Mafia: Discussion, History and Waiting List Thread

[Abhas]

Still, it's hard to hide one's playing style. I think I've figured out a couple of players in the current game already

----------

I was just looking at Cricket Mafia. No wonder Abhas won when he got 3 incarnations

Edited to add: he got 3 in the next game as well...

In cricket mafia I deserved it

Lost mafia was the worst game I played.

 

[barmyarmy]

Agreed. Some styles are easier to pick than others.

----------

Right some interesting mafia facts for you:

Aditya's overall record is superior to Abhas with 38% to 35%.
Filtering out fewer than 2 games the top three are Haari, barmyarmy and Aditya.
23 people have yet to win a single game.
The best town players are Smurf and bevab with 50% and 42% respectively.
Treva, Zorax and ARay have never won as town.
6 players have a 100% record as mafia (no minimum game limit). They are Haari, Zohaib, barmyarmy, AP, Manly and Gudduthemaster.
Treva, MaD and Chewie have been mafia 5 times.
Hedger and Varun both have 0/4 as mafia.
Abhas been individual or cult 4 times and won 3 times.
4 players have won MVP twice barmyarmy, Abhas, ARay and Spoobir.

 

[hedger_14]

Hedger and Varun both have 0/4 as mafia.

Should be 2/4 at least if not for that stupid Voldemort needs only one lynch to be lynched in the end when 4 players remain... And Themer of course choosing some questionable reasons to kill me off.

And doesn't help that you get killed N1 by the SK's swapped target... So I've only actually been lynched twice as mafia and one was when I had given up trying to defend myself as I was pretty sure I was going to win.

And I'm not sure but I don't think I've been lynched as town as well, or it may be once or twice. Normally killed by the mafia

----------

And don't ban Abhas. He's my favourite player to play with

 

[Themer]

And Themer of course choosing some questionable reasons to kill me off.

I didn't find my reasons questionable...

 

[barmyarmy]

I just find it amazing that ARay has only won once. We're all so scared of him he gets lynched or night-killed.
I reckon he'd enjoy anonymous mafia...

----------

I'd reckon instead that he should always be made a Suicidal Townie.

Just to pick up on this in the game I modded I forced him to include a famous quotation in one of his day posts to be allowed to use his night role. I think we need more ideas like that.

----------

Should be 2/4 at least if not for that stupid Voldemort needs only one lynch to be lynched in the end when 4 players remain... And Themer of course choosing some questionable reasons to kill me off.

Although, in fairness you are the only person in PC mafia history to play on both sides in the same game having already been killed as Snape.

Interestingly when I tallied games played I counted every death so in the two games where Abhas got 3 incarnations I put played 6 won 1

 

[hedger_14]

And yep, I have never got lynched when I have been townie.

Always have been killed :/

 

[treva]

The reason why I've never won as town is because I've been town once!

 

[ARay]

I just find it amazing that ARay has only won once. We're all so scared of him he gets lynched or night-killed.
I reckon he'd enjoy anonymous mafia

Sigh, I get targeted since I try and promote discussions
I have actually never been lynched when I am townie though. Always been night Killed.

I have been mafia twice I think, I lost my first one because Abhas caught me out in the end, otherwise we could have won that!
I was individual once as well, but I didnt last long enough.

 

[AbhishekS]

How about adding a role exclusive to anonymised games. A role similar to the cop but instead of alignment, he knows the PlanetCricket username of his target. Sounds cool to me.

 

[MaD]

That's pretty pointless and I don't see how it would help

 

[Aditya]

Aditya's overall record is superior to Abhas with 38% to 35%

Haha. That doesn't really matter. There is no one to argue that I'm nowhere near as good as Abhas. I've been lucky to win the games that I've won, maybe apart from one or two. Abhas is easily the best player.

 

[AbhishekS]

That's pretty pointless and I don't see how it would help

It won't help but it will add to the fun.

 

[Aditya]

Alignment is a lot important in mafia games. Even if he knows the name of that member on PC, it wont really make any difference. He wont know whether he is mafia or townie, which is much more important and so makes the role basically pointless.

 

[Varun]

Pokemon mafia has the record of most posts in a mafia game on PC. And guess who modded it?

 

[barmyarmy]

The reason why I've never won as town is because I've been town once!

I've got you down as being town three times... (although in fairness one was mafia round two and one was cop mafia)
It would be interesting to compile stats on who gets lynched most and least as well.