End Game Avengers: Endgame | Town (CerealKiller and Ashutosh) wins!

[RUDI]

That's basically most of the players in the game if not all.

I have posted whatever I had. You guys can decide for yourself. Just remember, one mislynch and game over for us.

Your vote counts. Are you not going to lynch Sod?

 

[Gaurav_7]

PE, however, holds a slight advantage (51-49) for the time being simply because he was the first to claim cop.

Don't you think that was the exact plan? To be at advantage when someone counters him? As I have said, an exceptional move by him to get ahead in the game and win it easily by lynching a townie. A well thought out plan, simple.[DOUBLEPOST=1557487009][/DOUBLEPOST]

Your vote counts. Are you not going to lynch Sod?

I already have.

 

[RUDI]

This setup has very less number of players and we don't know if Jack was killed because Mafia targetted him OR he was killed because he gave immunity to the person whom mafia targetted.

El loco cleared this. He was killed as the bodyguard!

 

[RUDI]

I just went through both Sod and Gary's ISO's:

Rebel has been too cautious in his approach this game , having a powerrole might be the reason for it. I soft cleared Rebel as town before and am willing to do so again, because for the simple reason that Sod has been sawing doubt and confusion.

Unlynch: Rebel

Lynch: PresidentEvil

 

[CerealKiller]

That is why I said he claimed the character he shouldn't have because I am Thor. He has been very smart from the beginning mentioning he knows nothing about the marvel universe. See, he knows if one townie is lynched today, it's game over for us. That is why he put the trap on me.

Pretty convenient for you to claim the exact same character after he'd claimed. What are the odds that he fake claims the correct character name?

Lynch : Rebel2k19

And i'm pretty sure @LBW. is your partner, based on reasons stated previously

 

[asprin]

What are the odds that he fake claims the correct character name?

This got me thinking. And I began to wonder why would Rebel counter claim with the same character (Thor) and same role (cop) as PE. He is experienced enough to know that the probability of PE getting a 100% match is too little/minuscule and should Rebel continue with it, he would, in all likelyhood, be opposed with this very argument. And yet he does it.

He could have used any other different character (say Captain Marvel or Vision etc) and kept the same role as cop if he was fake claiming to avoid one major counter argument (that of PE having the exact combo) but he didn't. This, in my opinion, could be because he is telling the truth.

Think about it....

I'm enjoying this because just when I start to sway towards one side and confirm my stand, a new post makes me see a new angle. This time though I think I'm leaning in the right direction.

 

[Targaryen]

That is why I said he claimed the character he shouldn't have because I am Thor. He has been very smart from the beginning mentioning he knows nothing about the marvel universe. See, he knows if one townie is lynched today, it's game over for us. That is why he put the trap on me.

Put the trap on you? Come on, you are the mafia. Don't make it funny by giving a 'he is smart' reply. Everyone know how smart you are.

Don't you think that was the exact plan? To be at advantage when someone counters him? As I have said, an exceptional move by him to get ahead in the game and win it easily by lynching a townie. A well thought out plan, simple.

Yes, start again with your same old dialogue. Exceptional, smart etc...

I just went through both Sod and Gary's ISO's:

Rebel has been too cautious in his approach this game , having a powerrole might be the reason for it. I soft cleared Rebel as town before and am willing to do so again, because for the simple reason that Sod has been sawing doubt and confusion.

Unlynch: Rebel

Lynch: PresidentEvil

Doubt and confusion? Just show me where did that doubt arise? I'm crystal clear from start of game. All the confusions have arrived when Rebel faked claimed it.

Rebel has been saying that he was protected by Jack on night 1. Jack was Bodygaurd and he got killed. First, Rudi comes out and says Jack saved him, then Rebel does it. It's a obvious thing that why would Jack save them why he was the one to put these two under FOS? Why did Rebel start behaving diplomatic towards Rudi and then he comes out and fake claims stating that Rudi is town. Come on, if you were really a town cop, why would you investigate the guy you seem to defend for his gameplay? Why is that you suspect Rudi on day 2 (yesterday) when you know that Rudi is town as per your investigation (which is obviously fake)?

