Medical Mafia I - Endgame

[surendar]

Nice try, another misrepresentation. Nice team work.
Here, I see you following him.

Team work & nice try? I do not understand what you are referring to, but it is very clear that your reactions are the only suspicious activity that I can get among the people who have posted here until now.

This is either, you are blowing out something out of nothing or you know something and trying to deviate the town.

Here I see you backing him up.
Could you explain @surendar

I repeat - It was just a FOS & not even a lynch but you are blowing the loudest trumpet in the whole town now. It looks like you are trying to create a forehand defense that you are not the mafia even before someone is pointing you to be one & I find it very fishy indeed.

massive FOS: Yash


With Umair & Sulaiman appearing as neutral read for me in trying to get the game happenings, we would need more inputs from AP/User/Varun. 'We will wait for other's decision to finalize' or no inputs are equally suspicious too.

 

[Sulaiman7]

With Umair & Sulaiman appearing as neutral read for me in trying to get the game happenings, we would need more inputs from AP/User/Varun. 'We will wait for other's decision to finalize' or no inputs are equally suspicious too.

Simon has been neutral too but what Umair has posted makes no progress for us and we definitely need some output from the experts (User & Varun).

 

[Umair7]

Simon has been neutral too but what Umair has posted makes no progress for us and we definitely need some output from the experts (User & Varun).

And how much you have contributed ?? 0.00 % ??

 

[Gaurav_7]

Okay, I have had a fair bit of read and guess what, it's the same man again! Yash is such a magnet! Tbh, from whatever games I have played with him, he does tend to react a lot. You should be calm and post as to what is required. Posting stuff such as 'I will be replying only to sensible posts and not typical nonsense, buzz off' won't help. You seem to give up very easily. If you don't want to post then don't sign up for a mafia game.

Moving on, I don't think Yash is a culprit over here. He is just that magnet, that's what I feel. Simon is the one I am a bit suspicious of as he picked up only Yash as a target when most of the people who had posted wanted a no lynch. He has tried to corner Yash and knowing that he will give up very early, he has targeted the correct person. Just a thought on my part.

Also, I think we should not let freebies like Umair who do not post or add much stay in the game for long.

For now I think I will go for

Lynch: Simon

 

[AngryPixel]

We need input from other guys too before making a decision

Simon has been neutral too but what Umair has posted makes no progress for us and we definitely need some output from the experts (User & Varun).

And how much you have contributed ?? 0.00 % ??

Oh!!! the irony

You should not be asking this question when your own contribution to this thread was nil, nada, zero.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[hedger_14]

Hopefully no drunk either since he's dead.

Aren't I back from the dead now? :O

 

[Abhas]

No, you're perma-dead.

 

[Varun]

I really hate how despite not being entirely 'newbies' Sulaiman and Angrypixel make posts which have little impact on the task at hand itself. Filling in between the discussions doesn't help, nor does following others while not having much of an opinion. Not pinning them as mafioso, of course. Talking of that, Yash has attracted a lot of attention which apparently is how he plays. Simon has been subtly untown for me, using Yash early on to appear town. Surendar: null read. Swirler hasn't posted much but looks town until now. User looks town. No judgments final.

Umair2000 will definitely need some help being a newbie, but I like his confidence for now.

Also, this game relies heavily on players being cautious with their roles and not giving in to overconfidence. Please don't, and choose a balanced target. If things go awry, we can wind up with as many as three townpeople dead at night. Surely something we don't want.

 

[AngryPixel]

In.

Received.

Sorry I had a busy weekend and just got back from college. I have to go out right now, so my input might take some time.

Gave it a cursory glance. I won't be active enough to delve into long analysis so a little change of style. Yashdude has clearly attracted attention to himself, will need to go over his posts again. I'll be keeping a close watch on Simon..*something* doesn't right with him, but at this point it could just be intuition. Not concluding anything. We have 48 hours before thedon returns, so yeah lots of time.

I really hate how despite not being entirely 'newbies' Sulaiman and Angrypixel make posts which have little impact on the task at hand itself. Filling in between the discussions doesn't help, nor does following others while not having much of an opinion. Not pinning them as mafioso, of course. Talking of that, Yash has attracted a lot of attention which apparently is how he plays. Simon has been subtly untown for me, using Yash early on to appear town. Surendar: null read. Swirler hasn't posted much but looks town until now. User looks town. No judgments final.

