End Game Star Wars Mafia - End Mafia(Surendar) & Third Party (Fake Passport) Won

[Fake Passport]

3am - Im out for the next 10 hours or so. Have fun all!

 

[surendar]

How does the inactivity make a difference? I read everything before posting and I've slight town reads on both of them. I even followed that line with "I might be wrong." Let's not make this about targeting people who suspect you. I'm not going to lynch anyone without a solid reason.

You did not give reasons in both cases. You were just clearing the people as town inconsistently. It is not about people who you clear, it is how about how you clear. You seem to me as tagging along the situation trying to make advantage of it instead of your own reasons.

Okay, what is making you to think FP is now in scum radar and what made you think FP was town?[DOUBLEPOST=1500054213][/DOUBLEPOST]

Varun's initial statement - FP and Villain are town, coming from inactive period.
Varun's later statement - I am clearing CC as town, will explain reasons later.

Seriously @Varun ?

This one.

 

[Varun]

CC

I'm confused, are you asking us to name what character we were given? My message was star wars themed of course, but did not give or mention a Star Wars character.

Were you given a Star Wars character name? If not your request is strange

@surendar, this is why @CaptainCremer is likely town, and Rudolph is likely to be mafia if he's actually claimed vanilla townie.

 

[Varun]

You did not give reasons in both cases. You were just clearing the people as town inconsistently. It is not about people who you clear, it is how about how you clear. You seem to me as tagging along the situation trying to make advantage of it instead of your own reasons.

Okay, what is making you to think FP is now in scum radar and what made you think FP was town?

That was just an initial read man, based on just superficial reasoning. I've no idea about everyone's playing habits, but you look unnecessarily aggressive right now.

 

[surendar]

CC


@surendar, this is why @CaptainCremer is likely town, and Rudolph is likely to be mafia if he's actually claimed vanilla townie.

Interesting you bring that up, when I actually stated I understood what Rudolph was saying - it was the way how he claimed. That was the one which ElLoco found it as pseduo crpytic. Claim was not straight forward, only few can get that.

So do you agree that CC and ElLoco did not get what Rudolph was saying? CC because, he clearly stated FP's claim was solid and ElLoco because, he said it was pseudo cryptic. Both did not get what the claim was? You brought VT now, but it did not give me that feeling that these 2 people even understood that.[DOUBLEPOST=1500054576][/DOUBLEPOST]

That was just an initial read man, based on just superficial reasoning. I've no idea about everyone's playing habits, but you look unnecessarily aggressive right now.

Asking questions is not aggressive varun. It is always good to clear the doubts.

 

[Varun]

I understood the sith/mafia elimination win-con, that's all he mentioned? Can you point me to where he said he's a vanilla townie without a particular name? Also, I doubt that there are three in this game.

 

[surendar]

@Varun - He didn't. This(underlined).

You brought VT now, but it did not give me that feeling that these 2 people even understood that.[DOUBLEPOST=1500054576]
[/DOUBLEPOST]

[DOUBLEPOST=1500054576]

It is present in the line you mentioned. Since this is a closed set up, i do not believe the probability of that soft claim to be so predictable. That is why, I am leaning towards Rudolph in understanding that statement.[/doublepost][DOUBLEPOST=1500061310][/DOUBLEPOST]It is present in the line you mentioned. Since this is a closed set up, i do not believe the probability of that soft claim to be so predictable. That is why, I am leaning towards Rudolph in understanding that statement.

 

[Varun]

I didn't bring it up.......everyone just said that he's claiming VT and he hasn't said anything against it. Besides, I mentioned that Rudolph has a chance of being a mafia if he claimed to be a VT. If he didn't, it's cool.

 

[RUDI]

I did, so did you by giving the same winning conditions that I received. I guess that makes you mafia too!

I didn't bring it up.......everyone just said that he's claiming VT and he hasn't said anything against it. Besides, I mentioned that Rudolph has a chance of being a mafia if he claimed to be a VT. If he didn't, it's cool.

 

[El Loco]

Why the furore about win conditions? If anti-town are eliminated that's all that matters in my mind.

Just to be clear, Fake Passport stated that his win-con included eliminating all the Mafia without loss of a townie?
Being the sceptic I am, it could easily be a calculated attempt at giving more legitimacy to his townie status. Seldom do you get a townie willing to be so transparent early on in a game.

 

[surendar]

I didn't bring it up.......everyone just said that he's claiming VT and he hasn't said anything against it. Besides, I mentioned that Rudolph has a chance of being a mafia if he claimed to be a VT. If he didn't, it's cool.

I repeat, it was not pseduo cryptic. Hint was accurate. I couldn't imagine this hint to match in this closed set up.
My FOS on you two(you and CC) remains, just trying to make the differences, that FP and Rudolph are having, in your favor. At the least to me, that's how it looks like.

 

[surendar]

Continue to post and you will likely be safe.

Not necessarily. Top/frequent posters(in count) in a game can be mafia too.

 

[El Loco]

I repeat, it was not pseduo cryptic.

Steady on, it was just a phrase I coined lol

My FOS on you two(you and CC) remains, just trying to make the differences, that FP and Rudolph are having, in your favor. At the least to me, that's how it looks like.

Well, I see you getting nice and cosy with Rudolph as if you're so sure of his alignment at this stage of the game. That could easily be seen as exploitation of this very altercation in the opposite way.

 

[Varun]

What? Just because your wincon is for all sith/mafia to be eliminated, you're not a vanilla townie. It's probably the win condition for the entire town (at least almost, depending on whether Fake Passport is lying or not) and not just the VTs. I know CaptainCremer and I are vanilla townies for a different reason, which is that our characters are nameless.

 

[surendar]

Well, I see you getting nice and cosy with Rudolph as if you're so sure of his alignment at this stage of the game. That could easily be seen as exploitation of this very altercation in the opposite way.

I am not sure what characters are in place, hint phrase was accurate. I do not see any other way that it could have been predicted in this kind of set up. So I believe that.