Mafia: Discussion, History and Waiting List Thread

[Gaurav_7]

Tbh, they never got going and were always in the waiting list...

 

[barmyarmy]

@Colin - Why did you remove the games in waiting list?

1. Rugby Union Mafia by CG123
2. Dickensian Mafia by ARay
3. Toy Story Mafia by Ollie
4. Sherlock Holmes Mafia by bevab
5. "Ponniyin Selvan" Mafia by RPHKR

The first 4 definitely weren't happening. I'll re-add yours if you want.
Stats are done. Will post them after lunch.

Highlights include:
Aditya and I both with a 50% win rate 9/18
Themer and Treva with a 50% lynched rate...

 

[Gaurav_7]

PD mafia 03

A very good game by the SK, Varun. Especially killing Abhas (who was mafia!) during the 2nd night. But, it was Bilal who stole the show with some excellent analysis later on in the game and took the town over the line keeping his head. User claimed survivor very early in the game and managed to survive till the end! MVP was BKB.

 

[RPHKR]

The first 4 definitely weren't happening. I'll re-add yours if you want.

Yeah please.

Expert cop mafia 3 by RPHKR Town win(Yudi, Bevab and Umair2000)
Yudi did the job for the town. His analysis later and the post in which he stated 'game over' was great. Bevab and Umair took a lot of time to lynch off. Abhas wasn't smart enough to get the win as the mafia. Varun was unlucky to get cleared at day 1.

Expert cop mafia 4 by RPHKR Mafia win(barmyarmy)
Poor play by the town, no good analysis from them. Colin was just brilliant to claim insane cop and get swacker lynched on the last day. Hedger was quite surprised to survive night 1 as Colin decided to kill Papa, the insane cop.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Abhas wasn't smart enough to get the win as the mafia.

What?

I need to read that game!

 

[RPHKR]

What?

I need to read that game!

He himself stated that. He was bit confused in that game.

 

[barmyarmy]

Clear mafia advantage in the last few games. It was level but now the mafia are ahead overall 22-17.

 

[Abhas]

What?

I need to read that game!

Read this instead http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...afia-endgame-mafia-abhas-manly-win-77208.html
or this http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...agues/conspiracy-365-mafia-day-9-a-76800.html
or this http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...eagues/planetcricket-mafia-endgame-73760.html
or best of the lot, this: http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...r-mafia-end-abhas-death-eaters-win-72400.html

 

[barmyarmy]

That Harry Potter game was epic.

 

[Abhas]

Kudos to Spin for that, he made it so dynamic, he always had something up his hat. Both the alignments were never out of the game, and never completely had it in the bag either.

 

[RPHKR]

Yeah such an awesome game. He should have spent a lot of time doing the roles. The JOAT role(Hermoine) was awesome.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Read this instead http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...afia-endgame-mafia-abhas-manly-win-77208.html
or this http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...agues/conspiracy-365-mafia-day-9-a-76800.html
or this http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...eagues/planetcricket-mafia-endgame-73760.html
or best of the lot, this: http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...r-mafia-end-abhas-death-eaters-win-72400.html

I feel disgusted every time I see that Harry Potter game. I was so close to winning that and I did play really well as well. Yes, credits to Spin for the game. Playing HP was very enjoyable. He had those horcruxes and I wasn't told that I was one too till all the other were destroyed. Then I had to get myself lynched. It was all done so well!

 

[barmyarmy]

I was thinking that a feature of recent games has probably been too few vanilla townies. They've basically all become role MaDness games where everyone has something.
It does make it harder for mafia firstly as it takes away the vanilla claim (and by extension makes it harder to lynch townies who claim vanilla) but also means that too many town roles become "confirmed".

It might be interesting for someone to run a simple 7 player setup, cop, doc, 3 x vanilla, goon, godfather. Then it's all about gameplay...

----------

Aditya is learning slowly.

Just spotted this from March 2011

If it helps I can role claim now to be a useless townie... As ARay has said not being killed by the mafia on night 1 shouldn't mean you get lynched by the town on day 2.
The mafia might have assumed I was protected night 1 or something. I shouldn't have to spend every day 2 I make it to explaining why I'm not dead.

And this from one of my first games!

 

[Gaurav_7]

I am going to do a mini mafia 03 with 7-9 players. But, now I need to wait till both the current games finish.

 

[RPHKR]

My game won't open until April I guess(Yeah, April 2013). Though, I think it would be good if I have it in the list.
It's 'Ponniyin Selvan' mafia based on a Tamil novel. If you guys find it hard to spell it, then let it be 'Son of Ponni' mafia.

Check this.