Abhas
Retired Administrator
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2004
- Location
- New Delhi, India
Everyone, just DIE!!!!
Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)
- Thread starter puddleduck
- Start date
You've dismissed it several times and are continuing to do so. You've said that you're convinced he's town because of your cop result. Only now are you conceding he "might" be mafia.
----------
To me, that's quite a revealing comment. It's you admitting that you knew he was roleblocker, probably mafia, and yet chose to leave him alone.
----------
It comes down to plausibility. People want to win this game hence they go for the more plausible explanation.
Clearly I wouldn't be putting my neck on the line if I thought you were innocent. Let's just say I get you lynched and you turn out to be town. I would definitely be getting lynched myself tomorrow.
No-one would believe that I had a guilty result on ste.
It's not LyLo and we can afford a mis-lynch but I'd rather not risk one hence I'm targeting you and not Ste.
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
People aren't going to know if I was town or not, thus you can easily lynch off Ste.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
Lynch : Ste
Best way to know who among Colin and Thedon is lying. Adding to that, if we are to take a gamble, it has to be this. He hasn't been active, his defense has been poor whereas he has been pretty good while attacking other members, which I even mentioned earlier, is really scummy. He only posts while he's under pressure and the bulletproof claim, just didn't come at the right time.
----------
RPHKR, who did you protect last night?
Best way to know who among Colin and Thedon is lying. Adding to that, if we are to take a gamble, it has to be this. He hasn't been active, his defense has been poor whereas he has been pretty good while attacking other members, which I even mentioned earlier, is really scummy. He only posts while he's under pressure and the bulletproof claim, just didn't come at the right time.
----------
RPHKR, who did you protect last night?
Here is the crux of the problem for Don as far as I can see:
I was tracked around Abhas on night 2. Abhas was neither killed nor blocked that night so how can I be the killer or roleblocker?
You have nothing to support your claim except the write-up which to my mind is ambiguous and suggests you could be mafia.
I was tracked around Abhas on night 2. Abhas was neither killed nor blocked that night so how can I be the killer or roleblocker?
You have nothing to support your claim except the write-up which to my mind is ambiguous and suggests you could be mafia.
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
That's because I have only talked about the write-up thus far. There are obviously other things to look at, such as my gameplay which is clearly more important and has been town.
It isn't confirmed that User was town by any means. Btw, how exactly do you know that Abhas was not roleblocked? A hunch you are stating as a fact maybe?
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
I've only just woke up.
Yet again i'm going to say that colin is revered as one of, if not the, best player in the game. He has claimed cop for I think 2 night phases now. How he is still alive if he is town is beyond me really.
Seems to me like colin is mafia, it doesn't make sense for the mafia to keep him alive this long. Also a lot of his theory involved smurf as mafia role blocker. With the characters we know of now I can't really see how trott can be assumed mafia like this. Maybe he could be, i guess, due to his perceived selfish play. But then that'd lend him to being much more of an individual character than a mafia member. It's much more likely that he was pro town.
Treva was the double voter and was suspicious of colin mainly. If i was mafia and colin was town i'd have went for someone like zhourab or bkb, so i could then vote with treva and effectively have colin lynched off today.
Yet again i'm going to say that colin is revered as one of, if not the, best player in the game. He has claimed cop for I think 2 night phases now. How he is still alive if he is town is beyond me really.
Seems to me like colin is mafia, it doesn't make sense for the mafia to keep him alive this long. Also a lot of his theory involved smurf as mafia role blocker. With the characters we know of now I can't really see how trott can be assumed mafia like this. Maybe he could be, i guess, due to his perceived selfish play. But then that'd lend him to being much more of an individual character than a mafia member. It's much more likely that he was pro town.
Treva was the double voter and was suspicious of colin mainly. If i was mafia and colin was town i'd have went for someone like zhourab or bkb, so i could then vote with treva and effectively have colin lynched off today.
Last edited:
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
No coincidence that people are only going after me because you say you got a result. When I mention I get a result, people start trying to use it against me, but since it is you that got the result, now it's 100% true.
Again, people accuse me of looking into my result too far. Now others are looking at someone else's too far? Makes no sense.
People were barely suspicious of me at all earlier, and very suspicious of Colin, now it is the other way around with just one fake result.
Again, people accuse me of looking into my result too far. Now others are looking at someone else's too far? Makes no sense.
People were barely suspicious of me at all earlier, and very suspicious of Colin, now it is the other way around with just one fake result.
ste_mc_efc
Chairman of Selectors
he should be against it, really.
7 left with 4 to lynch and we aren't sure if there are 2 or 3 mafia left (probably 2, though)
if i get lynched and someone gets night killed that's 5 left with 2 mafia at least. Almost game over.
Obviously there may not be a night kill if the doc saves the right person. But the idea of lynching someone you think could be town to clear yourself at this stage is just terrible.
By all means lynch me if you are trying to find a mafia and you think i'm the best candidate to lynch. but to apply that reasoning at this stage is beyond foolish.
thedon5
Panel of Selectors
A point I was making earlier. I ask, why the hell would treva be killed, and not me or Colin? And why was I blocked, not Colin? As I said in my first post, I think treva was on to something and the Mafia (Colin) is trying to stop it.
Clearly Colin is just going to use this as proof we are working together, one post, even though you don't directly mention me.
It's pretty obvious isn't it? If I die it immediately becomes apparent that Don was lying about his claim and he gets lynched. He has been keeping me alive.
----------
The point you're missing is that the mafia have fake claims. Smurf claimed roleblocker and the fact he was Trott doesn't mean he wasn't mafia.
----------
If I was mafia I would have killed the person who has been most suspicious of my play throughout the game, Aditya (also the person who got me killed last game!). Treva was the obvious target last night because they knew the doc (probably) couldn't protect him two nights running.
----------
Like I said. Two reasons:
1. Killing me shows I was telling the truth about being cop.
2. I might have been protected last night. Far safer to kill Treva.
Similar threads
