Just reitrating what richowebbo says, you cant go wrong with don bradman cricket, its nothing like cricket games before, the developers are passionate cricket fans like us, and you will see it ooze all over in the game, It captures the soul of cricket well.the developers engage the community allmost 24/7.
FIFA for all its polish is not cricket, and the amount of enjoyment you will get in this game is matchless, you will feel the pressure of being a No 4 batsman, the edginess of a opener, the finishing nerves, and bowling is actually something enjoyable and playable for the first time in a cricket game. The captures the feel of cricket really well.
Im already 250 hrs into the game and the enjoyment as well as depth of the game is only increasing. Sure there are little niggles here and there but they are very minute when you take it as a whole picture and doesnt impact your enjoyment of the game.
the graphics may not be top notch like fifa but it is pretty decent and the amazing gameplay makes up for it and the game does looks really good on PC.
I know it is off topic but being a huge fan of the game and the developers, cant help but spread the word.