End Game Star Wars Mafia - End Mafia(Surendar) & Third Party (Fake Passport) Won

[Varun]

@Fake Passport give your opinion on El Loco, swacker, and zwarrior?

@El Loco do you think swacker is mafia? He has looked like one to me.

@surendar who do you think is mafia now?

My role is not to investigate. It is not a good idea to mention what my actual role is.

Did you claim a character though?

Asprin was a Star Wars Cop. Sorry for telling it before.

Okay well shit. Our cop is gone. -_-

 

[Till Valhalla]

Also don't worry about the deadline, if we are having a healthy discussion I will happily extend it.

 

[Villain]

FOS:
swacker surendar (post)
Villain El Loco (post)
Fake Villain (post)
Cpt Cremer Villain (post)
El Loco Fake (post)
surendar Villain (post) zwarrior (post)
zwarrior Villain (post) Varun (post)
Varun Swacker (post)

Based on the "I'll post my views later" + the ^ FOS

Lynch: Villain
@Jack Ryder

Unofficial Lynch count:
Swacker Varun
Villain RUDOLPH

I've posted way more than you already and I hope you do realize people have a life outside("I'll post my views later"). And your FOS calculation that you made makes no sense honestly, correct me if I'm wrong someone.

Firstly the obligatory joke
Lynch Rudolph

But in all seriousness I'm happy with a Villain lynch.
Unlynch
Lynch Villain

Just too eager to get a free kill? eh? Reason? You seriously don't have any.

Massive FOS: Fake Passport
Just too eager to lynch basically anybody. Notice how swiftly he followed Rudolph and he's 'happy with a Villain lynch'. lol
Another reason for going against him I feel is because he was too desperate to get AliB replaced and got his wife in the game replacing him probably. She could be his old 'boss' in the game for who he had to get the old Rud lynched, now Rudolph has that role and I guess the new name must be 'Villain'. I have no idea why nobody found it scummy when just for his sake he got the old Rud lynched without even caring about if he could be town which he was.[DOUBLEPOST=1500632121][/DOUBLEPOST]I'm still yet to go through the remaining posts, was forced to reply because of these two lynching me and I don't want to make it easy for them either way.

 

[Villain]

Why would a mod force a 'townie' to get another 'townie' lynched? Notice how frustrated he gets when asked about it, lol

 

[CremerCurrans]

Did you claim a character though?

At no point have I claimed to be just vanilla town, but my character description is a wookie helping to defend the base.

 

[Varun]

Oh right. So essentially, Chewie. I'm inclined to believe that.

 

[El Loco]

Well, the fact that asprin was a cop means I will have look at his play in a whole new light. However I did not see any indications that he had expressed any significant in-roads being made, at first glance anyway.

@El Loco do you think swacker is mafia? He has looked like one to me.

I assume you would like me to come round to your train of thought on the matter? He did seem pretty willing to lynch asprin, not sure if he got round to actually doing it. While asprin did turn out to be town, all the the things he took him up on were justified (the parrying of accusations with further questions) and I expressed similar things.
If you're going down the inactivity route, then well, Swacker is doing the exact same thing at the moment.

Here's the problem, you can find more reasons to incriminate people when they post. If they don't, then the single reason is just inactivity.
When swacker has posted, he hasn't analysed any other person's play specifically apart from asprin's I don't think. Other than that he has made passing comments about certain events such as 'Can you explain why you lynched him' or 'Didn't expect that to happen on Night 1'. Not exact quotes but the gist is there.
He did post something else which I kind of empathised with when he said he didn't want to post so much because he didn't to come across so aggressive early in the game. Could also be a red flag though depending how look at it. I can't find anything lynch-worthy myself though.

Why would a mod force a 'townie' to get another 'townie' lynched? Notice how frustrated he gets when asked about it, lol

There are instances where you get a 'lyncher and a lynchee' in the midst of a wider game with other roles like a sub-plot kind of thing, so it's not implausible. But the fact that he has spent more time dwelling on his own role than anything else is what's grabbing my attention at the moment.

 

[CremerCurrans]

Why would a mod force a 'townie' to get another 'townie' lynched? Notice how frustrated he gets when asked about it, lol

You seem to forget that roles vary in mafia games. He is obviously third party or mafia though.

Notice how frustrated he gets when asked about it, lol

In his defence you get pretty cranky when people bring up activity with you.

 

[Fake Passport]

@Fake Passport give your opinion on El Loco, swacker, and zwarrior?

On it now, coming hours will post.

Just too eager to get a free kill? eh? Reason? You seriously don't have any.

Massive FOS: Fake Passport
Just too eager to lynch basically anybody. Notice how swiftly he followed Rudolph and he's 'happy with a Villain lynch'. lol
Another reason for going against him I feel is because he was too desperate to get AliB replaced and got his wife in the game replacing him probably. She could be his old 'boss' in the game for who he had to get the old Rud lynched, now Rudolph has that role and I guess the new name must be 'Villain'. I have no idea why nobody found it scummy when just for his sake he got the old Rud lynched without even caring about if he could be town which he was.

And this is a primary reason I'm voting to lynch you. You are completely misrepresenting what has happened. Your either not paying enough attention that your a liability or you are anti-town and looking to prolong the confusion.

JR has said, and I have quoted enough times that I was given a whole new role that is INDEPENDENT of the old role.

Spoiler: And again...

@Jack Ryder - You willing to confirm that my two roles are completely independent and the whole lynch Rudi thing is done and dusted? This is getting ridiculous....

