Psych-Ward Mafia - Night 4!!

Oh god that's a bad loss! MaD could have prevented a lot of killings had he quickly discovered the Schizophrenic.

Now, hopefully the psycho will knock down the mafia instead of town, so that we have a better chance of winning.

On another note, I feel Aray might be the Psycho, because this is the second time he's emphasizing on his abilities.

FOS: ARay
 
Oh god that's a bad loss! MaD could have prevented a lot of killings had he quickly discovered the Schizophrenic.

Now, hopefully the psycho will knock down the mafia instead of town, so that we have a better chance of winning.

On another note, I feel Aray might be the Psycho, because this is the second time he's emphasizing on his abilities.

FOS: ARay

I am emphasizing it so that all the players are aware of his role. I doubt being the psycho himself I would want much more attention for myself by boldly being the centre of attention. Intersting though, abhas, you do not comment on User2010's lynch above. You immediately direct an attack on me with you first post after MaD is killed? Maybe because you might have possibly pre-planned it? Possibly set me up as a lynch for the second day?
 
Yep, I agree someone has to go. Be it me or someone else, it will give us a shot. Also if we somehow tail a mafia under FOS they will all in one way or the other defend the person. Maybe not now but in the longer run it will help.

FOS: Varun

Quick to lynch in his first game? Could be a rookie mafia mistake?

Having a quick go against Varun knowing that this was his first game. We all know he wasn't a mafia now.

Interesting quote there Abhas. So does that make it two?

Two things for sure is, if Varun is mafia so is Hedger, and if Varun ends up a townie so is hedger. Either way we could lynch Varun to find out whether he ends up mafia?

The question really is whether we want a lynch @ Day 1 or not? If so, I reckon Varun has got to be the one, as it will also clear us out on Hedger. So shall we lynch him then?

Again, 'Varun has to be the one'.

Well Varun better explain himself. Till then:

Lynch: Varun

Its either Varun at this stage, or no lynch IMO. But I am still waiting for Varun to clear things up, and if he does, I wont hesitate to un-lynch him.

Again, Varun knowing his lack of experience.

Ah Well some had to go, and tbh Varun you were the most suspicous one. I reckon you should still watch the game, it will probably help you learn more about it. :)

Bye Varun, :wave
I like the emoticon too :p

'I like the emoticon'? See the excitement there. I posted the below quote and he hasn't really defended himself.

'Someone had to go'? BKB, I'm still very suspicious of you. I just feel Varun fell for the lack of experience here.
 
I don't approve of his Lynch of BKB, yet. There is no strong evidence to jump onto a lynch. After losing 2 townies already, and no substantial leads, we need to be more careful in our votes.
If User is voting for BKB, I want to wait and see what he has to say to defend himself.
Also, I am also not lynching you Ray, just a suspicion I had which I voiced.

To be Honest, User is in my suspect list as well, but probably not many would get what I noticed in the last night's write-up.

Could you tell me Ray, what would be an indirect attack if this is direct?
 
I've two people in my suspect list, BKB and Ollie. But, BKB is the strong contender and I think it is a good lynch.
 
FOS: User2010

Why is he going for Funknath when he is not there?

FOS: Abhas

Just had to.

Interesting BKB FOS Abhas for no reason early in the game. Maybe for fun.

Lynch: No-one

FOS: everyone :p

Bilal, Giving away you're mafia already?

An interesting choice of words for BKB

I find Shilpa very dodgy. Thats a double FOS on you now Abhas. :P


Yep, I agree someone has to go. Be it me or someone else, it will give us a shot. Also if we somehow tail a mafia under FOS they will all in one way or the other defend the person. Maybe not now but in the longer run it will help.

FOS: Varun

Quick to lynch in his first game? Could be a rookie mafia mistake?

I'm game for it.. who wants to be the sacrificial lamb? :sarcasm

Lynching someone off the first day might mean a double free kill for the mafia. And I believe being able to lynch off a mafia in the first day would mean incredibly stupid play from the other mafia members.
At this stage of the game, it's just impossible to know whom to trust.

Yeah, but it's correct that by FOSing others, we might judge their reactions..

I'll start off:
FOS: Varun

What 'companions' is he talking about? could be mafia, and being his first game, might have dropped the clue inadvertently.. !

Abhas added 2 Minutes and 58 Seconds later...

Edit: Lol! Bilal, for once we reached consensus, and have the same FOS.. I didn't see your post before posting, and was actually replying to Ollie..

