.
It is now Day 3. With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch. There are an initial 72 hours left in the day.
Last edited:
treva
ICC Chairman
And that is why you reveal your hunches when you actually have them, not the next day...
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
i definitely hate to say i told you so. actually no i don't. i love it.
as said during the last day session if we were close to lynching or pressuring a mafia member then it wouldn't make sense to kill manly in case his dossier ruined the scent, and if we were not close at all it would make sense to take him out in case his hunch was accurate.
The closest to being lynched was smurf so i think this kill strengthens his role claim a lot (despite manly being killed after saying he didn't really buy it)
I still think my logic was sound though.
Seems to me that the godfather and other mafia are likely to be those who are yet to come under scrutiny.
as said during the last day session if we were close to lynching or pressuring a mafia member then it wouldn't make sense to kill manly in case his dossier ruined the scent, and if we were not close at all it would make sense to take him out in case his hunch was accurate.
The closest to being lynched was smurf so i think this kill strengthens his role claim a lot (despite manly being killed after saying he didn't really buy it)
I still think my logic was sound though.
Seems to me that the godfather and other mafia are likely to be those who are yet to come under scrutiny.
Sounds like a back-up role becoming active. No real idea.
Last bit implies some kind of immunity maybe.
[quote[He knew where he worked was a joke, but it was his chance. He only hoped he could find the truth. He just had to find some promising leads.[/quote]
First bit unclear but looks investigative.
Some guy-love between Swanny and presumably Jimmy. Maybe some kind of seeker role here and Manly found Jimmy (or vice versa) before he was killed.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
I've been inactive, I know. I was planning to run a game, yes. I was planning run it during the diwali break, do I need to remind that? It wasn't going to be a big game like this and hence I don't see how my inactivity in this game and me planning to run a game are related! I'd just come out and say, I don't like the way Sedition's playing in this game. This is what I feel and I'd tell you why..
When I asked him why he lynched Manly on day 1, this is what he had to say;
Now, Sedition, I'm very curious to know what did your lynch on Manly tell you?
Moving on, Sedition put pressure on me and lynched me. Questioned my day 1 tactics, I questioned his. I don't see how I did anything wrong. Later, he unlynched me, don't really know why, I've been inactive and didn't really put forward a "impressive" defense, did I? Later, Sedition lynched Papa, following Abhas' lead. Hence, I would like to know what exactly was Sedition thinking on day 1 by lynching Manly, he's going after me for my inactivity/for me going for a no lynch on day 1 or simply because he's too desperate as a mafia to lynch a townie, as simple as that. To put some pressure,
Lynch : Sedition
I'd like to know what Treva and Colin think about Sedition.
When I asked him why he lynched Manly on day 1, this is what he had to say;
Now, Sedition, I'm very curious to know what did your lynch on Manly tell you?
Moving on, Sedition put pressure on me and lynched me. Questioned my day 1 tactics, I questioned his. I don't see how I did anything wrong. Later, he unlynched me, don't really know why, I've been inactive and didn't really put forward a "impressive" defense, did I? Later, Sedition lynched Papa, following Abhas' lead. Hence, I would like to know what exactly was Sedition thinking on day 1 by lynching Manly, he's going after me for my inactivity/for me going for a no lynch on day 1 or simply because he's too desperate as a mafia to lynch a townie, as simple as that. To put some pressure,
Lynch : Sedition
I'd like to know what Treva and Colin think about Sedition.
To be fair only Smurf has really been under scrutiny so that's a pretty safe bet.
Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
I wonder what Swann's role might have been, apart from being a mason. I tried to roleblock treva last night, but I got an unsuccessful pm from PD.
As for the write-up, the first line refers to the cult leader, I think. His resently ascended to leadership (dont know how), and can recruit twice as many people than before. Unless it's some sort of cricket endoiysm and the pulling refers to the shot that god rid of Manly, but I highly doubt that.
2nd paragraph refers to cop.
And third refers to Manly's death and reveals that he was a mason.
And now that's it day, I would like thedon to answer my question from last night.
As for the write-up, the first line refers to the cult leader, I think. His resently ascended to leadership (dont know how), and can recruit twice as many people than before. Unless it's some sort of cricket endoiysm and the pulling refers to the shot that god rid of Manly, but I highly doubt that.
2nd paragraph refers to cop.
And third refers to Manly's death and reveals that he was a mason.
And now that's it day, I would like thedon to answer my question from last night.
I'd like to know what Treva and Colin think about Sedition.
As I've said already sedition's bull-in-a-china-shop approach looks town as it is aggressively questioning multiple people but, as we saw last game, he can also pull it off as mafia.
I've got nothing more concrete than that at the moment. I'm happy to go along with any pressure you want to apply at this time.
Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
Jeez Aditya, your first post in a while and 90% of it is yet another self-defense 
Mason makes far more sense than seeker. That also means hopefully that his masonic partner can post his dossier thus clearing them and going after whoever he was suspicious of. Maybe he wasn't so crazy making himself a target.
----------
Jeez Aditya, your first post in a while and 90% of it is yet another self-defense
I'm wondering a bit if there's a staged fight here between sedition and Aditya to "clear" the other one in case one gets lynched. It's a bit strange otherwise how defensive Aditya is and how he keeps going at sedition.
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
okay can someone explain mason and seeker for me?
Similar threads
