Best Test XI from each nation (that you have seen)

I have seen last generation players as well so here goes my Indian XI:

Virender Sehwag
Sunil Gavaskar
Rahul Dravid
Sachin Tendulkar
Mohammad Azharuddin
Saurav Ganguly (c)
Kapil Dev
MS Dhoni (No choice here)
Anil Kumble
Javagal Srinath
Zaheer Khan

I will ODI line up as well:
Sachin Tendulkar
Saurav Ganguly
Rahul Dravid
Mohammad Azharuddin (c)
MS Dhoni +
Ajay Jadeja
Robin Singh
Kapil Dev
Anil Kumble
Javagal Srinath
Zaheer Khan
 
Its the best he has seen dude. It doesn't mean anything. He isn't building a South Africa all time XI.
There is plenty enough bowling in that lineup to win matches.

Only real criticism would be a lack of a spinner. Donald, Steyn, Pollock and Klusener would be an ok four man pace attack, although I'd question Klusener's inclusion on his bowling - averaged 37.91 with the ball, and his batting average of 32.86 would hardly be needed in that batting line-up.

But with those four pace bowlers, and Cronje and Kallis more than capable back-up, where is the spin? There hasn't been that much in the way of spin, but you could throw in Paul Adams (32.87) or Harris (37.11) if only for variety.
 
Only real criticism would be a lack of a spinner. Donald, Steyn, Pollock and Klusener would be an ok four man pace attack, although I'd question Klusener's inclusion on his bowling - averaged 37.91 with the ball, and his batting average of 32.86 would hardly be needed in that batting line-up.

But with those four pace bowlers, and Cronje and Kallis more than capable back-up, where is the spin? There hasn't been that much in the way of spin, but you could throw in Paul Adams (32.87) or Harris (37.11) if only for variety.

I would have gone without a spinner. I don't recall South Africa having any batsman that can bowl a bit of spin at least not in the time where War could have seen them.
 
Since I haven't been watching cricket for that long and I haven't seen any matches live I will make a best XI that I have seen on streams.

Mathew Hayden
Graeme Smith
Kumar Sangakkara+
Sachin Tendulkar
Brian Lara
Shiv Chanderpaul
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Warne
Shoaib Akhtar
Muttiah Muralitharan
Mohammad Asif
 
Only real criticism would be a lack of a spinner. Donald, Steyn, Pollock and Klusener would be an ok four man pace attack, although I'd question Klusener's inclusion on his bowling - averaged 37.91 with the ball, and his batting average of 32.86 would hardly be needed in that batting line-up.

But with those four pace bowlers, and Cronje and Kallis more than capable back-up, where is the spin? There hasn't been that much in the way of spin, but you could throw in Paul Adams (32.87) or Harris (37.11) if only for variety.

Klusener @ his peak with the ball between 1996-2000 in which i saw he was a top-quality seamer. Injuries reduced his potency circa 2001 & he started bowling off-cutters, which i why his end career test average is so high.

So really you dont need a spinner in the sub-continent when the likes of Donald/Pollock/Steyn can bowl lethal reverse swing with the old ball on a wearing 4th/5th day track. Unless its real sub-continent dustbowl.

Dare said:
I would have gone without a spinner. I don't recall South Africa having any batsman that can bowl a bit of spin at least not in the time where War could have seen them.

I saw a good deal of Pat Symcox. Who was easily the saffies best spinner since readmission. So in hypotetical sub-continental test with that Saffies XI, Symcox could come in for either Klusener or De Villiers.
 
Well as an Aussie fan it's hard because since 1988 when I first started watching there's been so many awesome players, but I settled on this XI:

1 Justin Langer
2 Matthew Hayden
3 Ricky Ponting
4 Damien Martyn
5 Steve Waugh
6 Michael Clarke
7 Adam Gilchrist (wk)
8 Shane Warne
9 Jason Gillespie
10 Stuart Clark
11 Glenn McGrath

And because I feel so bad about leaving some legends out...a second XI:
1 Simon Katich
2 Mark Taylor
3 David Boon
4 Mark Waugh
5 Michael Hussey
6 Allan Border
7 Ian Healy (wk)
8 Brett Lee
9 Craig McDermott
10 Stuart MacGill
11 Bruce Reid/Merv Hughes

I'd actually have Mark Taylor ahead of Langer, which when I first thought about it I thought it was odd, because i'm a big Langer fan, but Taylor played some of the best innings of the 90's against truly awesome bowling lineups-

-170 vs SA 1993 at the MCG, Donald was on fire that series, Taylor played him like a medium pacer, match was a draw but the pitch was juicy and conditions very wet and dodgy, he looked so good, pulling and driving with mastery.