Umair2000 will definitely need some help being a newbie, but I like his confidence for now.

Also, this game relies heavily on players being cautious with their roles and not giving in to overconfidence. Please don't, and choose a balanced target. If things go awry, we can wind up with as many as three townpeople dead at night. Surely something we don't want.

I really wish i had made that much contribution.
IMO you have not contributed any great deal. All you have done is beating round the bush in your post. You have repeated what has been said in previous pages. I'm actually surprised how can you so quickly decide who is town or who is not. This could easily be a ploy to win their trust and make sure they dont go for you when time to lynch comes.

FOS: varun

 

[Varun]

I really wish i had made that much contribution.
IMO you have not contributed any great deal. All you have done is beating round the bush in your post. You have repeated what has been said in previous pages. I'm actually surprised how can you so quickly decide who is town or who is not. This could easily be a ploy to win their trust and make sure they dont go for you when time to lynch comes.

This is exactly what I'm talking about. Half of what you said doesn't even make sense. I didn't even make a decisions ffs, only gave my initial impressions. How is that a ploy to win trust? And more importantly, who's?

----------

Okay, to emphasize my point, how have I repeated the same that has been said in the last few pages? And what bush I've been beating round?

 

[AngryPixel]

Only thing that doesnt make sense in this thread is your posts. On one hand you do exactly what other do and on the other hand you point to others who have done the same and question them. Nobody is sure of anyone's alignment yet. All people can do is discussion. All you contribute is by pointing fingers and give total BS reasoning.

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[AngryPixel]

Of all his post only one had something useful. In that he was questioning what have i contributed thats why i questioned his contribution.

----------

Almost nobody has nothing to say at this point because it is first day and a very long first day. So there will be people who point fingers and people who would rely to that. Everyone would have a different style of play. There would be people who would lurk and stay under the radar without ever getting questioned like a few in this game.

----------

If I were to make a comment on the above, imo it's pretty rich of AngryPixel to be sarcastic over Varun's activity when he hasn't added anything much himself. I mean, look at his posts:











He's been online most of the time I've logged in, and this is all he has had to add. Some replies to fingers of suspicion and some crappy sarcasm to go with. Really, Varun has at least said something useful instead of what you said, AP.

You seem to conveniently leave out the post where i questioned user for accusing suleman of less contribution when suleman asked to wait for other members to post. That was surprising comment considering that user himself had posted an exactly same thing a few pages back.

----------

Also Varun gets to BS for 4 posts and in his 5th post he comes on his mighty high horse and starts pointing out fingers at other people for their quality/lack of contributions and also in the same post try to judge who's townie or who's not. He's okay in your books. That is some reasoning you got.
Even i could have easily pointed out FOS at Yash to put more attention on him as he did but knowing Yash's previous games history i chose not to. Pointing fingers is fairly easier than having a discussion and reasoning rationally.

----------

For all intents and purpose you both could be mafia teaming up. Its a classic mafia strategy for one partner to blame other as mafia openly to gain the trust of townies. That is what varun has done here by accusing you of being mafia subtly in his post. Then you chose to defend him openly so that you appear to be townie as you showed literally no problem with him accusing you of being untown. This way you both appear as townie and now you can openly team up to take out some other townie by diverting the attention on them. Bravo

 

[Varun]

Nobody is sure of anyone's alignment yet. All people can do is discussion. All you contribute is by pointing fingers and give total BS reasoning.

For heaven's sake, I'm posting my initial impressions. Since almost everyone has posted before me, it just makes a lot of sense, doesn't it? I don't get you, where am I pointing fingers? Where am I giving BS reasoning?

This way you both appear as townie and now you can openly team up to take out some other townie by diverting the attention on them.

Wow, and now we're revealed. Shit. What a nice plan it seemed!

That was sarcasm. Let us stop with this now. To cool things off, I do not accuse Simon of being mafia - too early to decide. But his progression with Yash has been slightly untown-like. I guess @User2010 agrees. And putting pressure on him is a similarly logical progression. If he backs me up, it does not make me or anyone else for that matter immediately assumes him or me to be townies.