Just a quick post with a couple of videos to exemplify an earlier post.
The first video shows what happens if you press the defensive trigger + L up + R down - you inside,outside or bottom edge the ball every time (granted the video only shows three balls, but it does happen every time), despite the bat being completely straight. Yes, the right stick controls shot direction so you'd expect the ball to go backwards, but playing a defensive shot shouldn't result in edging behind every time?!
Compare that to the second video, where the defensive trigger + L up + R up are combined and you get exactly the same shot (in terms of body and bat position) but it's a solid forward defensive shot, with the balls going forward.
I'm not saying this is a bug but basically if you're going to defend don't have R stick down because you'll edge it onto your stumps or behind every time!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43BQqJ17OQ4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7p-iCDoQLM