Classic Mafia 2 - Game abandoned

[Gaurav_7]

Ah, so much of this and that. PD and Sedition are working great together, isn't it?

Just went through the thread quickly, I am neutral as far as PD and Sedition are concerned. They talk too much though. T20 is sort of playing it safe but, some of posts might give him away. Not reading into it too much still as far he is concerned.

I'm suspicious of Aditya. His post after that night writeup was dodgy. Clearly trying to state he's town and how the death wasn't a bad one for us.

FOS : Aditya

Also, I don't like the 48 hours a day thing. Agreed with night roles, they should be 24 hours. But, days can be longer if discussion is on.

 

[Aditya]

Are you guys kidding me? You surely are aware of the time zones. While I logged off yesterday, it was 11:00 PM IST. That surely isn't too early to log out, is it? Sedition, while I logged out yesterday, I did saw you raising suspicion on Puddlebuck but it wasn't something substantial and I didn't have anything important to post either. I've just logged on and have gone through the last few pages and to be honest, you guys are repeating the same thing post after post. Being inactive is one thing but raising questions unnecessarily about someone's inactivity is somewhat suspicious. The time zones are a main factor in mafia games.

As far as the topic of who is the doc and who is the cop is concerned. I've got no idea. I somewhat feel that T20 needs to be a little more active but then again this game has just started so I wont lynch anyone just yet, though I want T20 to be more active.

Oh yeah my bad! This guy is Adi

Waaat? Come on man. You've disappointed me. Everyone here knows, even Colin agrees that I'm better than him at mafia games and you still don't know my name! A rookie mistake man, a rookie mistake.

----------

I was just trying to post what I feel after the night write up. I mean, we have to agree that it's good that mafia's killed a simple villager than a doc or cop. Losing these two important roles on night 0 would have been a disaster. I don't see how I came up suspiciously there. Though, my way of using "us" in the post, might look a little odd but the members who have played with me in previous mafia games, should know that that's how I usually post.

 

[MaD]

Well we could always hope for a doc save, but that doesn't apply unfortunately for last night...

 

[puddleduck]

Are you guys kidding me? You surely are aware of the time zones. While I logged off yesterday, it was 11:00 PM IST. That surely isn't too early to log out, is it? Sedition, while I logged out yesterday, I did saw you raising suspicion on Puddlebuck but it wasn't something substantial and I didn't have anything important to post either. I've just logged on and have gone through the last few pages and to be honest, you guys are repeating the same thing post after post. Being inactive is one thing but raising questions unnecessarily about someone's inactivity is somewhat suspicious. The time zones are a main factor in mafia games.

As far as the topic of who is the doc and who is the cop is concerned. I've got no idea. I somewhat feel that T20 needs to be a little more active but then again this game has just started so I wont lynch anyone just yet, though I want T20 to be more active.




Waaat? Come on man. You've disappointed me. Everyone here knows, even Colin agrees that I'm better than him at mafia games and you still don't know my name! A rookie mistake man, a rookie mistake.

----------

I was just trying to post what I feel after the night write up. I mean, we have to agree that it's good that mafia's killed a simple villager than a doc or cop. Losing these two important roles on night 0 would have been a disaster. I don't see how I came up suspiciously there. Though, my way of using "us" in the post, might look a little odd but the members who have played with me in previous mafia games, should know that that's how I usually post.

You've reacted somewhat guiltily, that's all I'm saying.

Also, why on earth would I have any idea who's done what with when to why in the mafia history? This is my second ever time playing, and you didn't play last time... Also, I wasn't saying you were Addy, I was just shortening your name I don't really see what Colin has to do with any of this.

I think your post reeks of someone under pressure that they feel is bigger than it actually is. I felt the same about Zhuorb and it turned out to be correct in the last one. Not saying I'm right, but I would suggest you would be a good investigation for the cop.

 

[MaD]

I'm pretty sure that Colin thing was a joke, but it's come off rather... (not sure what word to use)...?

----------

dodgy?

 

[Aditya]

Puddleduck, you're taking this a bit too seriously man. The Colin thing was obviously a joke.

