Ashes to Ashes Mafia - Endgame (SK win)

[CG123]

Solid work everyone, not a single useful post since I was on last night.

Lynch: WC

I can't understand how he's this bad when he's played seven games. If he's town and he's playing this terribly then I won't know what to say...

----------

Btw Varun as cliched as it would be for me to say this if I was mafia, you'd be a lot better off focusing your efforts on someone else. Feel free to try and pick me apart if you want because I have nothing to hide, but there are about four or five others who are obviously trying to play under the radar etc.

 

[RPHKR]

I'm not sure what to say now, I have played seven games and this is my play style.
And thedon, I reckon this is my second game with you.

Manly has been posting just oneliners from the start. When the suspicion was raised, he said he was just briefing.
thedon5's giving town vibes. His play style is like the game in which he received town MVP.
I get void from Varun. It's his usual play I guess. As a mafia, he would be my primary target.

It would be foolish to let play WC now, he has no clue what he's doing. He should be replaced.
I agree with CG on his post about User. With WC playing cluelessly, let's look at Swirler,

Interesting, it looks like we may have just two mafia, and some kind of third party role. Not sure how the woman comes into it...

----------

When I first looked at the write-up I thought "Funk to Funky" was somebody that had been killed. Can't be though because there's no explanation. Is it in the song?

Thanks. I guess he was just using it to finish what he was writing.

Didn't really think much about the third paragraph at first, but now I think it might be a miller. stands-out when he first comes in, then goes to the bar near the other two, who cold be mafia.

----------

*could

Manly seems to do weird stuff like this every game he plays in. I Wouldn't be surprised if he tried to make us think it's a part of his role.

Have you joined the game to play, & actually contribute? Just seems like you're sitting back and making comments when you feel like it.

----------



I starting to think it's just a mixture of different "Ashes" themes. The roles and write-up seem to point to that.

----------

* I'm

I think this post was meant to be a claim, but like his other posts, it's done badly. Do you have anything more convincing, to make us actually believe you're town?

----------

Don't really want to lynch him at this stage, would like to give him a chance to show he is actually interested in assisting in discussion. :/

I wouldn't say that they're targeting you. All three lynches are there to put pressure on you. You haven't answered any of our questions, and you haven't been involved in discussion. Do you have any thoughts other than complaining about people targeting you?

These are the posts of Swirler in day 1. He was just questioning WC like others.
We are going nowhere now, the town, as a whole is inactive.

----------

@Colin - gonna replace WC?

 

[CremerCurrans]

I'm not sure what to say now, I have played seven games and this is my play style.
And thedon, I reckon this is my second game with you.

Manly has been posting just oneliners from the start. When the suspicion was raised, he said he was just briefing.
thedon5's giving town vibes. His play style is like the game in which he received town MVP.
I get void from Varun. It's his usual play I guess. As a mafia, he would be my primary target.

It would be foolish to let play WC now, he has no clue what he's doing. He should be replaced.
I agree with CG on his post about User. With WC playing cluelessly, let's look at Swirler,

These are the posts of Swirler in day 1. He was just questioning WC like others.
We are going nowhere now, the town, as a whole is inactive.

This post is really confusing. Did you just admit to being mafia? Also why did you quote all my day one posts, then say "He was just questioning WC like other"? Also you copied me by saying "I'm not sure what to say."

I think you need to explain better what you actually meant.

FOS: RPHKR

----------

I think RPHKR has slipped-up badly whilst trying to target me, but he's also supported me as well which doesn't make sense.

I think that post deserves a lynch, due to how scummy it appears.

Lynch: RPHKR

 

[ste_mc_efc]

Noted RPHKR and Swirler's posts here. As town we're never agreeing to lynch anyone today (except possibly WC, but i can't see that either) so it's not really prudent to post them now, but I have reasonably strong thoughts on both of those posts.

 

[RPHKR]

I think you need to explain better what you actually meant.

I meant Varun would be my target if I were a mafia.

Also you copied me by saying "I'm not sure what to say."

What the hell, are you kidding? That was my gesture.

 

[Manly]

Sorry chaps; been on the beers all day. I'll post properly tomorrow!

 

[thedon5]

Scummy post from RPHKR. The Varun statement makes sense. Varun shouldn't be half revealing things like he has been doing, he is an obvious target for the Mafia. Bit of a poor move from him showing off his results on day 1, should've waited till day 3 perhaps. But RPHKR looks very much like a member of the Mafia trying to get other players on his side. He also seemingly knows that CG, swirler and WC are town, but wants to try a way of getting one of them lynched using other peoples' suspicions. Right now he is trying to agree with CG's hunch to possibly get swirler lynched but he failed in his first try. He also knows I am town and after I was suspcious of him, he tries to use the tactic of saying that I give off town vibes so that I'll hopefully lay off him as I'd know he wouldn't go after me. This is my second game with you, maybe third if you played anonymous Mafia. From the last non-anonymous game I played with you, you were playing just like this and ended up being Mafia.

Manly yet again adds nothing. I'm not sure who gets on the beers on a Thursday, I just know I don't, especially all day...

ste saying we won't come to a conclusion today sounds like he is perhaps trying to get to night as quickly as possible, and that is a terrible statement for the townie to make as it puts us in a terrible position if we again don't lynch anyone today.

I also think Simon has been going under the radar for a while now.

WC is useless but he doesn't give any vibes purely because his English is poor and he doesn't know what he is doing. RPHKR is giving major Mafia vibes in all his posts. I guess to his disadvantage he actually knows English and knows what he's doing.

Unlynch: WC

Lynch: RPHKR

FOS: ste, WC, Manly, Simon

 

[CremerCurrans]

I meant Varun would be my target if I were a mafia.

I don't understand why you'd even joke about something like that?

"I get void from Varun. It's his usual play I guess. As a mafia, he would be my primary target."

Just sounds to me, that you have prior knowledge that he's town.

 

[thedon5]

I think he's saying that by hiding things, Varun makes himself more likely to be killed by the Mafia.

 

[CremerCurrans]

Okay. Maybe I'm misreading what he's saying; Just seems like he's contradicting his main points.

 

[thedon5]

Right. But for me that's not the most suspicious part of the post. If anything that's the best point he made.

 

[barmyarmy]

I've tried to replace WC but can't find anyone. Therefore just play the game and stop asking me about it.

 

[Gaurav_7]

 

[thedon5]

You already seem to know too much User... After that power role you seemingly had.

 

[ste_mc_efc]

Just a bit of warning I likely won't be on at all tomorrow, best man at a wedding.