Notice that he adds the edit saying that he didnt see BKBs post. This for some reason feels rather artificial to me.

Well Varun better explain himself. Till then:

Lynch: Varun

Its either Varun at this stage, or no lynch IMO. But I am still waiting for Varun to clear things up, and if he does, I wont hesitate to un-lynch him.

But BKB does not unlynch him. Could BKB be following someone who was voting for Varun as well (possibly his mafia partner)?

I don't approve of his Lynch of BKB, yet. There is no strong evidence to jump onto a lynch. After losing 2 townies already, and no substantial leads, we need to be more careful in our votes.
If User is voting for BKB, I want to wait and see what he has to say to defend himself.
Also, I am also not lynching you Ray, just a suspicion I had which I voiced.

To be Honest, User is in my suspect list as well, but probably not many would get what I noticed in the last night's write-up.

Could you tell me Ray, what would be an indirect attack if this is direct?

I dont mind you attacking me directly, but I am curious as to why you decided to address me on your list of suspicion immediately in your first post and then spoke about BKB in the next post. I mean when you are reading posts, I go through what is going on in the thread and address it along with my suspicions (If i have any).. But you spoke only about me in your first post? intersting.Plus can I detect a subtle defense for BKB?
maybe both of you are partners in crime? ;)
 
Last edited:
Very good point Ray. Actually, they might very well be deceiving us. Abhas has been defending Bilal not strongly but so much that he can be suspected. My lynch stays.
 
Interesting BKB FOS Abhas for no reason early in the game. Maybe for fun.

It was continuation of the rivalry we've had in a previous mafia game. Of course it was just for fun, and if you look at the first posts of the thread, you'll come across similar stuff from me as well.. that was BEFORE the game even started :)


An interesting choice of words for BKB

Well, he FOSed me, ofcourse I had to come-back.


Notice that he adds the edit saying that he didnt see BKBs post. This for some reason feels rather artificial to me.

Look at the post timings. For some reason, the live-thread thing doesn't work for me at times, and it did not work before I posted today's first post as well. I saw user's post, your post, and typed it up. the remaining 2 posts came u after mine was posted.
Also, I felt like adding the edit, because i wrote :
I'll start off:
FOS: Varun
I'll start off would seem odd if somebody before me had already started it.

But BKB does not unlynch him. Could BKB be following someone who was voting for Varun as well (possibly his mafia partner)?

BKB would need to answer that.

I dont mind you attacking me directly, but I am curious as to why you decided to address me on your list of suspicion immediately in your first post and then spoke about BKB in the next post. Plus can I detect a subtle defense for BKB?
maybe both of you are partners in crime? ;)

I did not mention the BKB thing because I felt I had a greater suspicion on you, rather than BKB. I'm not saying BKB's innocent, just that I don't have an opinion about him yet.

I'm still not sure about a few things, and before I clarify them, I would rather not make lynches on anyone.
 
maybe the psycho can't kill though. It seems like he didn't during the night otherwise the mafia didn't kill. Or maybe he just has a restriction on the killing.
 
Disappointed to see MaD out he could have helped us get a townie. What makes it worse is that he could have cured someone, and effectively we lost two townies last night.

Nice work there User, trying to rip me off for nothing that is concrete.


Having a quick go against Varun knowing that this was his first game. We all know he wasn't a mafia now.



Again, 'Varun has to be the one'.



Again, Varun knowing his lack of experience.



'I like the emoticon'? See the excitement there. I posted the below quote and he hasn't really defended himself.

All your quotes are saying the same things all over again. So I will try and answer them in one go, if you find I somehow missed something, then ask again and I will answer, I have nothing to hide.

You could say I have been aggressive on getting Varun lynched, but If you look at clearly at the posts you yourself quoted, then you will find all the answers there too. Like the second quote of mine you quoted, I did clearly mention that I was going either for no lynch or Varun at that stage, because there was no one else suspicious at that time. And I did open it up for debate, whether we plan on lynching someone or not. If you claim that I was quick to jump on Varun then look back, it certainly wasnt me, the first two to lynch were Abhas and MaD, and MaD, so generally all the townies were confused too. And the emoticon was @ Chewies statement:

oh sorry, I see you've fixed it now :p

I'm not sure whether I want to lynch Varun or not. He's been very suspicious but I don't know whether it warrants me getting rid of him. Though it would give me a nice opportunity to use the :wave smilie which is cool.