144 vs WI 1991, yes it was at antigua but the pitch wasnt the batting paradise it later was that decade. Obviously the bowling attack was brilliant- Marshall, Ambrose, Walsh etc, the whole series he had been threatening to make a big one, as an opener he really blunted the WI attack from ball one in most tests that series, looked a class above even the WI batters. This innings his backfoot drives were even better than his great displays in the 1989 Ashes, Marshall in particular he played easily.

169* carrying his bat vs SA in 1998, what a great innings, in my opinion his greatest test knock. My how well he punished the Sa attack including Pollock who was at his peak then, and was in the middle of a 7 fer that innings. People tend to forget just how attacking Taylor could play, he wasnt adventurous but could slap a bad ball as well as anyone, particularly savage on the pull and hook shots, not so string down the ground, typical lefty in that he loved square of the wicket and cover drives, which he played many that innings,

102* in the 4th innings 1998 vs India at Bangalore, one of his underrated test knocks, Australia had been severely thrashed in the opening two tests, Kumble and Sachin, even Sidhu just caned us. Taylor's strokeplay under pressure of chasing over 200 to win in the 4th innings on a spinning pitch was really bloody good, the ball sped away his whole innings, just like it did for Sachin during his 177 on day 1. The Indian crowd was dead silent every time he slapped the ball away.

123 vs England at Manchester, 1993 Ashes, day 1 cloudy and swinging day he was really good after a crap home summer vs WI and a poor tour to NZ. Hayden in particular breathing right down his throat after a bumper 2nd FC season, but his technique was rock solid all day and held the whole innings together. Lots of cracking big swinging deiveries from Caddick and Defreitas, those two mightve been pie throwers overseas mostly but in home conditions served up for them on a plate they were a handful.

123 vs Pakistan, Hobart vs Wasim, Waquar, Mushtaq etc, no doubt at all that the Pak bowlers were at their peak in that era, Taylor was in his best form of his life in those few years, he really played Wasim Akram easily, and was ruthless on Waqar's short balls and kept out his big in duckers. Same match Waqar broke Warne's foot with one. One of Taylor's forgotten gems. His backfoot play was awesome, his trademark effortless drives were fully on display.

One of our best openers who always seemed to be facing harsh conditions on day 1 as an opener, like Punter he was a bat first man, fully knowing it was his own average that was likely to suffer.
 
Great reports mate. Tubby is unfortunately quite underrated these days. People seem to remember his stodginess in ODIs or his poor run of form in 96/97 rather than his better times.
 
Yes well people are idiots, name me one batsman that hasnt had a bad year of test cricket, every player has had a dodgy run of form at some point, Tubby's slightly longer than most but its always tricky when its the captain, and a great one at that. One thing which has irritated the hell out of me since 1997, was the ferocity of the media around the time of his slump. At the start of the 96/97 season Taylor was in good form, we had about 8 months off after the 96 world cup where he was in great form, odi form of his life, no form slump yet, coming off one of his best test summers in 95/96. Then the Wi toured in 96/97 and he failed in all 5 tests, and all 3 in SA early 97. Great 1st test ton in the 97 Ashes ( July?) and form slump over, didnt even last one year, yet the press were saying it was 2 years he was out of form! (wooops, forgot the one off India test on that horrible pitch in November 1996) Mental stuff. Same as Hussey's slump- he had a great tour of India in 2008 and good 1st test vs NZ late 2008, then had a slump until the 5th Ashes test, people were saying it was 18 months he was in a slump- it was 7 or 8 months at best! GGGRRRRRRRR.
 
Since I haven't been watching cricket for that long and I haven't seen any matches live I will make a best XI that I have seen on streams.

Mathew Hayden
Graeme Smith
Kumar Sangakkara+
Sachin Tendulkar
Brian Lara
Shiv Chanderpaul
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Warne
Shoaib Akhtar
Muttiah Muralitharan
Mohammad Asif

I will not question other selections but I am sure you saw McGrath and he should be in for Asif.
 
Best Test XI I have seen:

Matthew Hayden
Virender Sehwag
Kumar Sangakkara+
Sachin Tendulkar
Brian Lara
VVS Laxman
Andrew Flintoff
Shane Warne
Glen McGrath
Muttiah Murlidharan
Wasim Akram
 
Best XI i have seen:

Matthew Hayden
Saeed Anwar
Ricky Ponting
Sachin Tendulkar
Brian Lara
Steve Waugh
Adam Gilchrist
Shane Warne (c)
Dale Steyn
Allan Donald
Glen McGrath

12th man: Murali/Flintoff

War added 6 Minutes and 45 Seconds later...

