Mafia - Janitorial 2.0 - Game Abandoned

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[Sulaiman7]

would we have gotten as good a read on the town as we have?

That's right , we haven't analyzed some players properly with the likes of Umair and Simon.

----------

Has my play looked Mafia?

Your play has looked more of defensive player which you aren't.

----------

Had it not been for P_Squared's result, would you think I was Mafia?

It had been a totally different story then , better talk about reality.

 

[Varun]

it's Varun , thedon and User working together.

If it is that, you'd be screwed mate. Give up already. jks

----------

Had it not been for P_Squared's result, would you think I was Mafia?

No. But he got the result. If he hadn't got the result, you wouldn't probably have User pinned up as mafia as well, if I'm getting it correctly.

 

[thedon5]

No. But he got the result. If he hadn't got the result, you wouldn't probably have User pinned up as mafia as well, if I'm getting it correctly.

I would have, before I even replied to P_Squared's result I had a FOS on User.

----------

That's right , we haven't analyzed some players properly with the likes of Umair and Simon.

----------



Your play has looked more of defensive player which you aren't.

----------



It had been a totally different story then , better talk about reality.

I don't agree with any of this.

 

[Varun]

I would have, before I even replied to P_Squared's result I had a FOS on User.

But P_Squared declared his result before you replied.

Honestly, I don't even know what to do except wait. Thedon can be mafia or miller and lynching him won't even help since he always comes up mafia. Lynching him right now sounds the way to go, but I'm listening to reason here, as one mistake costs us the entire game, having lost one town already. And I'll add that this is not a defense of thedon, lest he gets lynched and certainly comes up mafia I'd be on the hot seat. A lot depends on who P_Squared investigates, most probably User or an inexperienced player and hopefully nails another guilty.

In short, no lynch today and I'll go aggressive with them lynches from Day 2 since this is supposed to be a short game.

 

[thedon5]

But P_Squared declared his result before you replied.

Honestly, I don't even know what to do except wait. Thedon can be mafia or miller and lynching him won't even help since he always comes up mafia. Lynching him right now sounds the way to go, but I'm listening to reason here, as one mistake costs us the entire game, having lost one town already. And I'll add that this is not a defense of thedon, lest he gets lynched and certainly comes up mafia I'd be on the hot seat. A lot depends on who P_Squared investigates, most probably User or an inexperienced player and hopefully nails another guilty.

In short, no lynch today and I'll go aggressive with them lynches from Day 2 since this is supposed to be a short game.

I would guess that the lawyer used his ability yesterday as that's what hedger suggested, he suggested that the lawyer go on the vanilla Mafia. If I am lynched I will come up as the vanilla Mafia, when you see that I think you will know I'm town and that's it's LyLo not MyLo.

We can go for two no lynches, not just one, in the case that he picks out a townie on night 1. Still the same dynamic to the game in that it's MyLo again on day 2 and LyLo only on day 3. By then we can certainly lynch someone. As even if he has two town results, that's more than enough to work off. I'm convinced.

Unlynch: User_2010

No Lynch

 

[surendar]

Wow Varun, no lynch? Seriously with so many fishy things happening and you wanted town to go in disaster mode without giving any try? Your mention of you not playing for long time & wanting to wait for tonight to go with no lynch on day1 - clearly raising fishy points more on you.

Don's change of my image as town & With mentions of me or PS being target - clearly gives a message that I won't survive coming night 2.

Good team work guys - am sure 3 of Don, Varun, User, Simon are on mafia side. With Simon keeping silence despite knowing the fact that town needs help, somehow I feel - why can't he be lawyer? Anyways, not sure whether we will get replacement but hoping that someone takeover.

Knowing I cannot let my town down in disaster to go with no change, I stand by the cop - good or bad! I like to see townies get united!

Lynch : Don

All the townies - make it very clear, we need to be on the side of PS. Townies keeping silent is in favor of Mafia, we don't have any night roles except PS. I am sure that I will be killed tonight to take advantage of townsmen who don't speak on next day! Good luck.

 

[Sulaiman7]

Lynch : Don

 

[surendar]

But P_Squared declared his result before you replied.

Honestly, I don't even know what to do except wait. Thedon can be mafia or miller and lynching him won't even help since he always comes up mafia. Lynching him right now sounds the way to go, but I'm listening to reason here, as one mistake costs us the entire game, having lost one town already. And I'll add that this is not a defense of thedon, lest he gets lynched and certainly comes up mafia I'd be on the hot seat. A lot depends on who P_Squared investigates, most probably User or an inexperienced player and hopefully nails another guilty.

In short, no lynch today and I'll go aggressive with them lynches from Day 2 since this is supposed to be a short game.

If the investigation of PS ends up on lawyer, it will have no good on day2. The situation will be the same like today with giving benefit for mafia to have the town count down by 1.

Your no lynch is really a big letdown if you are a town or, you are on mafia side trying a clever play. Don's immediate switches with putting me in town's book & going for no lynch on User - sounds a strong message to me, there is a wonderful team work rather!

If someone calls accidental Yash's lynch & no lynch fishy, I don't have a word to describe these!

----------

. Plus, to go further Surender would have gone for me come whatever may if it was not for Psq's guilty on theDon. May I ask why?

People can assess only based on what you post here & how you react in mafia games. Whatever I have said about you, I already provided reasons for each & every point. Please read those pages that I quoted you and let me know if you need additional clarity on my reasons. I did not raise by suspect bar randomly on you + am not the only one to feel that.

 

[Sulaiman7]

If someone calls accidental Yash's lynch & no lynch fishy, I don't have a word to describe these!

He's definitely a townie , that's for sure.

 

[P Squared]

Think we need one more to hammer.

 

[Umair7]

That's right , we haven't analyzed some players properly with the likes of Umair and Simon.
@ Sully Tell me how much you have added see this is my first game and i am trying my best to understand it

Don-He has been acting like a scum especially that Miller thing makes me think that he is trying to save himself and PS is a cop who said he investigated Don and got him guilty and if i am not wrong the cop in this game is sane so yeah,

Lynch Don

 

[Varun]

Your no lynch is really a big letdown if you are a town or, you are on mafia side trying a clever play.

Because I want to play reasonably, that's why maybe?

And looks like we have the hammer. If thedon comes up as a lawyer or janitor, then he's sure mafia. If a goon, then he might be, or might be a miller but we'd still need to tread cautiously further on.

 

[thedon5]

I already told you, the lawyer was probably used on the vanilla Mafia so you'll know when I come up as vanilla Mafia that I was miller.

My pick for the Mafia team is User, Umair and either Simon or Sulaiman.

Anyway good luck fellas. You're going to need it.

 

[hedger_14]

Okay, that's hammer. You have about 6 hours if you want to unlynch.

Also, I need a replacement for Simon, ugh.

----------

Lynch Count

thedon5 (5) - P Squared, User2010, Suren, Sulaiman7, Umair2000
No Lynch (2) - Varun, thedon5