Independent.

You're tunneling me for an argument that simply does not exist. Yes I went after Rudi, of course I did, getting him killed of is was my mission. I was a 3rd Party.

Almost 100% literally your whole argument against me is invalid and has been invalidated by the game mod and what has happened, you're deliberately misrepresenting the whole thing...[DOUBLEPOST=1500639155][/DOUBLEPOST]

Why would a mod force a 'townie' to get another 'townie' lynched? Notice how frustrated he gets when asked about it, lol

And lets quote JR again:

His first condition had him getting Rudolph lynched for reasons I can't tell but him being Mod Killed his win con was snatched away hence I had to give him something different.

I was 3rd party.

 

[Fake Passport]

@Varun

Swacker - Being very chill and happy to let things happen and whoever said there isnt much substance isn't wrong when comparing him to old games. Im having trouble locking him as anything
El Loco - I liked that he was for a lynch day 1 to get things to odd numbers. As scum that would be a very easy post to not make. Alot of his posts, like THIS and THIS as examples seem genuinely town. Im pretty comfortable with Loco being town. I want to read his dialogue with surrendar together (just ISO'ing atm) to be sure.
Zwarrior - The inactivity is genuine, but that doesn't imply anything about his role. Hes very good on not offering much himself but asking alot of questions of others which I've always perceived as a slightly scummy action. I have this niggling feeling hes another 3rd party but dont know why...

 

[CremerCurrans]

Villain saying he is reading the thread and then disappearing is starting to bother me. It makes me think he's just checking in to reply to post accusing him of something instead.

FOS: Villian

If this continues I think I will join the others that have lynched him.

 

[Villain]

There are instances where you get a 'lyncher and a lynchee' in the midst of a wider game with other roles like a sub-plot kind of thing, so it's not implausible. But the fact that he has spent more time dwelling on his own role than anything else is what's grabbing my attention at the moment

Yes it is very much possible and I do agree with that.

You seem to forget that roles vary in mafia games. He is obviously third party or mafia though.



In his defence you get pretty cranky when people bring up activity with you.

I do know that mate, my point is he keeps changing now and then regarding his role and is he or will he benefit us in anyway if he actually is a third party?

On it now, coming hours will post.



And this is a primary reason I'm voting to lynch you. You are completely misrepresenting what has happened. Your either not paying enough attention that your a liability or you are anti-town and looking to prolong the confusion.

JR has said, and I have quoted enough times that I was given a whole new role that is INDEPENDENT of the old role.


You're tunneling me for an argument that simply does not exist. Yes I went after Rudi, of course I did, getting him killed of is was my mission. I was a 3rd Party.

Almost 100% literally your whole argument against me is invalid and has been invalidated by the game mod and what has happened, you're deliberately misrepresenting the whole thing...[DOUBLEPOST=1500639155][/DOUBLEPOST]
And lets quote JR again:


I was 3rd party.

Well you yourself created so much confusion regarding your role, first you said you had to get him lynched for your Boss before a townie gets lynched and you win if none of the townies get lynched. You confessed you are a third party now you say you were. I don't know what should I believe. So you're no longer a third party?

In simple words what I can get out of the game is that it probably is: Mafia vs Town vs Third Party.
Is it okay to keep him in the game for us town?

 

[Varun]

I assume you would like me to come round to your train of thought on the matter? He did seem pretty willing to lynch asprin, not sure if he got round to actually doing it. While asprin did turn out to be town, all the the things he took him up on were justified (the parrying of accusations with further questions) and I expressed similar things.
If you're going down the inactivity route, then well, Swacker is doing the exact same thing at the moment.

Here's the problem, you can find more reasons to incriminate people when they post. If they don't, then the single reason is just inactivity.
When swacker has posted, he hasn't analysed any other person's play specifically apart from asprin's I don't think. Other than that he has made passing comments about certain events such as 'Can you explain why you lynched him' or 'Didn't expect that to happen on Night 1'. Not exact quotes but the gist is there.
He did post something else which I kind of empathised with when he said he didn't want to post so much because he didn't to come across so aggressive early in the game. Could also be a red flag though depending how look at it. I can't find anything lynch-worthy myself though.

I'm just asking you because you're town in my books as of now. We don't seem to have a cop now, so we'll have to take risks sooner or later in the game.

 

[Varun]

Swacker - Being very chill and happy to let things happen and whoever said there isnt much substance isn't wrong when comparing him to old games. Im having trouble locking him as anything
El Loco - I liked that he was for a lynch day 1 to get things to odd numbers. As scum that would be a very easy post to not make. Alot of his posts, like THIS and THIS as examples seem genuinely town. Im pretty comfortable with Loco being town. I want to read his dialogue with surrendar together (just ISO'ing atm) to be sure.
Zwarrior - The inactivity is genuine, but that doesn't imply anything about his role. Hes very good on not offering much himself but asking alot of questions of others which I've always perceived as a slightly scummy action. I have this niggling feeling hes another 3rd party but dont know why...

I haven't played with swacker recently, but does his playing style in this game imply he is town?

I find Villain a little scummy too but it's Yashdude. You never know with him. :|

 

[Villain]

Villain saying he is reading the thread and then disappearing is starting to bother me. It makes me think he's just checking in to reply to post accusing him of something instead.

FOS: Villian

If this continues I think I will join the others that have lynched him.

I did the best I could using my phone, logged in using my PC now.

Also I got no clue what have I done to sound scummy? Just 1 guy lynching me from nowhere and the other one blindly following.