I'd actually have Mark Taylor ahead of Langer, which when I first thought about it I thought it was odd, because i'm a big Langer fan, but Taylor played some of the best innings of the 90's against truly awesome bowling lineups-

-170 vs SA 1993 at the MCG, Donald was on fire that series, Taylor played him like a medium pacer, match was a draw but the pitch was juicy and conditions very wet and dodgy, he looked so good, pulling and driving with mastery.

144 vs WI 1991, yes it was at antigua but the pitch wasnt the batting paradise it later was that decade. Obviously the bowling attack was brilliant- Marshall, Ambrose, Walsh etc, the whole series he had been threatening to make a big one, as an opener he really blunted the WI attack from ball one in most tests that series, looked a class above even the WI batters. This innings his backfoot drives were even better than his great displays in the 1989 Ashes, Marshall in particular he played easily.

169* carrying his bat vs SA in 1998, what a great innings, in my opinion his greatest test knock. My how well he punished the Sa attack including Pollock who was at his peak then, and was in the middle of a 7 fer that innings. People tend to forget just how attacking Taylor could play, he wasnt adventurous but could slap a bad ball as well as anyone, particularly savage on the pull and hook shots, not so string down the ground, typical lefty in that he loved square of the wicket and cover drives, which he played many that innings,

102* in the 4th innings 1998 vs India at Bangalore, one of his underrated test knocks, Australia had been severely thrashed in the opening two tests, Kumble and Sachin, even Sidhu just caned us. Taylor's strokeplay under pressure of chasing over 200 to win in the 4th innings on a spinning pitch was really bloody good, the ball sped away his whole innings, just like it did for Sachin during his 177 on day 1. The Indian crowd was dead silent every time he slapped the ball away.

123 vs England at Manchester, 1993 Ashes, day 1 cloudy and swinging day he was really good after a crap home summer vs WI and a poor tour to NZ. Hayden in particular breathing right down his throat after a bumper 2nd FC season, but his technique was rock solid all day and held the whole innings together. Lots of cracking big swinging deiveries from Caddick and Defreitas, those two mightve been pie throwers overseas mostly but in home conditions served up for them on a plate they were a handful.

123 vs Pakistan, Hobart vs Wasim, Waquar, Mushtaq etc, no doubt at all that the Pak bowlers were at their peak in that era, Taylor was in his best form of his life in those few years, he really played Wasim Akram easily, and was ruthless on Waqar's short balls and kept out his big in duckers. Same match Waqar broke Warne's foot with one. One of Taylor's forgotten gems. His backfoot play was awesome, his trademark effortless drives were fully on display.

One of our best openers who always seemed to be facing harsh conditions on day 1 as an opener, like Punter he was a bat first man, fully knowing it was his own average that was likely to suffer.

I saw the 169 vs & 102 vs SA live. But overall lovely nostalgic review.

Just a point on Taylor's record vs Windies in the 90s after that 90/91 series. Watchig highlights of the 92/93, 94/95, 96/97 i was always under the impression the windies quicks sort of work Taylor out technically after 90/91. Since i remember seeing in highlights of those other series (92/93, 94/95, 96/97), he seemed not to know where his off-stump was when playing them.
 
I will not question other selections but I am sure you saw McGrath and he should be in for Asif.

I did see McGrath and maybe I put Asif ahead of him just because Asif is fresh in my mind. What I remember most about McGrath is the 2006 Ashes in Australia and he only had one good bowling innings and that was 6/50 at Brisbane, for most part in that series he was ordinary or not like the old McGrath so I really don't have the best memories of him.
 
I did see McGrath and maybe I put Asif ahead of him just because Asif is fresh in my mind. What I remember most about McGrath is the 2006 Ashes in Australia and he only had one good bowling innings and that was 6/50 at Brisbane, for most part in that series he was ordinary or not like the old McGrath so I really don't have the best memories of him.

Didnt you see his 99 AUS tour to Windies live with Pigeon bowling @ his ultimate peak?
 
Didnt you see his 99 AUS tour to Windies live with Pigeon bowling @ his ultimate peak?

ahahah no. The first ever series that I watched in full was the 2005 England tour of Pakistan. I only started following cricket in 04/05.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top