End Game Expert Cop Mafia Redux II - Town Wins (CK, JR, Swack)

[Till Valhalla]

Sorry everybody to keep you waiting. My system went hazzle dazzle, fixed it now.[DOUBLEPOST=1495834316][/DOUBLEPOST]I investigated Asprin and got Town.

 

[asprin]

I investigated CK and got town.

So, so far we have:

CK - Joker (Mafia)
Joker - Swacker (Town)
Jack - Asprin (Town)
Asprin - CK (Town)

I'll need a pen and paper to analyze this since I'm on mobile and it's difficult to keep track this way.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I am interested in replacing Joker.

 

[asprin]

CK - Joker (Mafia)
Joker - Swacker (Town)
Jack - Asprin (Town)
Asprin - CK (Town)

Ok, so from the above I can only confirm* about Jack being either Sane or Novice cop.

* Pending swacker's investigation.

 

[CerealKiller]

I am interested in replacing Joker.

@Fake Passport[DOUBLEPOST=1495876101][/DOUBLEPOST]

I investigated CK and got town.

So, so far we have:

CK - Joker (Mafia)
Joker - Swacker (Town)
Jack - Asprin (Town)
Asprin - CK (Town)

I'll need a pen and paper to analyze this since I'm on mobile and it's difficult to keep track this way.

I can't be the Naive Cop, and none of you three can be the Paranoid Cop (assuming that you're not lying). If swacker got a town result, then i will either be the Paranoid Cop or the Insane Cop.

 

[Fake Passport]

Game Announcement

User has replaced Joker.

Sorry Simon, I'll defo hold a place for you next game!

 

[Gaurav_7]

Yeah I have. And yes Joker didn't lie.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Let's wait for swacker to reveal his result.

 

[swacker]

Apologies for delay, was away. Investigated Asprin, got to know that he was mafia?

Not sure how this works, do we have to find a role-cop of ourselves from the investigation we did?

Noobie with cop set-up, sorry for that.

 

[CerealKiller]

Apologies for delay, was away. Investigated Asprin, got to know that he was mafia?

Not sure how this works, do we have to find a role-cop of ourselves from the investigation we did?

Noobie with cop set-up, sorry for that.

You could be using the noob card to cover your false claim.

 

[Till Valhalla]

CK - Joker/User (Mafia)
Joker/User - Swacker (Town)
Jack - Asprin (Town)
Asprin - CK (Town)
Swacker - Asprin (Mafia)
So either Ck or Swacker is paranoid if nobody is lying.
Either I can be Sane, Naive or Insane Cop and Swacker can be the Sane, Paranoid or Insane Cop.
The Sane possibility
If CK is sane, User is Mafia.
If User is sane, Swacker is Town.
If Jack is sane, Asprin is Town.
If Asprin is sane, CK is Town.
If Swacker is sane, Asprin is Mafia.
If we go through only this two suspects will be User and Asprin.
The Insane Possibility
Assuming User is Mafia.
CK - Sane/Paranoid.
Jack - Sane/Naive.
Asprin - Sane/Naive.
Swacker - Insane/Paranoid.
Assuming Swacker is Mafia.
CK - Insane/Paranoid.
User - Insane/Naive.
Jack - Sane/Naive.
Asprin - Sane/Naive.
Assuming Asprin is Mafia.
CK - Insane/Paranoid.
User - Sane/Naive.
Jack - Insane/Naive.
Swacker - Sane/Paranoid.
Assuming CK is mafia.
User - Sane/Naive.
Jack - Sane/Naive.
Asprin - Insane/Naive.
Swacker - Insane/Paranoid.
Assuming Jack is Mafia.
CK - Insane/Paranoid.
User - Sane/Naive.
Asprin - Sane/Naive.
Swacker - Insane/Paranoid.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Investigations:

CK - User (Mafia)
User - swacker (Town)
Jack - asprin (Town)
asprin - CK (Town)
swacker - asprin (mafia)

--------------


Assuming swacker is mafia:
CK - Insane/Paranoid
User - Insane/Naive
Jack - Sane/Naive
asprin - Sane/Naive
Not clear.

Assuming asprin is mafia:
CK - Insane/Paranoid
User - Sane/Naive
Jack - Insane/Naive
swacker - Sane/Paranoid
Not clear.

Assuming Jack is mafia:
CK - Insane/Paranoid
User - Sane/Naive
asprin - Sane/Naive
swacker - Insane/Paranoid
Not clear.

Assuming User is mafia:
CK - Sane/Paranoid
Jack - Sane/Naive
asprin - Sane/Naive
swacker - Insane/Paranoid
Not clear.

Assuming CK is mafia:
User - Sane/Naive
Jack - Sane/Naive
asprin - Insane/Naive
swacker - Insane/Paranoid
Not clear.

This surely means one of the town cop is lying and I am not sure why! We can easily clear one townie if the 4 of us post our correct result. I remember once in the same setup, surender posted a false result which cleared me as a townie on day 1 but I was mafia! Whoever it is please correct it!

 

[CerealKiller]

This surely means one of the town cop is lying and I am not sure why! We can easily clear one townie if the 4 of us post our correct result.

Can you explain how we could clear one townie?

 

[Gaurav_7]

Dethy/Analysis - MafiaWiki

 

[asprin]

Well, a townie posting a wrong result is beyond me. Perhaps we should all double check our PMs. I remember in one of the games, a player had screwed up by giving wrong investigation result - can't remember the game or person though. It was recent.

Interesting that I got two different results for JR and swacker. I think it was PresidentEvil getting the same thing in the last dethy game.