Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Who said I wanted to mod? 
Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)
- Thread starter puddleduck
- Start date
Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Pd'll have to come online first.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Yeah guys if you could thanks! Not got internet till Saturday.
----------
Abhas can send you the spectator thread.
User was lynched. He is dead. He was Stuart Broad
----------
Abhas can send you the spectator thread.
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
They knew he was the danger man as his voice was heard more than the others. It was decided he will have to go.
It is now Day 6. With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
Someone change the thread title please.
Treva is dead. He was Alastair Cook.
It is now Day 6. With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
Someone change the thread title please.
Last edited:
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
I was blocked last night. Makes no sense to me that I would be blocked and treva would be killed. What about Colin, when he is clearly the better player than me?
Perhaps treva was killed since he was very active, or, more importantly, since he was really on to something there.
I'm sure there are two Mafia left since that would make sense, so a really good chance User was town. I was never in favour of lynching him, but anyway, it happened, so we move on. Seems like a mislynch to me.
1. RPHKR
2. thedon5
3. Zhuorb
4. Aditya
5. BKB V2
6. Barmy
7. Ste
The remaining players. Pretty sure it's seven alive btw, so it takes four to lynch.
For me, User most likely being town to some extent clears Colin, but not completely I suppose.
I got my town result on Ste, so I'm not going to get suspicious of him just yet. Also, I still remember that post where he asked what the Mafia QT was. Ste doesn't strike me as the kind of guy who would ask that when he indeed lnew exactly what the Mafia QT was as well, so I'm a bit hesitant to go after him even if I don't take into account my result. Zhuorb and Aditya I think are confirmed town. So there are three guys who could perhaps still be Mafia.
FOS: RPHKR, BKB1991, barmyarmy
Of the three, I am least in favour of lynching Colin for the reasons previously mentioned, but he remains an option I suppose.
The other two would make a team I suppose. Neither have really been adding much to discussions, especially recently. They have added something, but nothing much compared to the contributions of others. That is one problem. Also their general gameplay hasn't convinced me much.
So I'll be equally glad to lynch either of the two.
Perhaps treva was killed since he was very active, or, more importantly, since he was really on to something there.
I'm sure there are two Mafia left since that would make sense, so a really good chance User was town. I was never in favour of lynching him, but anyway, it happened, so we move on. Seems like a mislynch to me.
1. RPHKR
2. thedon5
3. Zhuorb
4. Aditya
5. BKB V2
6. Barmy
7. Ste
The remaining players. Pretty sure it's seven alive btw, so it takes four to lynch.
For me, User most likely being town to some extent clears Colin, but not completely I suppose.
I got my town result on Ste, so I'm not going to get suspicious of him just yet. Also, I still remember that post where he asked what the Mafia QT was. Ste doesn't strike me as the kind of guy who would ask that when he indeed lnew exactly what the Mafia QT was as well, so I'm a bit hesitant to go after him even if I don't take into account my result. Zhuorb and Aditya I think are confirmed town. So there are three guys who could perhaps still be Mafia.
FOS: RPHKR, BKB1991, barmyarmy
Of the three, I am least in favour of lynching Colin for the reasons previously mentioned, but he remains an option I suppose.
The other two would make a team I suppose. Neither have really been adding much to discussions, especially recently. They have added something, but nothing much compared to the contributions of others. That is one problem. Also their general gameplay hasn't convinced me much.
So I'll be equally glad to lynch either of the two.
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
Oops, yeah 7 it is. I was thinking I am alive as well.
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
Forgiveable mistake.
.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
Thedon, just a simple question I'd like to put forward and I've asked this earlier too but just so I know whether your views NOW are. I'm expecting a very straight forward answer so here it goes, going by your second last post you believe Colin, hence suggesting that this game has 2 cops, right? If so, surely not both of you are normal cops. One has to sane or paranoid. Correct me if I'm wrong.
There are definitely two cops but not quite in the way we all thought. I suppose I may as well move things along by revealing my result.
I got a mafia result on Don which took a while to work through but I reckon I've got there in the end. He's the mafia rolecop.
It fits his role perfectly and gives him a solid claim. Role cops dig dirt on people and as a tabloid reporter he's not with the forces of good!
I wondered how the mafia had been so successful at knowing who to block and target and the role cop explains it.
As far as I can work out Smurf was the mafia roleblocker, Don is the rolecop which leaves ste as the Godfather. I could be wrong about ste but I think if he was town Don would be going after him.
Don wasn't blocked last night because the roleblocker is dead. It's possible he got a choice of roles to use when Smurf died as User was blocked on night 5.
I find it very interesting that Don is obviously now panicking about the fact User being town clears me. He's now trying hard to distance himself from the lynch.
Anyway well played mafia. The fact both Smurf and Don claimed power roles was a realyl good strategy and totally threw us. It was proved that Smurf was lying by User and now I've got a guilty result on Don.
Lynch: thedon
I got a mafia result on Don which took a while to work through but I reckon I've got there in the end. He's the mafia rolecop.
It fits his role perfectly and gives him a solid claim. Role cops dig dirt on people and as a tabloid reporter he's not with the forces of good!
I wondered how the mafia had been so successful at knowing who to block and target and the role cop explains it.
As far as I can work out Smurf was the mafia roleblocker, Don is the rolecop which leaves ste as the Godfather. I could be wrong about ste but I think if he was town Don would be going after him.
Don wasn't blocked last night because the roleblocker is dead. It's possible he got a choice of roles to use when Smurf died as User was blocked on night 5.
I find it very interesting that Don is obviously now panicking about the fact User being town clears me. He's now trying hard to distance himself from the lynch.
Anyway well played mafia. The fact both Smurf and Don claimed power roles was a realyl good strategy and totally threw us. It was proved that Smurf was lying by User and now I've got a guilty result on Don.
Lynch: thedon
Similar threads