There you go, the fake cop claims his role as mine and states that he got investigation result - Rudi as town. But still he is suspicious on him. Mind you, this game doesn't have 'sanity' thing. So cop is obviously sane. But still he manages to suspect. Lol

What more evidence you need. It's quite open and obvious. [DOUBLEPOST=1557491821][/DOUBLEPOST]

He is experienced enough to know that the probability of PE getting a 100% match is too little/minuscule and should Rebel continue with it, he would, in all likelyhood, be opposed with this very argument. And yet he does it.

That is where his experience comes into play. I'm not as experienced as him to fake claim as someone else and defend myself. I would been down by now if I did so.

 

[RUDI]

I investigated Rudi last night, he is a townie.

Regardless Rebels alignment, I am hard cleared as townie! If he is scum, fake role claiming he will know I am town and if he is the real cop, his investigation cleared me.

Doubt and confusion? Just show me where did that doubt arise? I'm crystal clear from start of game. All the confusions have arrived when Rebel faked claimed it.

Rebel has been saying that he was protected by Jack on night 1. Jack was Bodygaurd and he got killed. First, Rudi comes out and says Jack saved him, then Rebel does it. It's a obvious thing that why would Jack save them why he was the one to put these two under FOS? Why did Rebel start behaving diplomatic towards Rudi and then he comes out and fake claims stating that Rudi is town. Come on, if you were really a town cop, why would you investigate the guy you seem to defend for his gameplay? Why is that you suspect Rudi on day 2 (yesterday) when you know that Rudi is town as per your investigation (which is obviously fake)?

There you go, the fake cop claims his role as mine and states that he got investigation result - Rudi as town. But still he is suspicious on him. Mind you, this game doesn't have 'sanity' thing. So cop is obviously sane. But still he manages to suspect. Lol

What more evidence you need. It's quite open and obvious.

This defense sounds more townish than that of Rebels

Unlynch: PresidentEvil

Lynch: Rebel

 

[Ashutosh.]

I agree with PE and CK.

Unlynch : LBW

Lynch : Rebel2k19

 

[Gaurav_7]

Put the trap on you? Come on, you are the mafia. Don't make it funny by giving a 'he is smart' reply. Everyone know how smart you are.

Yes, start again with your same old dialogue. Exceptional, smart etc...

Doubt and confusion? Just show me where did that doubt arise? I'm crystal clear from start of game. All the confusions have arrived when Rebel faked claimed it.

Rebel has been saying that he was protected by Jack on night 1. Jack was Bodygaurd and he got killed. First, Rudi comes out and says Jack saved him, then Rebel does it. It's a obvious thing that why would Jack save them why he was the one to put these two under FOS? Why did Rebel start behaving diplomatic towards Rudi and then he comes out and fake claims stating that Rudi is town. Come on, if you were really a town cop, why would you investigate the guy you seem to defend for his gameplay? Why is that you suspect Rudi on day 2 (yesterday) when you know that Rudi is town as per your investigation (which is obviously fake)?

There you go, the fake cop claims his role as mine and states that he got investigation result - Rudi as town. But still he is suspicious on him. Mind you, this game doesn't have 'sanity' thing. So cop is obviously sane. But still he manages to suspect. Lol

What more evidence you need. It's quite open and obvious. [DOUBLEPOST=1557491821][/DOUBLEPOST]
That is where his experience comes into play. I'm not as experienced as him to fake claim as someone else and defend myself. I would been down by now if I did so.

So you are saying just because I am experienced in mafia, I can get away with faking anything? Then why is it me playing mafia? I should just give up maybe. Because when the 'You are too smart because you have played more mafia than me' card comes into the picture, I cannot do much.

Coming to why I posted about being suspicious of Rudi, I was obviously trying to see who all (read: mafia) jump the gun. It was because I wanted to analyse everyone's response and then see who is who. Hence when Ashutosh lynched him, I argued with you. You questioned your own mate. Anyone who re reads the game will know how Ashutosh is being orchestrated. Whatever he has posted seems scripted.

And I say smart play because it is smart play from you! You have so easily got everyone to suspect and lynch me and once I am lynched, you and Ashutosh win. It is simple. The cop goes, you take out one more at night and game over.

Regardless Rebels alignment, I am hard cleared as townie! If he is scum, fake role claiming he will know I am town and if he is the real cop, his investigation cleared me.


This defense sounds more townish than that of Rebels

Unlynch: PresidentEvil

Lynch: Rebel

Yeah just because he says he would be done by now if he had fake claimed. All those emotional posts are definitely townish...

