I think all the attributes, all the sliders etc., they all work. But they are nowhere near powerful enough.. Which leads us all to askwhether things are cosmetic, and whether they are actually affecting what they are supposed to. Why did Russia hit 200 odd against ATB Aussies, etc.
In actual fact ATB Aussies will always win. Warner will always score more quickly than Anderson, and he will score more runs. But the actual difference isn't very large at all, which means we are playing excellent cricket, with very similar teams. A feeling I remember having with Brian Lara 99.
The other end of the spectrum is Brian Lara 05. Where a Lara would leg glance every ball for six, and James Anderson would be so useless as to not get a run in a hundred opportunities. Remember that tailender animation?
What we need is something in between. And the Big Ant silence on skilling and it's effects is deafening. Quite strange as we all love the game and will buy whatever they churn out. It's not like they're going to lose anything by sharing a few trade secrets, even if it's admitting some errors.
I've never seen such an in-depth player creation and skilling suite this side of Madden 15.. Bit annoying though that we can edit Alistair Cook's philtrum, but we can't stop him hoiking to mid-on without reducing his skills drastically.