Expert Cop Mafia 2 - Endgame Mafia win

[barmyarmy]

Ok, it's now day 1.
It takes 3 to lynch or to end the day.

 

[hedger_14]

I investigated MaD and got mafia.

 

[treva]

I investigated ARay and he came up town aligned.

----------

So on current info, neither me or Hedger can be the paranoid cop.

 

[ARay]

I checked MaD and he showed up as Town aligned. I am not the paranoid cop. I dont see how hedger cannot be a paranoid cop. His result showed up as mafia.

 

[treva]

Misread that, my bad.

So neither of us can be the paranoid cop, whilst Hedger cannot be the naive cop.

 

[Highlander999]

I investigated treva and got mafia aligned

 

[barmyarmy]

The other 5 could have completed another whole game in the time it's taken you lot to post.

 

[treva]

Not my fault, I'm here ready and waiting. Don't want to keep posting an update every other post though.

Going on everyone telling the truth:

Hedger: Cannot be Naive.
Me: Cannot be Paranoid.
Tom: Cannot be Naive.
ARay: Cannot be Paranoid.

 

[MaD]

Investigated Tom and got town aligned

 

[treva]

So, this is what we have, to sum it up

MaD: Tom is town aligned (Cannot be paranoid)
Me: ARay is town aligned (Cannot be paranoid)
ARay: MaD is town aligned (Cannot be paranoid)
Tom: Treva is mafia aligned (Cannot be naive)
Hedger: MaD is mafia aligned (Cannot be naive)

So two investigated MaD and got opposite results.

So if MaD is mafia, Hedger could be paranoid, normal or mafia. ARay would be insane, naive or mafia.

If he is town, Hedger would be insane, paranoid or mafia. ARay would be normal, naive or mafia.

I know that helps very little, but may as well get something down.

 

[hedger_14]

So if MaD is mafia, Hedger could be paranoid, normal or mafia. ARay would be insane, naive or mafia.

There's only one mafia

I've tried putting in all the combinations by assuming each player to be mafia but all results are possible so atm, any of the players could be mafia, although I know myself to be town.

 

[ARay]

So, this is what we have, to sum it up

MaD: Tom is town aligned (Cannot be paranoid)
Me: ARay is town aligned (Cannot be paranoid)
ARay: MaD is town aligned (Cannot be paranoid)
Tom: Treva is mafia aligned (Cannot be naive)
Hedger: MaD is mafia aligned (Cannot be naive)

So two investigated MaD and got opposite results.

So if MaD is mafia, Hedger could be paranoid, normal or mafia. ARay would be insane, naive or mafia.

If he is town, Hedger would be insane, paranoid or mafia. ARay would be normal, naive or mafia.

I know that helps very little, but may as well get something down.

To be fair, I dont get how if MaD is mafia Hedger or me could be mafia could also be mafia. I thought there is only one mafia in this game.

Okay So the possibilities boil down this right now:
MaD [ Naive, Insane, Normal, Paranoid ]
Treva [ Naive, Insane, Normal, Paranoid ]
Me [ Naive, Insane, Normal, Paranoid ]
Tom [ Naive , Insane, Normal, Paranoid ]
Hedger [ Naive , Insane, Normal, Paranoid ]

i feel like all of our timings that we come online are different.
As for discussions, I think we should decide now who were going to investigate for the next night so that i can increase our effectiveness.

I think two people should investigate the same person because it allows us to figure out the role much faster.
So two people in NOT paranoid group should investigate one person
two people in the NOT Naive group should investigate one person.

This way we can figure out among the NOT paranoid group who is naive and in the NOT naive group who is Paranoid.

 

[hedger_14]

Just remember that there is a good chance myself and Tom are paranoid/insane if Tom isn't mafia so by picking out another player, we're more likely to just pick out another town player and will come up mafia aligned and nothing is changed.

 

[MaD]

Ok I'm a bit confused so I'll do some research on this gametype.
Just let me know who I should investigate and it shall be done.

 

[ARay]

So it took a while but I figured this out.

If We consider Hedger to be mafia:
That makes based on their prediction
MaD: Normal/ Naive (MaD: Tom is town aligned)
Treva: Normal/Naive (Treva: ARay is town aligned)
Me: Normal/ Naive (ARay: MaD is town aligned)
Tom: Insane/ Paranoid (Tom: Treva is mafia aligned)

I know I am town and I am either Naive/ Normal. This means that only one of the two (MaD/ Treva) can be Normal/Naive. The other one has faked his result.

----------

Do I make any sense? This is because if Hedger is mafia, Either Insane or Paranoid role would be missing. That is not possible, hence hedger is cleared for sure.