Expert Cop Mafia 1 - Endgame Town win

[barmyarmy]

Haari is going to have produced an algorithm before too long...

----------

My apologies to user2010. His method does take account of mendaciousness.

 

[Abhas]

Most likely, the mafia would have claimed a town result. This can help him blend in as the normal cop.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I can't get what Haari is doing. As, Colin said, one has made up his result. So, the way I am doing is, it is correct. See my above post. When we take all 5 players, select any one of them as scum and analyze, we get possibilities. But, only when we take Abhas, we are sure, that there are 3 people with only two roles. As this game cannot have that, we are sure Abhas is town. For Abhas to be mafia, the game rules would have to be changed.

 

[Haarithan]

Ah that's right. Damn me, all gone wasted!

 

[barmyarmy]

Ah that's right. Damn me, all gone wasted!

Don't worry. It made for good reading

 

[Abhas]

Don't worry. It made for good reading

You read all that?!

----------

Assuming User as scum -

Haari -> Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
Smurf -> Naive/Insane (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Naive/Insane (User as Town)

 

[barmyarmy]

You read all that?!

Don't be silly! I was just trying to make him feel better...

 

[Haarithan]

Assumption: Haari, Abhas are town.

Haari -> Normal/Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
User -> Normal/Paranoid/Insane/Mafia (Smurf as mafia)
Smurf -> Normal/Naive/Insane/Mafia (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Normal/Paranoid/Insane/Mafia (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Normal/Naive/Insane (User as town)

Case 1: User's mafia

Haari -> Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
Smurf -> Normal/Naive (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Insane/Paranoid (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Naive/Insane (User as town)

Possible with Smurf being Normal and Abhas being Naive.


Case 2: Smurf's mafia

Haari -> Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
User -> Normal/Paranoid (Smurf as mafia)
Aditya -> Paranoid/Normal (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Normal/Naive (User as town)

Possible with me being Insane and Abhas being Naive.


Case 3: Aditya's mafia

Haari -> Normal/Paranoid (Adi as mafia)
User -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)
Smurf -> Normal/Naive (Abhas as town)
Abhas -> Naive/Normal (User as town)

Possible with me being Paranoid and User being Insane.

So by the looks of it, we're gonna one more night atleast for further leads.

 

[Abhas]

Assuming User as scum -

Haari -> Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
Smurf -> Naive/Insane/Normal (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Naive/Insane (User as Town)

Corrected

 

[Haarithan]

This's for the others. Explains why I'm not yet cleared while Abhas's cleared.

Case 4: Haari's mafia

User -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)
Smurf -> Naive/Normal (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Insane/Paranoid (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Normal/Naive (User as town)

Possible.


Case 5: Abhas's mafia

Haari -> Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
User -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)
Smurf -> Naive/Insane (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)

Not Possible.


With that, I'd like to no lynch.

 

[Abhas]

If we can quickly complete the night and switch to day 2, I'm happy with a No Lynch now. I think we haave taken into account pretty much all the possibilities with User's analysis. Seriously.. couldn't have done without him!

 

[Haarithan]

Yep, I want Day 2 already. Which is why I no lynched. C'mon, two more to go.

 

[Abhas]

Wait for everyone to come online.. Night won't finish before all roles are in.

----------

Assuming User as scum -

Haari -> Paranoid/Insane (Adi as mafia)
Smurf -> Naive/Insane/Normal (Abhas as town)
Aditya -> Paranoid/Insane (Smurf as mafia)
Abhas -> Naive/Insane (User as Town)

Corrected

 

[barmyarmy]

Well I have a meeting now anyway.
It makes sense to move to night 1 at this point so send me your roles whenever you want. I won't be replying to them until I have all the roles in as one of you is going to wind up dead...

 

[Abhas]

Can we investigate the same person on consecutive nights?