 

[puddleduck]

I realise it's meant to be a joke, but I don't know, it just yeah, seems dodgy

Also I hope Adi deliberately spelt my name wrong as a response to me getting his wrong, cos that's quite funny

(Oh thanks MaD, you laid out my hypothesizing nicely)

Anyway, I'm keeping my FOS: Adi. So far you're about the only person that has seemed at all dodgy. I'm not 100% sure about T20 and his motives. Feigning ignorance and not contributing is apparently fairly standard mafia tactics but then I've also heard it's standard town tactics which is why it becomes standard mafia tactics. Urgh, I'm confusing myself again haha

So yeah, I obviously have to presume Sedition is town for now, because he's played a lot like I did in the last game, and our mutual lack of trust for each other and overriding paranoia lends itself to me believing he could certainly be town (or a very sneaky mafia).

User for me hasn't really done or said much, but I get town vibes from him.

So to lay out where that leaves me is that if I know I am and I think User and Sedition could be. That leaves 2 from MaD, Adi and 20-20 as the mafia. However for some reason I think the doctor is one of those 3, and I actually think MaD has shown strong town signs too. This is where I start to get confused, as in the end i'm left with only Adi as someone I can really see as mafia at the moment.

 

[barmyarmy]

even Colin agrees that I'm better than him at mafia games

It's a lie Lynch him...

 

[Sedition]

Agree that Aditya's looking pretty dodgy. I'm all for lynching someone based on the majority's gut feeling and right now we've got User, Mad, PD and myself all suspicious of him. Just like how Zhuorb should've bit the bullet on day 1, Aditya should this day.

*hands out the pitchforks*

Lynch: Aditya

 

[Aditya]

Oh come on. Dodgy? seriously? I was just joking around, there is nothing to go on at the moment. The only member I'm suspicious of is, T20 but that's all because of his inactivity. Apart from him, no one really has done anything suspicious. My post after the night write up just stated a fact. My post today, after logging in, I tried to clear all the doubts but that seemed dodgy too and I've no idea why. Simply because I joked about Puddleduck using my name wrongly and to be honest, it isn't as big a deal as it is being shown.

 

[puddleduck]

You seem to be getting more and more defensive is my issue. As though you keep feeling under more pressure than you actually are.

Sedition kept telling me I didn't seem worried when he accused me, and there's a reason for that I know, I'm not guilty. Your posts are a lot like Zhuorbs were on the first day whenever he was accused. A mixture of incredulous shock at the fact that someone might be accusing you because you can't believe anyone has read between what thin lines there are in this game and decided you actually are mafia.

I'm not so quick to go to lynch you yet. As I feel if the cop can investigate you tonight we can answer a lot of questions. Though if others are also feeling that we should lynch you, then by all means I love being a sheep haha

I stick with my FOS: Adi

----------

Clearly it has nothing to do with the joke either and more to do with your overselling of your complete shock at being fingered. Not much to go on yes, but it's something.

 

[Aditya]

I've made my point here. I don't think I've done something so suspicious to get lynched. Still, I'd like to know what others think.

 

[Sedition]

Yeah, it's not what you said, but how you said it Last I heard from Mad and User, they were also suspicious. So only T20's thoughts you're waiting on? I'd love to hear what he has to say in your defence too..

 

[puddleduck]

Thing is Adi, I think a town player at this moment wouldn't have just acted as though being accused was so shocking. They would maybe have suggested that me and sedition were working together? That perhaps the very person who accuses them is in fact mafia... Yet, you seem to have no way of deciphering anything in anyone else's games so far because perhaps you know exactly who is town and who is mafia?

 

[Aditya]

I've mentioned in my earlier posts too, it's too early in the game to put suspicion on someone, unless they have done something very suspicious, which neither of you two did. Though, you guys were posting the same thing again and again as there was nothing to go about but at least you were starting discussion. The thing is, while you were discussing about the game, T20 was online but he still didn't post anything effective which does make me suspicious. At least, I'm not shying away here. I've got nothing to hide and hence I'm posting in my defense consistently. The point about me not questioning that you and Sedition are working together, I don't feel that it's a townie's tactic. If I were a mafia, I wont leave a single chance to lynch the members who are under a bit suspicion and you two were, as I guess User or MaD did question about you two working together. As I mentioned, you guys were only just starting a discussion, which I appreciate.