If Hoggard wasn't playing, I'd be all for him being given a go, but he's too similar or a very poor mans Hoggard. What has Sidebottom actually done to prove his class? Knocked over the West Indies at Headingley in April/May which are normally very bowler friendly and then one innings against India. I'm not just saying Harmison, I think he's the best option in that squad, but I think we'll miss a tall bowler a la Tremlett if not Harmison in this series. Sidebottom will not run through sides like Sri Lanka away from home. In New Zealand, he'll probably do well, but not the here and now.