Surprised Ravi didn't even make the 12 but I guess it makes sense that Shahzad's retained in the squad. Liking the bowling attack too, Finn, Anderson and Broad should be very handy if conditions are similar to those seen in the Aus-Pak series. Nice to see they've ditched Bresnan also, he was never good enough for Test cricket.
Agree 100000000000% on Bresnan, my biggest worries in the squad are Morgan (good enough?) and Anderson (consistency) Bopara is maybe left out because the selectors want to show consistency in selecting Morgan, not that they show consistency from one series to the next with ODIs and T20s thrown in the mix. They could easily have picked a XIII
Strauss - 5622 runs @ 43.92
Cook - 4197 runs @ 44.18
Trott - 751 runs @ 50.07
Pietersen - 5166 runs @ 49.20
Collingwood - 4057 runs @ 43.62 & 15 wkts @ 61.33
Morgan - 81 runs @ 41.50
Prior - 1662 runs @ 40.54
Swann - 605 runs @ 30.25 & 91 wkts @ 30.02
Broad - 846 runs @ 25.64 & 83 wkts @ 36.16
Shazhad - 5 runs @ 5.00 & 8 wkts @ 15.75
Anderson - 483 runs @ 14.21 & 165 wkts @ 34.27
Finn - 3 runs @ 3.00 & 19 wkts @ 23.42
Bopara - 502 runs @ 33.47
Bresnan - 125 runs @ 41.67 & 14 wkts @ 35.14
I'd say from the XII selected a bowler is likely to be left out without Bresnan in the squad, otherwise you could have a tail of Prior, Swann, Broad, Shazhad, Anderson, Finn which Pakistan could mop up very quickly. I've thrown in Bopara and Bresnan for comparison, I'm unconvinced by Morgan while Anderson and Broad need to show greater consistency with the ball as both have very disappointing averages with the ball for their respective abilities.
Bear in mind those stats include Finn and Shazhad who've only bowled against Bangladesh, Bresnan has only ever played against Bangladesh and West Indies while Bopara's breakdown is below :
Bopara vs
Australia : 105 runs @ 15.00
Sri Lanka : 42 runs @ 8.40
West Indies : 355 runs @ 118.33
So his Test average is sustained by three 100s vs West Indies, he has a HS of just 35 against Australia and Sri Lanka from SEVEN Tests (12 innings) I don't think the "Test recall" was as imminent and expected as the media make it sound, his Test career may only be 10 Tests old, but lacks substance thus far so no matter how many county runs he scores or headlines he makes, when the crunch has come he hasn't performed. His Ashes average says it all, plus his tendancy to get in and not go on in the big games is as worrying as his ability to score ducks :
Bopara vs Australia/Pakistan
Ducks : 4
1-8 : 3
9-17 : 0
18-35 : 5
36+ : 0
Reached 18-35 FIVE times and got out before he made 40, bowled out for a duck or single figures the other seven times. I know it's hard to average 12.25 with impressive scores, but frankly having got to 20 in 1/3 of his innings, he needed to make 40-50
at least once. Pakistan may give him second chances, down under the aussies will have his number. So in the shorter term this is probably a wise non-selection