Mine
:
That's a graphical glitch, rather than superhuman catching. Playing that shot with a mid-off fielder in, I'd expect you to get caught.
It looks weird, because usually this kind of game uses graphics to reflect an underlying model (rather than modelling graphics and using those results) - but what happened was:
1) you played an uppish stroke
2) game checked and found a fielder potentially in position to take a catch
3) game computed chance of the catch being taken
4) game picked a random number, and compared with the chance of the catch. In this case, the random number said "yep, caught it"
5) Game produces graphics to reflect this result
Oh, and on-topic, my most stupid dismissals at the moment are all still of the "Wait, Yes, No, Sorry!" variety.
My best (in bowling) was getting one to turn just enough that the batsman was playing down the wrong line, and the ball clipped off stump. Very, very satisfying.