Pretty convenient for you to claim the exact same character after he'd claimed. What are the odds that he fake claims the correct character name?

Lynch : Rebel2k19

And i'm pretty sure @LBW. is your partner, based on reasons stated previously

Exactly. Just re read my first response after Sod lynched me. I there itself said you played well but the character and role you claimed is what is wrong. It is because I know I am Thor and a town cop. The odds aren't existent but that is where I said very smart play by Sod.

Also it is not like he is a newbie in the game. He is experienced too to play surely. Just see how nicely he plays the 'Rebel is more experienced than me' card and tries to get away with it.

I think I am one away from the hammer and with Ashutosh still not voting, it is game over as soon as he comes on.

Just go through the game once more and then decide you all.

This got me thinking. And I began to wonder why would Rebel counter claim with the same character (Thor) and same role (cop) as PE. He is experienced enough to know that the probability of PE getting a 100% match is too little/minuscule and should Rebel continue with it, he would, in all likelyhood, be opposed with this very argument. And yet he does it.

He could have used any other different character (say Captain Marvel or Vision etc) and kept the same role as cop if he was fake claiming to avoid one major counter argument (that of PE having the exact combo) but he didn't. This, in my opinion, could be because he is telling the truth.

Think about it....

I'm enjoying this because just when I start to sway towards one side and confirm my stand, a new post makes me see a new angle. This time though I think I'm leaning in the right direction.

I know I am telling the truth, simple. If people are going to question the co incidence of Sod's claim being similar to mine then I can't do much.

He had to be the first one to claim to look innocent which he has been successful at. Being the only town PR remaining, I would never out myself unless it is a sure town win which it isn't! But one mislynch and it is game over for us. Just one more time try and think of the plan he has executed to near perfection here.

Show me where he tried to really push at me so hard if he knew I am mafia and he is town. He just claims the role and there itself wins half the battle. Me having exactly the same character and role is what has gotten me so far and talking till now.

I cannot win the emotional arguments though so all upto you guys to decide. Cheers.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I agree with PE and CK.

Unlynch : LBW

Lynch : Rebel2k19

Well, it's all over!

 

[RUDI]

Unlynch

Kuddos to you both for your defense. But I am the real town cop !

Spoiler

Just kidding

 

[Targaryen]

I agree with PE and CK.

Unlynch : LBW

Lynch : Rebel2k19

That's the hammer. You all will know that I was actually saying the truth and it is Rebel who is faking it.

Please make sure to not lynch anyone on day 3 if you are not sure. Because 1 mislynch is a game over for us. My sacrifice shouldn't go in vein.

 

[RUDI]

Lynch Count:

Ashutosh (1) - LBW.
LBW. (1) - Ashutosh
Rebel2k19 (1) - PresidentEvil

6 alive - 4 for hammer

Well you have hit the nail on the head here! Just that you claimed the character and role you shouldn't have. Nice move though to try and take me out early on and clear your path. As you couldn't do that an night even after you ordered to kill me because Jack surely must have protected me, here you come out as a cop and try to get me lynched as mafia.

A very well thought out mafia move and I appreciate it. But let me post my part now and let the others decide whom to believe. I am Thor, the town cop. I investigated Rudi last night, he is a townie. Hence I was so reluctant on lynching him today. I was mainly supporting Ashutosh to try and see if he pushes hard for a lynch. And you counter questioning him makes me feel, you both are a team!

No way the only PR remaining would openly out himself without even trying to give subtle hints. Sod outing means the real cop, which is me will have to out and there goes our only PR remaining at the night. If I am lynched now, 3 townies and 2 mafias remain. At the night, one more townie is surely killed. Game over on day 3. A very nice move Sod but if people will think clearly and then decide then they will know who is who.

Lynch: PresidentEvil

Pretty convenient for you to claim the exact same character after he'd claimed. What are the odds that he fake claims the correct character name?

Lynch : Rebel2k19

And i'm pretty sure @LBW. is your partner, based on reasons stated previously

I agree with PE and CK.

Unlynch : LBW

Lynch : Rebel2k19

Was that really the hammer?

 

[Targaryen]

Was that really the hammer?

Yes, I had lynched him first, followed by CK, You and Ashutosh.