Yea I read your suspicion after my post, but I didnt see any reason to comment on it. It was just like FOS a random guy and you didnt give me a clear reason why you thought so at that time, so I couldnt really be arsed at spending time on that.

I have seen what you have done, waited along and let everyone lynch Varun, and then go on and try to bite us claiming that it was as if we knew he was townie. I still see nothing in the above part really that puts a significant question on me being a mafia, what I said was basically what everyone was thinking, to lynch or not to lynch, and if so, then who, and was it not obvious that Varun was the most suspectible guy at that time?

Gimme a few minutes and I will reply to ARays post as well.

BKB1991 added 15 Minutes and 59 Seconds later...

Interesting BKB FOS Abhas for no reason early in the game. Maybe for fun.



An interesting choice of words for BKB








Notice that he adds the edit saying that he didnt see BKBs post. This for some reason feels rather artificial to me.



But BKB does not unlynch him. Could BKB be following someone who was voting for Varun as well (possibly his mafia partner)?



I dont mind you attacking me directly, but I am curious as to why you decided to address me on your list of suspicion immediately in your first post and then spoke about BKB in the next post. I mean when you are reading posts, I go through what is going on in the thread and address it along with my suspicions (If i have any).. But you spoke only about me in your first post? intersting.Plus can I detect a subtle defense for BKB?
maybe both of you are partners in crime? ;)

Quote 1 & 3: yep for fun, if you read the thread at the early stages, me and Abhas have a friendly rivalry going on, and It was pretty clear that I was just playing around at that time to get the game started. So if you look into deciding whether I am mafia or not then i suggest you bang your head on the wall :p

Quote 4: Answered above (ie in my post answering Users queries)

Quote 5: I obviously didnt unlynch Varun my suspicion stayed, I said it before and I will say it again, I said we either vote to lynch or not. If we are voting and people already started to before I did mine, it was clear we were going to lynch someone, and It was obvious that Varun looked the most guilty at that time. And MaD made the same mistake too, he lynched Varun too, even though he was a townie, so I wasnt the only one confused.

And let me tell you that I aint me and Abhas arent ganging up, I am a vanilla townie, so I dont know whos in my team or not.

Atm I have no idea on who to go for. Any one with night roles should try and guide us.

One more time, If anyone has any direct questions please post em out and I will answer them, dont just put up quotes that doesnt really mean anything.
 
Yeah, that's it.

Any one with night roles should try and guide us.

Ah, indirectly wanting to know who is who so that your fellow members and you can kill them.

Anyone noticed Bilal is defending himself a bit too much? That is what I wanted to see. I am very sure he's the mafia.

User2010 added 6 Minutes and 11 Seconds later...

And MaD made the same mistake too, he lynched Varun too, even though he was a townie, so I wasnt the only one confused.
Actually, it was you were the one who confused the people.
 
Yeah, that's it.



Ah, indirectly wanting to know who is who so that your fellow members and you can kill them.

Anyone noticed Bilal is defending himself a bit too much? That is what I wanted to see. I am very sure he's the mafia.

User2010 added 6 Minutes and 11 Seconds later...


Actually, it was you were the one who confused the people.

Yea Sure you did. And had I not replied properly are in detail I would have been townie right? You are just seeing me as a mafia and everything I do, right or wrong will make you think I am mafia.
 
Ollie was the one who suggested lynching someone in the first place.

Yes, he did. But, that is what he has been doing in all the games (almost). I was suspicious of him in first place and am still but I'm more suspicious of BKB1991.

As User said, and I have stated, I have always been for lynching on the first day as if a no-lynch majority is reached it just gives the mafia a free kill in the night and the town don't get any chance to analyse any of the situations. Now we have managed to have a series of discussions picking up on people's posts and we could be closer to finding out the mafia.

Whilst everyone is questioning Abhas and BKB, I'd like to bring up the case of hedger_14. He has been relatively quiet (as have I, I had a football tournament when it started and am trying to improve my grades at school) and has only contributed a few thoughts to the actual discussion. He was the one who placed the hammer vote on Varun and that can always be a dangerous thing to do. He said that 'I have already placed suspicion on him and although I didn't really want to lynch him on Day 1' yet he had only pointed his 'worry' out once rather than actually interrogating him. Even though others might have, hedger never acted on any of his morals. He also only seemed to act as 'It's his first game', this just makes him a quick an easy target for a mafia player.

So, after this FOS: hedger_14
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top