End Game Expert Cop Mafia Redux II - Town Wins (CK, JR, Swack)

[Till Valhalla]

Lynch is better when we could put one as Town from the analysis but that didn't happen.

 

[CerealKiller]

Lynch is better when we could put one as Town from the analysis but that didn't happen.

But wouldn't that mean we will start day 2 with only 2 cops alive if we get the wrong person today? That would be huge for the mafia.

Can you two check your PMs again?

 

[CerealKiller]

But wouldn't that mean we will start day 2 with only 2 cops alive if we get the wrong person today? That would be huge for the mafia.

Coming back to this, that would happen only if swacker is a Cop. And the only way you can be sure that he is a Cop is if you are the Mafia. Are you the Mafia?

 

[asprin]

Coming back to this, that would happen only if swacker is a Cop. And the only way you can be sure that he is a Cop is if you are the Mafia. Are you the Mafia?

What I said was said after taking the odds into account. We have only a 20% chance of hitting the Bullseye. So there is a 80% chance that we might mishit.

It was never meant to be sure. It was all numbers.[DOUBLEPOST=1495971578][/DOUBLEPOST]

Can you two check your PMs again?

Done. Same result.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Town cop lying is stupid tbh as it auto clears one townie and we can afford a lynch. I don't think there's enough to judge people by their play but I do find asprin suspicious. His posting seems a bit off.

 

[asprin]

I don't think there's enough to judge people by their play but I do find asprin suspicious.

Contradicting statements, aren't they?

Anyways, I am only putting up valid arguments and stats. If you find that suspicious, then I don't know what to say.

-->CK wants to lynch based on inactivity in a game of 5 players. Let me repeat that -- 5 players.
-->I don't
-->JK doesn't too (going by his lynch statement in # 61)

If anything, I find you and CK to be more suspicious.

 

[Till Valhalla]

I have doubled check my PM and it is correct.
ATM
FOS: User and Asprin.

 

[Gaurav_7]

If I was mafia I would definitely keep mum and not ask town cop to post correct result as that would clear one person for the rest of the game.

 

[asprin]

Fair enough. But it could also be that you want us to think that way.

I've decided for now. Until there is no real clue, I'm gonna say

No lynch

Being active or not doesn't matter to me at this point. We have seen in the last 7-8 games since revival that all inactives have always been townies.

It's the mafia who never stay inactive.

 

[CerealKiller]

Unlynch swacker
No Lynch

 

[swacker]

Town cop lying is stupid tbh as it auto clears one townie and we can afford a lynch.

Liars are more likely to be lynched once they're found out. Today, we can't do that, but in the future, shouldn't lie if you don't need to.[DOUBLEPOST=1495991889][/DOUBLEPOST]

You could be using the noob card to cover your false claim.

Sorry, what's that?

 

[CerealKiller]

Sorry, what's that?

You could be the Mafia, and the noob card might help you not to look suspicious

 

[Till Valhalla]

I say we go with a no lynch and wait for tomorrows investigation.
CK and swacker investigations will be quite helpful. I would suggest them to swap their targets for this day.
No Lynch

 

[CerealKiller]

I say we go with a no lynch and wait for tomorrows investigation.
CK and swacker investigations will be quite helpful. I would suggest them to swap their targets for this day.
No Lynch

You also investigated asprin, so why don't you swap? Or was your investigation non-existent?

 

[Till Valhalla]

You also investigated asprin, so why don't you swap? Or was your investigation non-existent?

You both got mafia that's why I said you two to swap. I am also OK with swapping.