Octavius
Club Cricketer
Easy situation, umpire was misleading to Murali by walking in when Murali looked over at him, but the blame has to go squarley on Murali's shoulders, as an international cricketer you should be aware when the ball is in play and when it isnt, quite clearly the fielder was still fielding the ball and there is no way he should have walked from his crease. Simply an error of judgement by Murali, pounced on by McCullum.
Cricket is a competitive game, so i think McCullum was quite diligent in whipping the bails off and appealing. It should have been up to the Captain and umpires to come together and say something.
As far as i am concerned no blame rests with McCulum, Jerling is a new umpire to international cricket (and a good one from what i saw) who made a slight error in giving the wrong message to murali, then murali missed Jerling signalling him to get back.
McCullum and Jerling knew the ball was still in play, Murali did not, Murali pays the price.
Cricket is a competitive game, so i think McCullum was quite diligent in whipping the bails off and appealing. It should have been up to the Captain and umpires to come together and say something.
As far as i am concerned no blame rests with McCulum, Jerling is a new umpire to international cricket (and a good one from what i saw) who made a slight error in giving the wrong message to murali, then murali missed Jerling signalling him to get back.
McCullum and Jerling knew the ball was still in play, Murali did not, Murali pays the price.