Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[Papa_Smurf]

What do you mean verified? No one has yet to counter-claim otherwise. And I dont know if mafia have been given fake characters or not, but since User hasnt claimed his, I guess not.

You'll see my point after I've been hammered, and hopefully turn your gaze to the players who have scum written all over their gameplay.

 

[treva]

I'm inclined to hold on here. I'd like to see some more posts from User and thedon who seem to have started this lynch then legged it (Obviously I know this may be due to timezones and whatever) hoping for PS to get lynched off in a swift move with us all itching to actually lynch someone.

 

[thedon5]

Before this gets out of hand, I was blocked last night, User is lying and Smurf is telling the truth. My suspicions of RPHKR remain. The fact that I was blocked, in addition to Smurf's claim of Trott is what made me drop my attack on him early in the day.

User was already one of the guys I isolated who could be Mafia, so now I am 100% sure he is Mafia. There was no BD at work here.

Unlynch: RPHKR

Lynch: User2010

Now I'll read through the rest of the thread and reply to some more of it.

----------

I realise Smurf could indeed be the Mafia RB, but for me, User is easily more likely to be Mafia.

----------

What is your character User?

There's another reason. Perhaps the Mafia haven't been given fake claims? Maybe User is having trouble thinking of who to claim as?

I still am a bit lost as to why Smurf still thinks I am Mafia though... Clearly the kill still went through, so it is unlikely that I would be Mafia if the RB was successful...

----------

Oh and yes, this was completely due to timezones that I was off. I was asleep.

----------

Seeing as User was completely willing to rule out anything Smurf had to say before bandwagon lynching him, I'm inclined to believe that Smurf is more likely the town RB than the Mafia RB. I'm sure he would have defended Smurf to some extent if he was Mafia RB.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Papa Smurf (4) - User, Barmyarmy, RPHKR, BKB
RPHKR (1) - Treva
Barmyarmy (1) - Aditya
User (3) - Papa Smurf, Ste, thedon

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch. There are plenty of hours left in the day... for now.

 

[Sedition]

Okay consider me officially tweaking confused

 

[thedon5]

What's confusing? User is lying, and Mafia, and Smurf is seemingly mostly telling the truth.

 

[treva]

I'm certainly swaying on the side of keeping PS in this. We've all doubted him but now things are starting to come to light. I just don't think we should lynch him off yet.

Let's get some pressure on User. Need to see what he has to say about his no character claim business. I'd suggest that if there are no fake claims to fall back on then the mafia are among those who have not claimed at all yet.

Unlynch: RPHKR
Lynch: User

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Papa Smurf (4) - User, Barmyarmy, RPHKR, BKB
Barmyarmy (1) - Aditya
User (4) - Papa Smurf, Ste, thedon, Treva

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch. There are plenty of hours left in the day... for now.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Alright guys, we know at least one of Don or Smurf or both are mafia. Don says he was blocked so I am lying. But, Smurf did say he blocked no one!

Also, I knew about BD because I and my target were switched first night. I got a result saying 'You saw User around xyz'

And, I am Stuart Broad. Just for people who want to know more my PM says that I am good at following batsmen and so am the tracker.

And, I obviously don't want to give out my night 2 result as it does nothing but instead brings out another town PR, I think.

I am heading to play some Cricket now so won't show up till 3 hours at least.

We have two people here. Don and Smurf. But, Don has been caught red handed saying he was blocked when he wasn't. So I will lynch Don.

Unlynch
Lynch: Don

 

[thedon5]

I'm certainly swaying on the side of keeping PS in this. We've all doubted him but now things are starting to come to light. I just don't think we should lynch him off yet.

Let's get some pressure on User. Need to see what he has to say about his no character claim business. I'd suggest that if there are no fake claims to fall back on then the mafia are among those who have not claimed at all yet.

Unlynch: RPHKR
Lynch: User

It's quite obvious that the Mafia are among those who haven't claimed yet, everyone who has claimed so far, barring User and possibly Smurf have had solid claims which haven't been CCed.

Why pressure? If he is lying about one thing, he is lying about his claim as well though.

What exactly could have happened surrounding the BD though? Perhaps Smurf was switched with someone else who didn't visit anyone, but does that mean Smurf would've still been able to block me? I guess I'm a bit unsure about exactly how the BD works.

For me, it's either Smurf or User and I'm more convinced that we lynch User.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Wow, I can't really believe you guys for jumping on me without really using your brains. Don, how are you so sure that Smurf is town? You weren't blocked, mafia!

 

[thedon5]

Alright guys, we know at least one of Don or Smurf or both are mafia. Don says he was blocked so I am lying. But, Smurf did say he blocked no one!

Also, I knew about BD because I and my target were switched first night. I got a result saying 'You saw User around xyz'

And, I am Stuart Broad. Just for people who want to know more my PM says that I am good at following batsmen and so am the tracker.

And, I obviously don't want to give out my night 2 result as it does nothing but instead brings out another town PR, I think.

I am heading to play some Cricket now so won't show up till 3 hours at least.

We have two people here. Don and Smurf. But, Don has been caught red handed saying he was blocked when he wasn't. So I will lynch Don.

Unlynch
Lynch: Don

He clearly said he blocked me. I was blocked last night so not sure where you are getting that from.

More scummy behaviour now, trying to lynch the guy who has put the heat back onto you.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Ha ha ha. That's why you need to read the thread too and not just the mafia QT. He blocked no one. Guys, I am 100% sure now that Don is lying!

 

[Sedition]

Don, you might aswell claim your full role now that you've said you were blocked and must be a town PR if you're not mafia. Very strange turn of events here, but I'm inclined to believe User right now.

 

[thedon5]

Wow, I can't really believe you guys for jumping on me without really using your brains. Don, how are you so sure that Smurf is town? You weren't blocked, mafia!

That line about your PM actually makes me believe you a bit more tbh, the part where the tracker is good at following batsmen. Broad is again a solid claim, and I think from the write up we know for sure there is a tracker in the game (plus, it's consistent in PD's games). You also haven't been CCed. Still a good chance you were affected by the BD, and seeing as it was mentioned in the write-up, surely the BD's actions were significant, maybe switching Smurf and someone else. I would like to know what that would mean for his block on me, if he was BDed, would that mean he would still block me?

I know for sure Smurf is either the town or Mafia roleblocker. I know I have been looking somewhat suspicious to the town as well this game, but I don't see how blocking a townie is exactly going to help us.

Unlynch: User2010

I want to hear what Smurf, and others, have to say. But right now I am more leaning towards lynching Smurf.